Alex shivered when Montag took his legs to put his feet on his shoulders and raised his butt. The anticipation was killing him, if he felt that good with his fingers, he couldn't imagine how good it would feel with his cock. Alex wasn't even scared; he was just excited. Montag ripped open a condom package and put it on fast, then he drenched his dick on lube and positioned himself at his entrance.
Slowly, Montag pushed his dick inside and Alex felt his sphincter expanding around it. The sensation of being filled was overwhelmingly uncomfortable, he was expecting pleasure but what he felt was borderline pain. He tightened his muscles and Montag whimpered.
"Babe, you're gonna rip my dick off, relax."
"It fucking hurts"
"Relax, I need your body to get used to my size. I promise it will get better."
Alex tried to breathe through his nose, taking it slow to relax himself. It didn't matter about the amount of research he did; he wasn't prepared for the situation. Maybe he wasn't made for anal. Montag took his dick, which was resting limp against his pelvis and fapped him slowly. Alex tried to focus on the sensations awoken by his hand and not the burning pain in his butthole.
After a few minutes Alex's dick was once again hard and Montag kept on masturbating him while thrusting deeper into his body. Alex heard the soft moans of pleasure coming from Montag's mouth and forced himself to endure the experience; he wanted to make his lover happy. Once his dick was almost buried completely in Alex's body, Montag gave a final thrust and Alex felt a pang of pleasure.
"Do that again" he moaned and pushed his ass forward.
"Fuck, wait baby, you're still too tight. Give it a second."
Alex was desperate, he could feel his body getting comfortable with the intrusion and the bit of pleasure he had felt showed him there was more than just pain. Montag retreated a bit and immediately pushed again, rubbing that pleasurable spot deep inside Alex. He moaned loudly and held onto Montag's arms.
"Yes!" he cried and threw his head back "Yes, I love this."
"It feels so good inside you."
They soon found a slow, torturing rhythm that made Alex lose his mind. It was so good it was hard to believe moments ago he was feeling dreadful. The slapping sound of Montag's thighs hitting against his but cheeks should make him feel embarrassed, but it was weirdly erotic, as erotic as the wet sounds coming from where their bodies were joined.
"Montag, Montag, I wanna hug you."
His lover smiled and Alex felt his heart skip a beat. Montag repositioned himself, making Alex wrap his legs around his waist and leaned against his body. He was so close that Alex could see the drops of sweat on his brow, the blush covering his cheeks and the way he clenched his teeth to delay his climax as much as possible. Montag being overwhelmed by pleasure was a beautiful sight. Satisfied and wanting to be closer to him, Alex threw his arms around his shoulders and pulled him closer to kiss him. The kiss was messy, with their mouths opened, their tongues clashing and their breaths mixing, but Alex adored it.
Montag increased the pace of his thrusts and Alex felt the now familiar tingling sensation of an orgasm growing inside him. He knew Montag was close too because his moaning and groaning was louder and faster, and his hips were pushing deep inside him. Alex tightened his legs around his waist and pushed his ass to meet him halfway, their movements desperate. His orgasm took him by surprise, exploding like a ball of light turning his limbs into jelly. Montag whimpered against his ear and with a last deep thrust reached his own heaven.
"Motherfucker" Montag kissed his neck "You are so fucking sexy."
Alex laughed, panting, and pushed gently against Montag's chest. He couldn't breathe and Montag's weight over him wasn't helping. Montag understood and pushed himself up resting on his shoulders doing his best not to crush him. His green eyes held his gaze, they looked like a sunny day in the forest, all light and warmth. Alex smiled bashfully at him, feeling the heat creeping down his cheeks.
"I think you're aware that I liked it."
"Me too"
Montag chuckled and leaned to kiss him softly on the lips, the movement making his dick slide out of Alex's body. The lube seeped out of his ass and Alex felt the embarrassment conquering his body. He knew sex was full of humbling moments and it was ok to laugh and even be embarrassed in bed but as someone so self-conscious it was going to take a while to get comfortable.
"We need to clean up."
"Let me admire your post orgasm beauty for a couple more minutes."
"I feel sticky and sweaty."
"That means we did an excellent job." He kissed him behind the right ear and pushed himself up "let me help you get up."
They walked together to the bathroom; Montag kept an eye on Alex in case his limbs decided to give out. Just like last time, he sat on the toilet while Montag prepared the shower. They stood under the warm water for a couple of minutes before Montag used his hands to rub soap all over Alex's body, stopping occasionally, to kiss him on the lips, the neck, and the nipples. Minutes later, they were masturbating each other's cocks while kissing fervently. Montag turned Alex around and kneel to face his ass, without a second thought, he nibbled the skin just above his butt and slid his fingers between his cheeks to clean him lightly.
"It doesn't hurt, it just stings a little. You were really considerate."
"A herculean task. You were irresistible."
The warm wetness of a tongue against his butthole took Alex by surprise, but the shower was so small he didn't have anywhere to move. Montag gave him languid, deep licks and kisses against the throbbing skin, one of his hands pushing gently down on his lower back to keep him bent and the other masturbating him. The pleasure of the double attack was greater than his embarrassment and Alex let him have his way with his body.
Half an hour later they were cuddling in bed, Alex wearing one of Montag's oversized t-shirts and Montag naked. Too tired, too satisfied, and too comfortable to think about eating despite both feeling hungry. Alex rested his head on Montag's chest listening to the beating of his heart lulling him to sleep. He didn't want the night to end but every inch of his body felt like jelly and all he wanted was to sleep and dream about his lover.
"Thank you so much, I promise to never forget this night" Alex knew he was dangerously sincere when sleep took over his body "in my eyes, no one will ever compare to you."
Montag kissed his head and squeezed his arm gently but didn't say anything. Alex was too sleepy to feel embarrassed, so he just threw his leg over Montag's thighs and inhaled his scent deeply before falling asleep.
"I'm falling so hard for you" that's what Alex wanted to say.