"He's my brother!" Kamala answers, as if that explains it all. "He'll be here if I need him later." Okay, I wasn't expecting that response.
"But why wait?" Anna asks. Good question.
"Anna," I admonish her. "It's her decision, right?" Anna shakes her head like it's the stupidest discussion she's ever heard. I turn my attention to my sister's pussy. She hasn't spread her legs as wide as the others did but her pussy is still on full display. And what a damn fine pussy it is.
Although medium thickness, her labia is larger than any of the others. I didn't see it when she was standing up but it overhangs almost twice as far as any of the other girls. Shit. I want to suck those pussy lips into my mouth and just gnaw away at them. I know I could drive her absolutely crazy!
"Your pussy lips are to die for, Sis," I tell her as I pinch one side between my fingers and slide them around on the slippery surface.
"Hmmm," she murmurs as a shiver runs through her body.
"I like the way you've trimmed it too," I tell her as I move to the other side of her pussy and do the same thing with her other lip.
"Let's see how you smell," I smile as I bend closer to her exposed pussy and take a big whiff. Holy fuck! My cock swells at the erotic scent of my sister's pussy. I could get high on this stuff. I take another big sniff as I insert my finger into her pussy to get some juice to taste.
"Just lick it once," she says so quietly that I'm not sure that's what she said. I look up at her and she just nods her head. If I'm only going to get one lick, I'm going to make it a good one.
I lift up her thighs and push them farther apart, exposing both her ass and her pussy. With a thick coat of saliva on my tongue, I slowly rim her asshole before gliding it up along that very sensitive area between her ass and her pussy. Then, pushing it between her lips, lingering as I dive deeply into her hot love canal. Sucking in some of her delectable cream, I press my tongue against her clit and swirl it around several times.
When I come up for air, Kamala is shivering with arousal. She has her eyes closed and her head back and I savor her persistent flavor inside my mouth as I await further direction.
"Again," she finally says almost under her breath. I repeat nearly the same route only this time I suck her clit into my mouth and push two fingers into her pussy.
"Ohhh! Mmmmm," Kamala moans as I work my magic on her red hot pussy. She's so ready for a climax that no teasing is necessary; I just piston her hole with my fingers while I assault her clit with my mouth. In short order, she is crying out her need for release.
"Max! Damn you! Fuck you! Oh God! Right there! Oh Yeah!" She arches her back, grabs my head with both hands and nearly suffocates me as her pussy explodes in orgasmic bliss. Her pussy gushes hot liquid honey while her body convulses in pure pleasure. I stay with her until her orgasm subsides, then pull my fingers from her still quivering hole and lick all around her wide lips.
"See, I told you," Anna says, stroking Kamala's hair as she strives to catch her breath.
"You were right," Kamala nods. "It was amazing!
"And the winner of the sexiest pussy..."
"I haven't even caught my breath yet!" Kamala protests. "Give me a second."
"Okay," I smile. "I'll go clean up." I linger, watching my sister's chest heave as she catches her breath.
"Go already," she says, shooing me away.
Damn! I just ate my sister's pussy! Instead of feeling ashamed, I find myself wishing we were alone. I splash water on my face and stare at myself in the mirror. Pervert!
"Are we ready now?" I ask my sister when I return from the bathroom. She just nods but returns my smile with that 'just fucked' glow all over her face.
"The sexiest pussy award goes to... drum roll, please... Yelena!" Her smile is absolutely radiant. "With your rose petal pussy lips, sweet, exotic scent and feathery blonde hair, you're going to have guys lining up to serve your every need!"
"Thanks, Max," Yelena says. "But not with these tits." Fuck! I never thought she was so self-conscious about her tits.
"You're wrong, Yelena," I admonish her. "You've got great tits. I admit guys like cleavage but your nipples are the end all of nipples and your ass - don't even get me started on your ass again, plus you have the sexiest pussy in the room. Wanna fuck?" I didn't actually say that last part but I was thinking it. I would love to drive my hard cock into that tight, possibly unused pussy!
"If you say so," she smiles.
"So who wins overall?" Monica asks. Good question.
"You are all sexy as hell. No guy could be disappointed with any of you." I look around at the naked girls, bathing in their post orgasmic radiance. Shit. I just ate out four different girls and my cock is so hard I can barely think.
"The winner, Max?" Anna prompts me.
"The sexiest girl in the room with best combination of attributes.." I pause and look at each of these naked beauties. "By a very narrow margin, mind you is... Kamala, my baby sister!" I point my finger at Kamala as I await the complaints from the other girls but they just start whooping and applauding my choice.
"What does the winner get?" Kamala asks, mischievously.
"You get to take care of that," Anna says, pointing to my erection.
"What?" Kamala responds incredulously. "Wait... no."
"He's been hard for nearly two hours, don't you think he deserves some release after eating all this pussy?"
"Yes, but..." my sister stammers but Anna cuts her off.
"You're the one who said you could deep throat a real cock and wish one was here."
"But he's my brother," Kamala retorts.
"Who just ate you your pussy!" Yelena jumps in to counter Kamala's argument. "Seems to me you owe him one."
"One of us needs to do it," Monica says, stepping closer while she looks questioningly at my sister. Fuck! Four naked teenage girls arguing over who's going to suck my dick? Life should always be this tough.
"Think you can deep throat him?" Anna challenges while looking appreciatively at my cock. I'm not built like a porn star. I have a normal width cock that is maybe a little longer than average. Not much different in size or shape than the rubber dildo that's still sticking up from the coffee table.
