The following day dawned bright and sunny. Analise made up her mind to seek revenge during daylight hours. After breakfast with Michael Myers and the dogs, she and Michael checked the next target on her mother's list - a woman named Sky Galling. Sky had intentionally ruined her mother's prom dress by spilling punch on it in the school bathroom. However, upon searching online, they discovered that Sky had passed away. They learned that she had four adult children - three sons and a daughter, all of whom owned a gas station/mechanic shop. Analise remarked, "Well, her kids will do." Subsequently, Analise and Michael Myers drove to town and parked near the gas station. Upon arrival, they located the breaker box at the gas station and turned off the switch labeled Monitor Room, disabling all the cameras. They opted not to wear masks to avoid attracting attention during the day. Analise decided to recreate a murder scene from the 2018 Halloween movie. She targeted the two brothers in the mechanic shop, while Michael went after the sister and another brother who were outside the building. Analise approached one of the brothers working on a car and fatally struck him with a tire iron. She then killed the second brother by hitting him on the head, causing instant death, and using a hammer to separate his lower jaw from his upper jaw. Meanwhile, Michael pursued the sister into the bathroom and assaulted her. Hearing her screams, the other brother rushed to her aid and attacked Michael with a crowbar. Michael remained undeterred by the blow from the crowbar, seizing the brother and forcefully slamming his head against the wall, causing him to release the crowbar. Michael then proceeded to repeatedly slam the brother's head against the bathroom stall until it gave way, and then threw him to the floor. Afterward, he lifted the sister by the neck, pressing her against the wall and snapping her neck. Analise and Michael meticulously removed any DNA from the bodies before retracing their steps, returning to their car, and driving home.
After Analise and Michael Myers arrived home, Analise marked Sally Galling's name off her mother's list. Suddenly, it started raining and thundering outside. Analise's aunt Sidney texted, asking "Would you like some BBQ ribs, potato salad, and vanilla cake?" Analise responded with an enthusiastic "Yes." While waiting for Sidney to arrive, Analise and Michael decided to watch the movie that made her grandfather Norman Bates famous, Psycho. Michael gently massaged Analise's ankles as she rested her feet in his lap. Later, Sidney arrived with dinner. Analise assisted her in taking the food to the kitchen. Sidney whispered to Analise, "I've been following the news lately." Analise replied, "Yes, but those people who were killed deserved it because they either wronged me or my mother. And believe me, there are many more people to seek revenge on." Sidney said, "That's my girl, always stand up for yourself and your family, no matter what." After hugging Analise goodbye, Sidney mentioned, "I made enough for the dogs too." Analise fed the dogs their portion of the meal, adding wet dog food, and then she and Michael ate while finishing watching the Psycho movie. They cleaned the dishes after eating and then retired to their room. Sidney texted to wish them goodnight and express her love for them. Soon, Analise and Michael Myers undressed each other and engaged in mutual oral pleasure. Analise then mounted Michael Myers, moving back and forth vigorously as he traced his fingers down her stomach, causing her pace to quicken. When she felt herself on the brink of climax, she sat above Michael's face, gripping the bed rest as he helped her reach climax through oral pleasure. She moaned as she released and watched in excitement as Michael licked her ejaculate off his mouth. They then got high and drunk, ensuring they didn't overdo it so they wouldn't be bedridden the next day. As the effects set in, they laughed and experienced hallucinations. Shortly after exchanging a kiss, they fell asleep, their dogs resting at the staircase landing, while Coco's spirit stood in the doorway, his eyes filled with joy at the sight of his content owner.