Judging from his expression.
It was as if Shen Yao had entered his trap. Those views that he had advocated before.
The purpose is to make the other party throw out the argument of stealing the concept, and then he will fight back with this argument.
And we are back to the origin of the problem.
The purpose is to disrupt the opponent's rhythm.
As a result, the opponent's rhythm is disrupted without them realizing it and gradually step on the landmines they are going to plant later!
Once the other party starts to make inconsistent statements, their chances of winning will increase again.
Although they have learned that a big shot from above has intervened in the lawsuit and is on the other side, the chances of winning this lawsuit for the Tencent Legal Department are basically zero.
However, Tencent's legal department, which has no way to retreat and can only fight back, will not just sit back and accept its fate.
As long as they can defeat the Royal Court Law Firm in this trial, even if the intervention of the bigwigs above cannot change the final outcome of this lawsuit, as long as they can defeat the Royal Court Law Firm, then the final outcome will naturally not appear in this trial...
This is what it means to die standing!
If the first trial ends with a loss, that is not called dying standing, that is called shame, a shame of falling from the altar to the mortal world!
This is unacceptable to all members of Tencent's legal department!
But how would they know
This law firm, which they did not take seriously, started studying their Tencent's legal department from the first day of its establishment!
The goal is to be able to step on the other person and rise to the top in one leap when the opportunity comes one day!
Let's put aside the fact that we have been studying the legal department of Tencent.
For this lawsuit, the Royal Court Law Firm worked tirelessly for half a month before getting Ye Chen's commission. After being commissioned, they did not dare to be careless. Until the opening of the trial, the entire law firm was still preparing for this lawsuit around the clock!
so.
In other words, Shen Yao didn't know what the other party was thinking, otherwise she would definitely shake her head and say you guys took it for granted.
As for the tricks and routines that Tencent's legal department would use in court, Huangting Law Firm has already simulated them thoroughly.
Including the questions raised by the other party at this time.
These were also envisioned at the beginning of the Royal Court Law Firm!
Facing the other party's sneer.
Shen Yao shook her head lightly.
"Regarding how Nirvana plagiarized 'Reincarnation', I have already provided evidence in the materials submitted to the jury. However, since you want to know, I believe the jury will satisfy you!
As Shen Yao finished speaking.
On the judgement seat.
The members of the jury looked at each other and nodded.
Ultimately, the presiding judge decided to project the materials.
Material on the projection.
It was indeed proved in detail by the Royal Court Law Firm. At first glance, it is absolutely unreasonable to say that Nirvana did not plagiarize Samsara.
But it doesn't matter, after all, Nirvana is not a copy of Samsara,
I'm afraid everyone who knows the two games knows the answer.
Therefore, Tencent's legal department never cared about the so-called evidence from the beginning to the end.
What surprised them was that Shen Yao actually gave up the method of verbally presenting evidence and chose to speak through material evidence from the jury.
This undoubtedly cut off their idea of taking advantage of the other party's mistakes and contradictions in their arguments to increase their own chances of winning.
"Are these evidences sufficient? Are they enough to prove that Nirvana has committed extremely bad plagiarism?" Shen Yao said.
"It is undeniable that based on these evidences, there are indeed similarities between Nirvana and Samsara. However, based on the explicit provisions of domestic laws on intellectual property rights, can you tell me which provision of the intellectual property law has been violated by Nirvana based on the evidence you have provided?" said a representative from Tencent's legal department.
"The winning formula of Tencent's legal department is to exploit loopholes in certain areas where the law is not yet perfect?" Shen Yao shook her head and sneered.
"As a lawyer, don't you think it's unprofessional to say this? I'm asking you, which explicit clause in the intellectual property law is touched by 'Nirvana', which borrows from 'Reincarnation' to a certain extent?" The other party focused on this point.
After saying this, he looked towards the judge's seat.
He continued, "Your Honor, members of the jury, I still say that the gaming world itself is a melting pot. Based on the evidence presented by the other party, I don't think it can be said that Nirvana is a copy of Samsara. It can only be said that Nirvana has highly borrowed some aspects of Samsara. According to the existing intellectual property law, there is no explicit clause in the definition of whether a game is a copy, which can prove that Nirvana is a copy. Similarly, Tencent has always been open to learning from the outside world. As for Tencent's many games, as long as the outside world can learn from them according to the relevant clauses, Tencent will definitely maintain its open attitude, so that the gaming industry can further prosper in the good domestic environment!
These words are undoubtedly extremely shameless! Is Tencent open to being borrowed?
If they had such an open attitude, why did they sue this and that all the time in the past years?
In addition, Tencent Games has now become a giant in the industry and has already established a monopoly.
So, for now, let alone Tencent's open attitude to being borrowed, even if Tencent is open to being copied, plagiarized, and copied, no one will copy it.
The reason is very simple, because no matter how much they copy and plagiarize, it will not pose any threat to the current Tencent. Under the rule of the Tencent, no matter how much they plagiarize, it cannot change the result that in the end not only can they not eat the meat, but they can't even drink the soup.
At the plaintiff's attorney's table.
Regarding the other party's claims.
Shen Yao smiled contemptuously again.
Then he said seriously, "Mr. Judge, members of the jury, it is true that according to the existing intellectual property law, there is indeed no relevant clause that can finalize that Nirvana is a plagiarism, but the existing intellectual property law has not yet been perfected in the field of games. However, legal principles must be based on both law and reason. As for Nirvana and Samsara, the outside world almost unanimously believes that Nirvana is a complete copy of Samsara. Just because the intellectual property law has not yet been perfected in the field of games, can we do whatever we want? If so, will there be original developers in the future? In that case, in areas where relevant laws have not been fully perfected, it will evolve into a complete law of the jungle, accompanied by more unscrupulous and blatant encroachment. Will fairness and justice still exist?"
"Mr. Judge, members of the jury, I refute the opposing lawyer.
The court is all about the law, and the legal principle is the law first. The other party's lawyer reversed the order of the two! There is no clear clause in the intellectual property law that can prove that "Nirvana" is plagiarized. If "Nirvana" is arbitrated for this reason, how unfair is it for Tencent? You know, Tencent is the leading taxpayer in the country and an enterprise that has made great contributions to the whole society. Once injustice is done, it will chill the hearts of all Tencent employees. At that time, where is the justice for Tencent? ? ? "
The representative of Tencent's legal department spoke out loudly.