It was New Year's Eve, and Analise eagerly anticipated the arrival of 2025. Analise sat at the kitchen table, breastfeeding Lilly, while waiting for Michael, Mark, Rusty, and Mick to finish getting ready for their grocery shopping trip. When Michael Myers entered the kitchen and saw Analise breastfeeding Lilly, he smiled and softly whispered, "I miss having your breasts in my mouth." Analise smiled back and replied, "They'll be yours again soon." Once everyone was prepared, they made their way to the store. Upon arrival, Analise placed Lilly's car seat in the basket, and as they strolled through the aisles, many people commented on how beautiful and adorable Lilly was. In the produce aisle, they encountered an everyday Karen who gave them a disapproving look and asked Analise, "Um, excuse me? Please tell me you know which of these older men is the father of your baby, because I would feel bad if you don't." Understandably upset, Analise was about to respond when Mark intervened, placing a gentle hand on her shoulder and telling the lady, "Please mind your business, KAREN." The lady quickly walked away. After purchasing the groceries and returning to the car, Mark inquired, "So, are we getting rid of the Karen?" Analise confirmed, "Yes, she had a school badge with her name, so we can look her up." Upon arriving home, Sidney texted Analise, "There's a New Year's party at town hall tonight, are you guys coming?" Analise replied, "Of course."
Two hours prior to the party, Analise sought out the impolite woman from the supermarket, remarking "Her name's Angel? Her name should be Karen." She then provided Mark with the address and instructed, "You, Rusty, and Mick, teach this lady a lesson about speaking rudely about my daughter." Mark responded with a simple "Yes, ma'am." Mark, Rusty, and Mick arrived at Angel's residence with Cujo and Shep. Mark knocked on the door, and when Angel answered, they forcibly removed her from the house, bound her hands behind her back, and transported her to an abandoned ranch, with the nearest resident being 5 miles down the road to ensure no one would hear her screams. They escorted Angel out of the car, and Mark questioned her, "So what gave you the right to be rude about a baby you don't even know?" Angel began to apologize and turned around, pleading for them to release her. Rusty, visibly irritated, struck her across the face, Mick untied her hands, and said, "If I were you, I'd start running." He then whistled for Cujo and Shep, who began chasing her. She attempted to flee across the vast yard, but she couldn't outrun the dogs. Cujo tackled her, and he and Shep mauled her until her screams ceased. Mick whistled for the dogs, they returned to the car, and they drove back home.
After arriving home, Mark, Rusty, and Mick changed into their finest party attire. Analise inquired, "Are you all prepared for 2025?" Mark replied, "Certainly, although we haven't been in the real world for very long, let's see what 2025 has in store." At 10:30, they made their way to the town hall after tending to the dogs. Sidney embraced Analise and requested to hold Lilly. Analise beamed at her aunt doting on Lilly. As 11:50 approached, everyone eagerly anticipated welcoming 2025. At 11:59, they commenced the countdown for the final 10 seconds of 2024, and as soon as midnight struck, everyone shouted "Happy New Year." Analise and Michael exchanged a kiss, while all her married relatives or those with partners shared a kiss with their significant others. Mark, Rusty, and Mick each planted a kiss on Lilly's cheek. Upon returning home, Analise placed Lilly in her crib, and they all retired to bed, eagerly awaiting the start of a new day.