About law and reason.
It became the melody of this trial.
A dialectical argument in which both sides hold their own opinions.
From various quotations to extensions to reality, the verbal battle has reached one climax after another.
The representative lawyer of Tencent's legal department kept laying traps for Shen Yao with all kinds of rhetoric.
As long as Shen Yao hits the target, then Tencent's legal department will definitely be able to turn the tables in this trial.
However, he could never have imagined that all the various speech plans they had designed in advance were simulated by the Royal Court Law Firm.
So for Shen Yao, it was not difficult at all to defend against it.
There were rounds of verbal battles.
The two sides were evenly matched.
As a lawyer from an 18th-rate law firm, Shen Yao was not at all at a disadvantage.
This also caused everyone in the gallery, the jury members in the courtroom, and even the people from Tencent's legal department to be shocked!
It is extremely difficult to remain calm and composed in the face of Tencent's legal department, and to keep one's logic and thinking in an extremely clear state from beginning to end.
But the opponent was able to maintain that state and still not be at a disadvantage at all...
Who on earth is this god?
With such ability, is he willing to work in a small 18th-tier law firm?
The confrontation lasted nearly two hours.
In the face of the flawless and yet always targeted words of warning from the lawyers representing Tencent's legal department.
Similarly, Shen Yao was also guiding the opponent's rhythm invisibly while defending and responding step by step.
Although it was avoided almost perfectly by the opponent.
However, under her invisible inducement, the other party still fell into her trap!
Suddenly.
Facing the other party's arrogant self-confidence.
Shen Yao smiled.
"Judge, jury, regarding the law and reason, this seems to have fallen into a dead end. However, the other party just brought up the relationship between plagiarism and patents. Well, then, we have another document to submit, a part about patents!"
Swish-
When they heard Shen Yao say that she wanted to submit a patent, everyone in Tencent's legal department suddenly changed their expressions.
A feeling of uneasiness suddenly overflowed.
'Reincarnation' has applied for multiple game patents? How is this possible!
Before the mobile game "Reincarnation" was launched, Qianlong Game Company was almost in a half-dead state.
In this case, before "Reincarnation" is recognized and sold in the market, would the other party have the mind to apply for a patent?
Taking a step back, even if the other party applies for a patent, those game patents related to intellectual property rights cannot be obtained overnight!
So, where did the other party get the patent?
Another thing is that Tencent had prepared in advance to solve the patent problem, so it submitted multiple patent applications before "Nirvana" was launched. Even the patents applied for by Tencent have not been approved yet. How can a mere Qianlong game get its patent application approved quickly?
No, that's impossible! But it doesn't matter whether it's possible or not.
The situation is already in chaos at this point!
Just because they were certain that the other party did not have a patent, they dared to focus on learning from it again and again, thus ignoring the existence of the patent. For this reason, they unknowingly dug a patent pit under the invisible guidance of the other party.
However, if they know that the other party has a patent, instead of digging a pit and jumping into it, they will change their strategy of confrontation so that even if the other party throws out the patent issue, they can get away with it. Even if they cannot get away with it, at least they will not be defeated so completely!
But under the other party's guidance, they have fallen into the patent trap.
This also means that there will only be two possible outcomes in this court trial at this point.
One is that the other party can throw out relevant patents, and in this case, Tencent's legal department will be powerless to reverse the situation.
Secondly, the other party cannot produce any relevant patents. In this case, even if the Nanshan Court wants to rule in favor of the other party under pressure from the bigwigs above, it will not dare to ignore the influence of Tencent and directly rule in favor of the other party when the other party cannot produce a patent. In the end, the lawsuit will be dragged on!
But, the other party is now threatening to provide patent materials? Damn it, how could this be possible... How could this be possible!
In the judgement seat.
I took a look at Tencent's legal department.
The presiding judge nodded and said, "Plaintiff's lawyer, you can submit the relevant materials!"
"Okay, Mr. Judge. I'll have to ask the staff to project the materials so that the lawyers representing the defendant can have a good look at them!"
After saying that.
Shen Yao smiled and nodded slightly to the staff of the Royal Court Law Firm next to her.
The latter immediately presented the "trump card" that he had prepared long ago to the judge's seat.
soon.
Those patent-related materials were also projected for public display.
It clearly shows the patents obtained by "Reincarnation".
The patent was approved before Nirvana was launched! Tencent's legal department would never have thought of this.
The registration applications for these patents are actually made by Qianlong Games in preparation for the PC game!
I just didn't expect it would come in handy so soon!
Originally, if only these patent materials were thrown out, the strength of Tencent's legal department would not be enough to kill the Tencent legal department.
However, they had already dug the patent pit themselves under Shen Yao's inducement of retreating to advance.
At this time, facing the patent materials thrown out by the other party...
This pit is enough to make Tencent's legal department unable to climb out!
"Defense attorney, as you wish, the patent materials you want have been displayed. You can question its authenticity, that's fine, but you all have computers with you, so you can check the game-related patents online!" Shen Yao said with a smile.
In fact, there was no need for her to say more.
After these patent materials were projected.
The staff of Tencent's legal department immediately checked the authenticity of the serial number on the projection.
At this point, do you think your so-called reference is still tenable? Yes, there is no clear clause in the intellectual property law to explain whether Nirvana is a reference or plagiarism, and according to the dialectical point you just advocated, the patent should be the standard! Now, the patent materials have been shown to you, so what else do you have to say about Nirvana's plagiarism of Samsara?
Shen Yao looked at the other lawyer and smiled calmly.
Facing Shen Yao's somewhat sarcastic ridicule, the representative lawyer of Tencent's legal department turned pale and pale, and was completely unable to continue the conversation.
Seeing this.
Shen Yao turned around and looked at the judge's seat again.
He said it loudly and sternly in a heroic manner.
"Mr. Judge, fellow judges, facts have proven that the 'Nirvana' released by Tencent Games is a complete and heavy copy of our 'Reincarnation' released by Qianlong Games. I hereby implore the Nanshan Court to conduct an on-the-spot arbitration against Tencent Games, ordering them to immediately remove 'Nirvana' from the shelves, and to pay a total of RMB 1 in compensation according to our lawsuit!"