I couldn't believe the cute, innocent girl I had a crush on was whispering such obscene things in my ear. Worse, she was in a relationship. However, my urges were starting a battle. "May…" I said, weaker than I would have liked, "You have a boyfriend. I'll forget this whole thing happened if you just stop. Please."
But she only grinned and took my hand. "You want it." She told me as she guided my hand to her crotch. I felt a moist spot, tainted with the heat radiating from her pussy and let out a small moan, partially of shock.
"Told ya." May said triumphantly. "I won't tell. You won't tell. No one around us is gonna blab."
"May… Please stop…" My good nature was being stripped away slowly by my hormonal urges. I was going to cave soon, and May knew it.
She leaned in close to my ear again, this time moving to my neck, slowly kissing it. She moved up to my ear and nibbled on the lobe, giggling naughtily as she slowly removed her hand from mine. Curse my hormones, my hand kept going. She kept kissing and lightly sucking my neck before slowly removing it just far enough to speak. "You wanna take this upstairs?"
My conscious mind wasn't even switched on at this point. Wordlessly, I just stopped petting her, took her hand and started to go upstairs. May, giggling, put down her beer and kept close to me. We walked upstairs and knocked on a few doors. A few responses were heard from some rooms, but eventually, we found one unoccupied room. Once we got in, May immediately got on the bed and spread her legs.
She looked simply delicious. "Oh my god…" I moaned aloud. "I've wanted this for so long."
"Shut up and get over here." May drunkenly ordered, taking her pants off. I jumped up on the bed and took a good long look at her panties. Pink lace. Great choice. I slowly, teasingly, slid them down her beautiful legs and marveled at her pussy.
I'm guessing Carson liked it shaved, because not even a hint of stubble could be seen. Her pussy is small and beautiful, yet her lips, glistening with May's juices, puffed out and looked simply inviting. Going slowly, I started to lick around her folds.
"Nuh-uh," May moaned in impatience. "No foreplay. Just do it please."
If that's what she wants, I reasoned to myself. Too pent up to even think about what I was doing, I dove in, extending my tongue into May's love tunnel. May moaned instantly as my tongue penetrated her, and started to get into a lapping rhythm inside of her.
"Oh, fuck ." She sighed. I grabbed around her thighs as I tried to make my tongue go deeper, allowing her as much pleasure as I could possibly give her.
My tongue darted back and forth, hitting every pleasure button I knew. My arms went from grabbing her thighs to traveling up and down her body. I caressed her clothed C cups for a bit, earning a bit of a moan from her. My hands traveled downwards until they got down to her ass, and I almost stopped in surprise. I'm not sure how I didn't notice this, but May's ass was much larger than I originally thought it was. I knew she had wide hips, but I never quite noticed her ass. It completely filled my hands and then some, and it felt heavenly to the touch. Moaning into her pussy, I told myself that I just had to get a better feel of it.
I stopped and took my head out from between her legs, earning a complaint from her. Before she could protest further, I whipped her around so that her face was in the pillows. She lifted her head out to breathe just as I positioned her legs so that her ass was sticking right up into the air. I admired my work.
God damn. How did I miss out on this? Her adorable bubble butt, curvy and smooth with a beautiful pale complexion, had barely any sag to it. I did notice a few stretch marks – no doubt left over from her history of being fatter she told me about – yet as I looked at it, I couldn't help but move my head forward to lick and lightly bite her cheeks, which earned a small, continuous moan from her.
I didn't waste any time, and dove into her pussy again, eating her out for all I was worth. Unlike Nicole and Megan, I could say that May actually distinctly tasted good – like a delicate, subtle, almost bland fruit flavor – which only encouraged me to eat her out deeper and faster. As my tongue worked its magic on her love tunnel, May grabbed the pillow in front of her and scrunched it up against her, her moans quickly becoming louder and more frantic.
I lost track of time as I kept eating her out. Minutes passed as seconds before me as I realized that May was showing the telltale signs of being close. Trying to impress her, I went even faster and harder, cramping up my tongue as I did so. My efforts were not in vain – soon after, May tensed up her whole body, and remained there as I shoved my tongue fully inside her. I froze as May revealed in the waves of pleasure her orgasm was giving her. She didn't squirt or even give me anything extra, but I knew she was feeling the pleasure overtake her. She remained there, giving a silent groan as she slowly adjusted on me. Finally, she collapsed on the bed, taking my tongue out of her in the process.
