Earlier that day, Asta had accidentally hurt Lily's feelings by telling Noelle that he was planning on marrying Sister Lily. He had already recognized his feelings for Lily, so he didn't actually mean it. He said it in past tense which Lily didn't exactly catch. He just wanted to make her jealous to see her adorable envious pout, but he did way more emotional damage than he wanted to do. He didn't want to hurt her feelings at all, but being the oblivious guy he was, his plan backfired on him. They were in his room talking through it together. After Asta explained himself, he apologized to Lily and asked for her forgiveness.
"I'm really sorry Lil. Can you forgive me?" Asta said, asking Lily for forgiveness as he reached up towards her face. She let Asta wipe away the tears from her cheeks.
"I suppose I can forgive you." Lily said, faintly smiling as she closed her eyes and leaned her head into his hand while placing her hand on top.
"Please... lemme make it up to you." Asta said as his face drew nearer until his lips met hers in a sweet and passionate kiss. As they made out, he ran his tongue along her lip asking for entrance. Lily parted her lips and Asta slipped his tongue inside her mouth. She allowed him to explore inside her wet cavern for a little while. Then she countered him with her tongue, their tongues dancing together fighting for dominance. Lily eventually won and explored her new territory inside Asta's mouth. The need for air separated them as a string of saliva connected their tongues. Asta sat back and began to take off her clothes then proceeded to take off his own. Lily watched him as he removed his clothes. His erection sprung up as he slipped off his pants and boxers, precum was leaking from the tip.
"This is what you do to me, Lily. No one else can get me this hard." Asta said, using her full preferred name as he took her hand and placed it on his penis. Lily could feel her face heat up as she got flustered. Heat pooled in her core as arousal consumed her. She began rubbing his shaft, eliciting moans from his throat.
"Lemme make you feel good too." Asta said as he placed both his hands on her breasts and massaged them, forcing small mewls of pleasure from her. Then after a while, he removed one of his hands from her right breast and latched onto that breast and began sucking on the pert bud on the mound of flesh. He snaked his now free hand down to her lower region and inserted a finger inside her and pumped it in and out of her core. It was harder to focus on pleasuring Asta while he moved his fingers inside of her.
"A-ah~! Asta~!" Lily moaned his name as he pleasured her. Asta continued to finger her, gradually adding more fingers until all four fingers were inside of her. He used his thumb to rub her clit as he pumped his fingers in and out of her. He pulled away from her right breast, removed his hand from the other breast and latched onto it, to give it the same treatment. With his other hand now free, he reached down and guided Lily's hand in moving it against his member the way he liked it. Once she got the hang of it, he released her hand and let her do it on her own. He began moving his hips, rubbing his penis against her hand for more friction. The two of them became moaning messes under each other's touch. As they pleasured each other, they neared their climaxes.
"Lily, I...I'm gonna cum!" Asta announced as he bucked his hips and released his seed all over her hand and arm. Lily climaxed shortly after he did, drenching his fingers in her juices. He withdrew his fingers and lapped her essence off of them. She seductively licked his sperm off her arm and hand, arousing Asta further. He grabbed her arm and pulled her forward towards him and kissed her hungrily. Lily locked her hands together behind his neck as she melted into the kiss as his hands roamed up and down her body, landing on her waist. He pulled her closer to him, pressing his body up against hers. She could feel his dick throbbing against her lower stomach. Suddenly, Lily pulled away from the kiss.
"Asta... let me ride you." Lily said as she pushed Asta down on the bed. He watched her as she positioned herself above him. Grabbing his member, she guided the tip and aligned it with her folds and lowered herself onto him. Asta moaned as she descended onto his cock. Once he was fully inside her, she began to raise and lower her hips at a slow pace. She gradually increased her pace, her breasts starting to bounce up and down. Asta was mesmerized by Lily's erotic figure as she rode him. He placed his hands on her hips and pulled her down forcefully onto his dick as he thrust upwards, hitting her g-spot hard and making her cry out in ecstasy.
"Oh Asta~! Ah~! Right there~!" Lily moaned out his name as Asta hit her special spot just right. He aimed for that spot over and over again, managing to hit it almost every time. They exchanged moans as they dove deeper into the depths of pleasure together. With every thrust of Asta's hips, Lily got closer and closer to her orgasm. The tension in her abdomen was building, yearning to be released. Asta was nearing his climax as well, his member twitching inside her.
"Lily... I'm about to cum~!" Asta announced as his thrusts became more frantic. He made one more powerful thrust and buried himself inside her, the tip of his penis kissing her cervix as he released his seed deep inside her womb. Lily came shortly after Asta, throwing her head back in pure ecstasy while moaning out his name. She collapsed on top of him. They both panted from their love session. Once they caught their breaths, Lily got off of Asta, his now flaccid length slipping out of her core. Some of his semen seeped out of her and dripped onto his bed sheets as she went to go lay down next to him. He reached over and lovingly brushed a strand of hair away from her face and tucked it behind her ear. He stared into her storm blue eyes with his lime green ones and smiled.
"I love you Lil. More than you realize." Asta said as he caressed her cheek with his thumb. Lily smiled and cupped his face in her hands and lovingly pressed her forehead to his.
"I love you too Asta. I always will, now and forever." Lily said as she leaned in and briefly kissed Asta on the lips. He chuckled lowly then pulled the covers over them and wrapped his arms around her, pulling her in close to him. She placed her hand on his chest and snuggled up against him. His warmth started to make her feel sleepy and vice versa. Soon they both fell asleep in a naked embrace.