On December 31, 2024, news broke on X that discussions are underway for a potential trilogy fight between Katie Taylor and Amanda Serrano, set to headline at the iconic Croke Park in April 2025. The event is reportedly being co-promoted by Matchroom Boxing and Most Valuable Promotions.
This announcement has sparked plenty of debate among fans. Amanda Serrano has lost to Katie Taylor twice, which makes the idea of a trilogy somewhat unconventional in boxing. Typically, trilogies are reserved for rivalries where both fighters have secured a victory. However, there's no denying the exceptional quality of their previous two bouts, both of which were awarded Fight of the Year honors. Achieving such a feat twice is a rare accomplishment in the sport, showcasing the unparalleled talent and heart of both fighters.
Still, it raises the question: does a third fight make sense? It's reminiscent of the idea of Usyk vs. Fury having a trilogy if Fury had already lost twice. While some argue Serrano deserved the nod in one or both of their fights, the reality is that boxing decisions lie in the hands of the judges, not the fans. As it stands, Taylor has come out on top in both encounters, cementing her legacy as one of the greatest female boxers of all time.
If this trilogy does happen, it's undeniably a win for the fans. Taylor and Serrano bring out the best in each other, delivering edge-of-your-seat action every time they step into the ring. However, the big question is whether the third fight can match the magnitude and excitement of their first two clashes. The bar has been set incredibly high, and there's always the risk that the magic of the rivalry might not translate a third time.
That said, the setting of Croke Park—a dream venue for Katie Taylor—adds an extra layer of significance. Fighting in front of a packed crowd in her home country would be a career-defining moment, and Serrano's determination to avenge her losses ensures that this fight, if finalized, will carry plenty of drama and intrigue.
Whether or not this trilogy becomes a reality, the rivalry between Katie Taylor and Amanda Serrano is already one for the history books. If we do get a third installment, fans can look forward to another thrilling chapter in this legendary saga. Personally, I can't wait to see how this unfolds.