The following day, while examining the remainder of her mother's target list, Analise discovered that the last 8 individuals were all part of the same group that sexually harassed her mother 2 weeks before Analise was born. This realization angered Analise, especially knowing that her mother was pregnant with her at the time. Beside the names, her mother had written that Timmy Haynes was the leader of the group and that he should suffer slowly. Upon researching Timmy Haynes, Analise came across a post of his announcing a beer party with the boys at Jones Lake that night. Analise decided that she, Michael Myers, and their dogs would carry out the revenge killings that night.
While preparing a meal consisting of macaroni salad and potato wedges, Analise received a news alert on her phone, appreciative of her decision to subscribe for news updates. The notification revealed that the 4 siblings whom Analise and Michael had eliminated the day before had been discovered just an hour after the incident. A smirk appeared on Analise's face. As night descended, Analise, Michael Myers, and their dogs headed towards Jones Lake. Analise had brought along some specialized torture tools for Timmy. When Timmy wandered off to find a suitable spot to relieve himself, Analise ambushed and knocked him unconscious. While the rest of the group laughed and drank, Analise signaled the dogs with a whistle, prompting them to charge out of the woods and attack 5 of the men, while Analise and Michael Myers took care of the other 2 by beheading them with axes. Timmy Haynes awoke to find himself tied to a tree in front of his deceased companions. Analise revealed her identity to him and inquired if he remembered the incident where he and his friends had sexually harassed her mother. Slowly, she began inflicting cuts on Timmy's body, causing him to scream in agony. However, his cries went unnoticed as the lake was situated 5 miles away from the nearest residences. After inflicting numerous wounds on Timmy and saturating the ground beneath him with blood, Analise doused him in gasoline and set him ablaze. Following their departure from the lake, Analise and Michael drove to a late-night burger establishment, where they ordered cheeseburgers and fries for themselves and their dogs before returning home.
Once Analise and Michael arrived home, they fed the dogs two cheeseburgers, fries, and some leftover macaroni salad. Afterward, they both enjoyed their own meal. Following dinner, Analise and Michael retired to their bedroom, where they engaged in a passionate intimate moment. Analise ran her fingers along Michael's stomach as he expressed his admiration for her. They shared a deep kiss as their lovemaking intensified. Eventually, Michael climaxed, and they both experienced a sense of satisfaction. Subsequently, they indulged in some recreational substances, including cocaine that Analise had taken from one of the victims at Jones Lake. They became more altered than they normally did as they laughed at almost everything they said and eventually drifted off to sleep with the dogs asleep in the hallway.