Everyone is back and we're ready to roll. Monica never left the couch.
"Like this?" Monica asks, as she takes up the position I mentioned.
"Exactly, Monica," I answer, my throat dry despite the beer as I stare at her widespread legs. I glance over to see the other girls almost as enthralled as I am and it dawns on me they have probably never seen another girl's pussy, at least not displayed like this.
I sit on the edge of the couch and lean down towards her wide-open pussy. Fuck! This is a fucking wet dream come true if ever there was one. With everyone watching, I jump on this opportunity to distract Monica from how intimate I'm getting by slipping into lecture mode.
"The pussy can be sexy in so many different ways," I explain, while running my fingers through Monica's coarse pubic hair. "It's not just about how it looks but how it feels, smells and tastes. I'll need to use all of my senses to determine who has the sexiest pussy." Monica's pussy lips are glistening with her juices even before I touch her.
"Seen a lot of pussies, have you, Max?" Anna asks with a slight smirk.
"I'm about to see four more," I answer for lack of a better response. Before she can respond, Yelena changes the subject, sort of.
"You're going to taste us?" Yelena asks anxiously. I can't tell if her anxiousness is excitement or nervousness but I notice Monica opening her thighs a little wider.
"Don't worry," I reassure them. " I'll be using my finger to get the taste sample." As I'm talking, I slide my finger across Monica's pussy lips, dipping the tip in just enough to get it wet.
"Oooooo," Monica moans as my finger slips between her dark pussy lips, exposing the slick pink interior.
"You have a lovely pussy, Monica," I tell her, leaving the tip of my finger resting inside of her while I bend down towards her pussy. With my face inches from her aroused pussy, I take a big whiff and suck in her incredible aroma. I watch the girls turn up their noses as I push mine closer and breathe in her smell again.
"Damn, you smell like sex!" I tell her. "You girls might not think so," I continue my quasi-lecture to the other girls, "but a woman's smell is a major turn on and why so many guys enjoy going down on their girlfriends."
"Do you go down on Gwen?" Kamala asks and I'm not sure why she's brought up Gwen.
"Who's Gwen?" Monica asks as her pussy pulsates around my fingertip and she arches her back to suck it in farther.
"His girlfriend," Kamala answers, looking at me like she's still waiting for an answer.
"Which of you has had your pussy eaten?" I ask the group in an attempt to sidestep Kamala's question. The girls look at each other and only Anna raises her hand.
"I have," Monica says, "but not by someone as experienced as you," she smiles teasingly.
"Show us," Yelena says. "Show us how you do it, Max."
"I don't know," I answer, wondering why I'm even resisting this invitation.
"Why not?" Anna asks.
"Oral sex is usually a prelude to sex or a substitute for sex. If I start licking Monica's pussy without giving her an orgasm, that's not fair. I'm just going to frustrate her. And I'm not really sure we should be turning this sleepover into an orgy," although it is pretty damn close already.
"Same question, why not?" Anna retorts. "You have four, or maybe three," she hesitates as she glances at Kamala, "very willing girls, am I right?" she asks of her friends. Monica and Yelena nod while Kamala looks contemplative. "You appear to be somewhat aroused by us," she laughs as she stares at my fully erect cock.
"We're all over 18, Max, consenting adults," Monica adds. "Just do it!" I look to Kamala for direction but she just shrugs like it's completely up to me.
"What do you want me to do?" I ask to no one in particular. "Just taste her a little or eat her pussy through a full orgasm?" Okay, is this the weirdest fucking conversation you've ever heard? It is certainly the most bizarre conversation I've ever had. It's like I'm putting it to a fucking vote. While the girls all look at each other, my phone buzzes in my shorts pocket.
Kamala grabs my shorts off the floor and extracts my phone from the front pocket. "It's Gwen," she says, holding the phone up so I can see.
"Let it go to voicemail," I answer, raising a smile from my little sister. Shit. What am I doing here with these high school girls? Eighteen or not, they're all too young for me. Before we can get back to what we were doing, the phone buzzes again.
"It's a text," Kamala says, reading it out loud, "I'm sorry, let's talk." She raises her eyebrows at me. I should text her back but one of my fingers is in Monica's pussy and they're about to tell me how long I should eat her.
"Text her that I'm sorry, too. Helping my sister with something. Let's talk tomorrow."
"You want me to text all that?" Kamala asks with a scowl. "Why don't I just tell her you're eating our pussies and can't come to the phone right now?" Her thumbs are flying across the screen before I have a chance to answer. The other girls laugh hysterically as I wonder what the fuck Kamala actually texted.