"Of course, I can do it," Kamala says looking directly at me. "Max?" she says, raising her eyebrows questioningly.
"It's your party, Sis," I answer, scooting forward on the couch so whoever sucks me off has easy access. None of these girls would be a consolation prize but I find myself hoping it will be Kamala. "Your party, your rules."
"You know you want to, Kamala," Anna urges her on. My pulse is racing as my little sister kneels on the floor between my legs. The other three girls gather around as Kamala hesitantly reaches for my hard-on.
I swear that until tonight I had never harbored any sexual feelings towards my sister. I am happily in a relationship with Gwen, well mostly happy. Kamala has always just been my annoying little sister. But when I look between my legs and see her big brown eyes staring up at me as she wraps her fingers around my solid cock, my mind blots out every other girl I've ever known.
Staring right into my eyes, she tries a few tentative strokes up and down the length of my shaft before rising up on her knees and moving her mouth towards the domed head. She questions me with her eyes just before her lips reach me. I silently nodded as she plants a kiss on the tip of my dick.
Based on what I heard and saw earlier, Kamala is no stranger to blowjobs. Instead of diving right in, she teases me by licking up and down the sides of my shaft, coating the length with saliva. It is so fucking erotic the way she maintains eye contact with me the entire time.
With one hand gently cupping my balls she licks all over my cock, concentrating her attention on the sensitive underside of it just below the head. Even with three other naked girls to look at, I couldn't break eye contact with my sister if I tried... and I didn't try. With our eyes locked on each other it's like no one else in the room exists.
Finally, pulling my cock down towards her she slides her lips over the head while her hand strokes up and down my shaft. I emit a low moan from deep in my throat as she corkscrews her hand up and down my shaft and slides her lips farther down my hard dick.
Damn! My sister knows her way around a penis. This is already one of the best blowjobs I've ever had and she's barely gotten started. I'm not sure how much is due to her skill and how much is due to the fact that she's my sister. Either way, I'm not complaining.
Kamala continues stroking my cock while she takes a deep breath. I know what's coming next and apparently so do her friends.
"Here she goes," Anna says, breaking the spell between Kamala and I. Fuck! I wish they would just watch quietly. Doesn't matter though once Kamala's mouth engulfs my cock and she slides her lips about two thirds of the way down, I don't care anymore!
"She's doing it," Yelena marvels as she leans in for a closer look. I reach up and pinch Yelena's nipple just as I feel my cock enter my sister's throat. Fuck!
Kamala pulls back along my throbbing shaft and continues stroking my cock as she gasps for breath.
"You didn't hit his pubic hair," Anna announces.
"What?" Kamala, yells at her. "He was in my fucking throat!" I can vouch for that.
"True deep throating means you take his entire cock," Anna says, sassily. "Your lips have to hit his pubic hair." I'm not sure where she's getting her rules but it's an interesting one.
"And you can do that?" Kamala asks?
"Yup, sure can," she answers.
"Fine. Go ahead!" Before I know what's happened, Kamala has moved out of the way and Anna is kneeling between my legs.
"I've wanted to do this all evening," she says, smiling as she sucks the head of my cock into her warm mouth. Yelena is sitting on one side of my legs and Kamala on the other watching intently as Anna pumps my cock into her mouth, taking it deeper with each stroke.
With the other girls watching so closely, I feel more like a biology experiment than getting a great blowjob. And it is a great blowjob! My sister knew what she was doing but Anna is the blowjob queen. She's only at it a few minutes when I feel her loosen the muscles in her throat and my dick slides down. She actually swallows my cock! I can feel her swallow as the head enters her throat. Fuck! I could almost shoot my load right now but Kyle is pressing my cock deeper into her throat.
"She did it!" Yelena announces as Anna's lips brush against my pubic hair. Damn! She has my entire cock in her mouth... and throat! She holds it there, glancing up at me before she starts the slow withdrawal. My cock is about to burst, especially with the next surprise.
"Can I try it?" Yelena asks as Anna gasps for breath. Anna literally hands her my dick. Shit! Am I just going to get passed down the line? Not that I'm complaining. Any guy would sell his mother to be where I am.
"I've never done this," Yelena admits as her small hand encircles my hard cock and she feeds the head into her mouth. "Mmmmm," she moans around my erection as her hand strokes the length of my saliva-coated shaft. This girl has been watching her friends.
"Don't try to take too much your first time," Monica advises her. Monica has moved up to where Yelena was sitting and Anna is over beside Kamala. Even just the head in your mouth feels great for the guy. Isn't that right, Max."
"Absolutely!" I agree as Yelena bobs her head up and down on my cock.
"Use your tongue to lick the underside of the head," Kamala adds her two cents and this starts feeling more like a training session than an orgy. Not that I mind. It's quite a turn on to be a girl's first blowjob. Makes me wonder about the state of her vagina. Surely she can't really be a virgin.
"Now you've got it," Monica says encouragingly. "How does that feel, Max?"
"Fucking amazing!" I answer and Yelena's eyes reflect what I interpret as a proud smile.
"How about now?" Monica asks seductively, as she glides her fingernails over my balls.
"Damn!" I cry as I feel my balls tighten. "I'm going to cum!" I shout. Yelena's eyes get really big and she slows her movements.
"Don't stop!" I admonish her.
"Want me to take it?" Monica asks.