Mark, Rusty, Mick, and Casey embarked on a grocery shopping trip. Analise had granted Casey permission to purchase some candy at the store. While perusing the cereal aisle, Mark instructed Casey that he could select his candy from the candy aisle, which was situated three aisles away. After a few minutes, Casey returned holding two packages of gummy candy, but with a visibly uncomfortable expression on his face. Concerned, Mick inquired, "Casey, what's wrong?" However, Casey remained silent, and the group chose not to press him further. Upon returning home, Casey ran to Analise in tears. Alarmed, Analise asked, "What's troubling you, Casey?" Through his tears, Casey explained, "While I was in the candy aisle, three men, who appeared to be college students because their university shirts, approached me. One of them whispered to me, 'I bet your mama is a whore,' while the other two laughed and then they walked away." Hugging Casey tightly, Analise exclaimed, "Who would say such a thing to a nine-year-old?" Casey, still upset, replied, "They had their college IDs on them." He then provided Analise with the names of the three individuals: Mickey Bask, Joe Mitchell, and Cash Rolland. Analise subsequently conducted an online search and discovered that Mickey had made a public post about attending a party at an abandoned farmhouse. Determined to take action, Analise handed a printout of the information to Mark, Rusty, and Mick, instructing them, "Teach these three individuals a lesson."
Mark, Rusty, and Mick proceeded towards the derelict farmhouse with clear determination. Upon arrival, they swiftly identified their three targets. Mark resolved to confront Joe, Rusty opted to handle Mickey, and Mick chose to apprehend Cash. The party's boisterous atmosphere ensured that no one noticed when Mark, Rusty, and Mick discreetly abducted Mickey, Joe, and Cash.The trio carried their captives to another deserted farmhouse, where Rusty's semi-truck cab had been strategically positioned. Drawing inspiration from his notorious role in the "Saw" films, Mark was determined to inflict psychological torment on his target. When Joe regained consciousness, he found himself securely bound to a chair, with Mark standing ominously before him, gripping a rope. Mark directed Joe's gaze upward to an open animal trap suspended from the rafters. Mark began, "So you think you can demean a young boy by insulting his mother?" As he released the rope slightly, the trap descended, prompting Joe to scream, "Look man, I'm sorry!" Mark retorted coldly, "I am one of that boy's bodyguards." Joe pleaded, "Just let me go and I promise I won't harm him again." Unmoved, Mark responded, "I can't allow that." He then released the rope completely, causing the trap to clamp down on Joe's head, its teeth embedding deeply and ending his life instantly. In another part of the house, Cash's muffled screams joined Joe's before abruptly ceasing, as Mick, without warning, ruthlessly bludgeoned Cash's head with a hammer until he fell silent. Outside, Rusty, seeking to emulate a gruesome scene from "Joy Ride 3," opened the hood of his semi-truck, exposing the rapidly spinning motor fan. Despite Mickey's desperate pleas for mercy, Rusty declared, "If you use your mouth to hurt others, I'll ensure you can never use it again." He then forced Mickey's face into the fan, watching dispassionately as fragments of flesh scattered to the ground. As rain began to fall, Mark and Mick brought their victims' bodies outside and placed them beside Mickey. Confident that the rain would eliminate any traces of evidence, they climbed into Rusty's semi-truck and drove home. Upon their return, they found Analise and Michael Myers watching a news report about a massacre at the lake orchestrated by Analise and Michael the previous year. The secluded location had delayed the discovery of the bodies. "Those bodies must have reeked," remarked Analise, glancing at Mark, who confirmed, "The task is done." Analise acknowledged with a nod and removed the stew from the burner. They dined on the stew accompanied by cornbread, while the dogs enjoyed a mixture of dog food and raw lamb. Analise simultaneously fed Lilly while eating her meal. Following dinner, they retired for the night. Analise tenderly placed Lilly in her crib, kissed her on the forehead, and ensured Casey was comfortable in his bed, giving him a gentle kiss on the cheek and turning on his nightlight. Cujo, their loyal dog, lay beside Casey's bed. Analise and Michael Myers shared an affectionate kiss before drifting off to sleep, as the other dogs slumbered in the hallway.