"You have a girlfriend?" Anna asks, sounding somewhat disappointed.
"We fight a lot," I answer, not sure why I even said that.
"Why are you here with us if you have a girlfriend?" Yelena wonders aloud.
"Anna has a boyfriend," Kamala counters, "and she's buck naked waiting to get her pussy eaten." I guess that settles the question about whether it's just Monica's pussy I'm going to be diving my face into.
"Can we get back to this?" Monica asks. "Will you eat me to an orgasm, Max?" she asks quietly. I gently pull my finger from between her moist pussy lips, push her legs up towards her shoulders and lower my mouth to her charcoal black labia.
"Ooooo yeah!" Monica moans as I flatten my tongue and lick from just above her puckered asshole to her clit.
"The secret to good pussy eating is the tease," I tell my nearly hyper audience. "Anyone can dive in and tongue-fuck a pussy but the intense arousal that will produce an orgasm is a different art form."
"Will you shut up!" Monica says, pulling my face back to her pussy. I take the hint and start licking all around her thick outer labia, tasting her succulent juices while I tease her by avoiding direct contact with her pussy.
The other girls move in for a closer look as Monica moans and murmurs in response to my machinations. I hear a gasp from one of the other girls when I lick around Monica's crinkled asshole.
"He's licking her ass," Yelena whispers. "Yeww!"
"Ask Monica how it feels," I say over my shoulder to Yelena then push my tongue into Monica's pussy and suck her inner labia into my mouth.
"Oh fuck!" Monica cries when my tongue brushes against her clit. "It... um... felt weird to have him... you know... lick my butt, but I really liked it," she reassures her friends.
"Oh yeah! Oh Max!" Monica screams as I suck her clit into my mouth and gently tap it with my tongue. Sliding a finger into her pussy, I piston it in and out while I devour her clit with my mouth. Monica is rocking all over the couch now, moaning and crying words of encouragement.
"Oh! Oh! Just like that! Oh yeah! Oh Fuck!" she pants, as she grabs my hair and humps her pussy against my face.
"Damn!" Anna exclaims. "He's going to make her cum!"
Of course, I am. That's the whole idea.
"I'm getting soaked just watching them," Kamala says, causing me to conjure up images of my sister's juicy pussy as I attack Monica's with renewed vigor.
"Damn... right... I'm...going... to... cum!" Monica has abandoned any inhibitions she might have arrived with and is unabashedly fucking my face with her pussy. Her fingers are entwined in my hair and she's rocking so hard against me that I'm having trouble breathing. Just when I think she might suffocate me, I go in for the kill shot, gently biting her clit between my teeth as I push my tongue hard against the tip of it.
"OhhhhhhhhHHHHHH FUCK!" Monica screams as the floodgates open and pussy juice gushes from her wide-open fuck hole. Her clit is too sensitive now and she pushes my face away and tries to close her legs. I pull my finger from her pussy as I block her thighs from closing so I can lap up her freely flowing cream. Fucking delicious!
I raise my eyes to see her face but they stop at her luscious breasts and her dark nipples, thick with arousal. I reach for those black nubs, pinching them between my fingers as I continue to devour her soggy pussy.
"Unfuckingbelievable!" Anna says as I release Monica's nipples and lower her legs down onto the couch. She still hasn't caught her breath as I sit back and wipe my face with my arm. The other three girls are flush with arousal, their legs pressed tightly together as they watch their friend recover from her orgasm.
"I need to wash up," I say to no one in particular as I stand up and head to the bathroom. Fuck! One down, and two to go. My face brightens into a wide smile. Or maybe three to go... we'll see.
I wash my face and hands, brush my teeth and get myself presentable for my next contestant. This has turned into the wildest night of my life... and to think it's with my sister and her friends! As crazy as we got at some of my college parties, I've never experienced anything like this.
As I walk back to the living room, Monica is giving the other girls a detailed description of how she felt during the whole thing. I listen for a minute before I go in.
"No one has ever eaten me like that!" she says. "The guys I know just stick their tongue in a few times and then want to fuck." She lets out a big sigh. "Thank you, Kamala, your brother really knows what the fuck he's doing!" This seems like a good time to make my entrance.
"I'm all cleaned up and ready for my next contestant," I smile as I walk over to the couch.
"Thank you, Max," Monica says as she stands up and gives me a hug. I squeeze her ass checks and hold her against me, my hard cock pushing into her stomach.
"The pleasure was all mine," I tell her.