A few days following their wedding, Analise made the decision to undergo a new makeover. However, before doing so, she visited Countess Mary's residence to pose a very significant question. Seated at the table in Countess Mary's spell room, Analise inquired, "When my son Casey was born, is there a specific reason why he did not age faster than a typical child, given the fact that I possess fictional world DNA due to my grandfather Norman being brought to life from a horror movie?" Countess Mary replied, "The truth is, I was aware of Casey long before his birth. Your mother's spirit came to me after you discovered your pregnancy at the age of 12 and requested that I allow him to develop normally in your womb, knowing that you did not wish to terminate the pregnancy since it was not the baby's fault for what your father did to you. The spell also enabled Casey to grow up like any other child."
Analise expressed her gratitude to Countess Mary before departing to begin her makeover. She had scheduled an appointment for the same day at a clinic, where a friendly assistant welcomed her at the reception. Shortly thereafter, she was guided to the operating room, where she underwent a Brazilian butt lift and breast augmentation. The doctor, who mentioned that he was acquainted with her grandparents and that his parents were a witch and a warlock, inquired, "Is there a particular reason for this procedure?" Analise replied, "It is a gift for my husband, Michael Myers, as we recently celebrated our marriage." The doctor responded, "You have made a wise decision; my wife is Carrie White from the 1976 film 'Carrie,' and we have two young sons named Masin and Basin. In fact, everyone who works here is a witch or warlock." After examining her reflection in the mirror, Analise felt pleased with the outcome and expressed her gratitude to the doctor. Her makeover journey continued with two additional stops: first, she visited a hair salon where she opted for a shorter hairstyle that remained long enough to style, and then she proceeded to a tattoo and piercing studio. There, she had Michael Myers's name inked above her cleavage, a sun tattooed around her navel, and multiple piercings, including her nipples, belly button, nose, eyebrow, and clitoris. The entire process took an hour, aided by the tattoo artist's assistant. Upon returning home, Analise beamed as she entered to find Michael reading to their daughter. She requested that he follow her upstairs, and he handed their daughter to Rusty before ascending. Upon entering their room, Michael was taken aback by Analise's transformed appearance and remarked in his characteristic whisper, "Oh my gosh, you have added a significant amount of allure to your figure," while playfully adjusting himself. Analise responded, "I did it just for you." Michael then closed the door, approached Analise, and kissed her passionately. He lifted her and playfully tossed her onto the bed, where they made love. Analise attempted to stifle her moans, but the rapid movements of Michael Myers caused her to reach climax, prompting her to dig her fingers into his back and urge him to go faster and deeper. Downstairs, Mark, Rusty, and Mick glanced up at the ceiling, where Rusty remarked, "That's genuine love right there," as Lilly playfully swatted Rusty's hand and made her cute baby noises.
Five days later, Casey's adoptive parents transported him back to Wisconsin in their private jet to start his new life with his biological mother, Upon arrival, Analise warmly welcomed them on the front porch, and Casey rushed to hug her tightly. His adoptive parents also embraced Analise, while Michael, Mark, Rusty, and Mick brought Casey's belongings inside. Casey expressed to Analise that Michael Myers is his favorite horror movie character, and he was thrilled that he is now his stepfather. Lyle and Cherry, Casey's adoptive siblings who had been in Australia during the wedding, also joined them and fell in love with the land surrounding Analise's house. Analise assured Casey's adoptive parents and siblings that they can remain a part of his life, visit, and write to him whenever they want, and she expressed her gratitude for them adopting Casey. The adoptive parents were delighted with this idea and hugged Casey, while each of the adoptive siblings gave him kisses on the cheek. Afterward, they headed back to the airport, and Analise showed Casey his room, which he adored, but he was most eager to see his baby sister. Michael gently placed Lilly in Casey's arms, and he kissed her on the head, promising to be the best big brother ever. The dogs showered Casey with affectionate licks, and Sidney arranged a family dinner to welcome Casey home, where everyone fell in love with him. Analise smiled, excited to have her oldest child home, knowing that Lilly now had a big brother and that her mom and grandparents would be looking out for her children.