(Sally's original story if you have not read it: http://fc03.deviantart.net/fs70/f/2012/077/c/9/creepypasta___play_with_me_by_kiki_hyuga-d4rd25t.html )
(The after story: http://kiki-hyuga.deviantart.com/art/Revenge-is-Sweet-329539721 )
Sally's Pov
"Sally," I hear a familiar voice mumble in my ear.
"Ngh, let me sleep Charlie," I mumble, cuddling deeper into the blankets.
"Sally you need to wake up," he says again.
"But Charlie," I mumble, glaring at my bear.
"Sally?" I hear a soft voice ask from the doorway.
"Miss Y/N?! Where am I?!" I ask, shooting up.
"Woah there," she says, rushing to my side when I gasp in pain.
"You need to stay down Sally," she says, pushing me down softly.
"What happened?" I ask.
"You don't remember?" she asks as she places a cool rag on my forehead.
"Umm," I mumble as images flash through my head.
"Mommy make them go away!" I cry out, clinging to Y/N's neck and burying my face in her neck as the tears flow down my face.
"Shh, it's okay Sally. They can't hurt you anymore," she whispers, holding me and rubbing her hand up and down my back.
"How did you find me?" I ask, looking her in her (e/c) eyes.
"I just happened to be walking home from buying groceries," she says.
"Thank you Miss Y/N," I whisper.
"Of course," she says ruffling my hair. "Oh I better get that."
"No don't leave me!" I exclaim when there is a knock on the door.
"Why don't you come with me?" she suggests.
"Okay. Will you carry me?" I ask her.
"Of course," she says, carrying me downstairs with Charlie.
"Hey Sam," she says, opening the door.
"He's mad I don't want to go with him," I whimper burying my face in her neck.
"Sals," Sam says. "Come on I'm taking you home.
"NO!" I scream, clinging tighter to Y/N.
"Sals don't do this,"he growls.
"Sam calm down. It's a typical little kid move. Anyone who didn't save her or was there when she woke up she automatically believes is mad at her," Y/N says, stroking my hair.
"But," Slender exclaims exasperated.
"Sam come inside," Y/N says stepping to the side.
I hear Slenderman sigh in exasperation and follow Y/N inside. I keep my head buried in her neck as I feel her carry me back upstairs.
"I'm not mad Sally," I hear him say.
"I just wanna stay here," I mumble as Y/N sits on her bed.
"Sally don't you think Y/N might me busy? What if she has a date or something?" he asks.
"Hahaha! Not likely," Y/N says laughing as she lays me down in the bed and pulls the covers over me.
"You're not helping," Slender mumbles, a small smile gracing his lips.
"Listen I don't mind if she stays here tonight. She's had a traumatic day and if she wants to stay here then she can stay," Y/N says, smiling at Slender.
"I don't want to inconvenience you," Slender says.
"It's not an inconvenience. Listen you're free to stay as well. It would just be better if Sally stayed here since she refuses to leave," she says.
"Very well," Slender says, finally giving in.
"Thank you Daddy!" I giggle, hugging him.
"I'll go get you some pajamas and you can rest in here with her," Y/N says, smiling and leaving the room.
"Sals why are you so stubborn?" Slender asks, stroking my hair.
"Because I can be," I say smiling.
"What's so special about her?" he asks me.
"Everything," I whisper, yawning and falling asleep.
Slender's Pov
"Everything," Sally whispers before yawning and falling asleep.
"Everything huh?" I mumble tucking her in.
"Here you are. It should fit they were my dad's," Y/N says, handing me a pile of pajamas.
"Thank you Y/N. Again I'm," I start to say.
"Sam it's no big deal. Besides it's nice to have some company," she says smiling.
"Where are your parents?" I ask her.
"They work a lot and are out of town at the moment. Good night Sam," she says smiling and closing the door behind her.
I admit Y/N is an interesting human but I feel as if there are secrets that she has. Deep dark secrets that she tries really hard to hide, and I want to know what they are. Sally may trust her but I don't. I've already done a background check and the information on her is extremely minimal. Who exactly are you Y/N? I ask myself as I quickly change and crawl under the covers with Sally, holding her close as she snuggles with Charlie into my chest. I still remember the day I found Sally and it is a day I would rather forget. I am thankful she doesn't remember but I know there are times when she has nightmares about it. Those nights lead to me holding her and watching over her all night, making sure the nightmares stay away.