"That was amazing." She panted, clearly a little sobered up at this point. "Not even Carson is that good."
I just shrugged, grinning confidently.
"Well, I think you just earned yourself a little something, Adam Watson." May grinned back as she got on her knees, matching my height on the bed. She leaned in and kissed me, shoving her tongue into my mouth, tasting her own juices and melting into my arms as she also reached down below decks and undid my jeans button and flew. Breaking the kiss, she smiled knowingly at me as she pulled my pants and underwear down in one go. Her eyes wandered down to my dick, and as her eyes fluttered back up to mine, she flashed me a smile of approval. She and I swapped places as I leaned back against the pillows and had May's mouth put me in my own personal heaven.
May didn't just start by downing my cock. Instead, she teased me, licking all up and down the shaft, occasionally focussing her tongue's efforts on the head or on my balls just to tease me, occasionally looking up at me and giggling. And god damn, she had a great tongue on her.
When I couldn't take any more teasing, she went right down to business, taking more than half of me into her mouth on the first bob. Instantly, her velvety warm mouth made me groan as I felt sparks traveling all over my skin, starting and ending between my legs. Her hands traveled my now slightly muscular body as she continued sucking, looking like she was enjoying this as much as I was. She clearly had experience, and there was no doubt that she and Carson got down to business and did it frequently, because sweet, innocent little May was sucking my cock like a pro. I soon found my hands on the back of her head, caressing her beautiful brown locks, as I let out a moan of warning.
She understood and immediately took her mouth off of me, replacing it with her hand as she quickly jacked me off. While doing so, she spooned up against me and started to lightly kiss and suck my neck again, muttering words of encouragement in between.
"Come on, hot stuff. Let me see you cum. I want to see a big load coming out of your big dick." She purred, emphasizing all of the right words. As she licked away at my neck again, my body tensed and fireworks went off in my head. I felt a pressure build up in my dick, then quickly discharged as I fired shot after shot everywhere. May had the foresight to lift up my shirt just as the first shot hit my stomach. The next shot hit her right in the arm, then the next few hit my stomach again.
With my discharge subsiding, I breathed heavily until I could see and think clearly again.
"Wow, May…" I managed. "You were incredible."
"Yeah." May smiled at me. "You were even better than… Then…" Her smile faded. "Carson. My boyfriend. Oh my god, he's my boyfriend! Adam, what the hell did we just do?"
Guilt was starting to creep into me too now that the euphoria was fading, but I didn't let it show. I didn't want the situation to turn into panic. "May, it's okay." I was soothed.
"No it's not okay!" May objected, fear in her eyes. "I just… I can't… Why?!" She got off the bed and immediately started putting on her clothes. I took the hint and started wiping myself off with a conveniently-placed tissue.
"Adam, this is not okay. I'm a faithful girl. I don't cheat." May protested in a panic.
"May, calm down." I soothed her. "Keep a level head. Panicking won't solve anything. You just had a bit too much to drink. Your judgment was clouded."
May digested what I told her, the little cogs of her thought in motion. "Yeah…" She began slowly. "Yeah, I was drunk. But you're sober, and you can think clearly! You took advantage of me!"
This was turning into Megan all over again. "Woah now." I said, having put all of my clothes back on. I stood up, getting off the bed and facing her. "You may have been drunk, but you came on to me and didn't take no for an answer. I told you I wouldn't, but you kept trying to make me hornier until I caved. If anything, you took advantage of me, May."
Fate smiled upon me, as May lowered her head and nodded weakly. "What do we do?" She asked, on the brink of tears.
I sighed. "We made a stupid mistake, but it would be selfish of us to just pretend it never happened. We need to do the right thing. We need to tell Carson and Megan."
"Oh my god, no." May responded instantly. "Carson wouldn't forgive me. I don't cheat, Adam. It's not something I do."
I laughed softly. "Well, guess what, May? You just cheated. We both did. We can figure out what we're going to do in the long term later, but for now, we just disgraced our relationships by being unfaithful. Don't you think we owe it to our partners to confess, live without secrets?"