An unreckonable being - that she is.
Using evil magic to battle against the forces of evil is something everyone didn't expect from Eli.
This only explains why there's that black mist surrounding her earlier when she came. They always see that dark haze whenever a summoned creature is about to make an appearance.
Now that it happened on her, the situation is already kind of self-explanatory - merely a small portion of it, though. Even when everyone already has a hunch on what's with the eight tails, they have no idea how, when and why she managed to get her hands on them.
"Hey, cat boy..." Noah suddenly called out to his upperclassman, catching his attention.
"Were you aware of this?" he asked with his eyes narrowing in suspicion.
"Don't look at me. I didn't do anything..." Wes retorted, raising his hands as if pleading innocent.