Chereads / The Lantern Bearer / Chapter 6 - A Meeting of Masks

Chapter 6 - A Meeting of Masks

Chapter 6: A Meeting of Masks

"To know oneself is to strip away every mask, even the one you show yourself."

The sun had barely begun to rise when Diogenes left the house. The streets of Athens were still cloaked in the quiet of early morning, save for the occasional sound of a baker stoking his ovens or a beggar stirring from his makeshift bed. Diogenes pulled his thin cloak tighter around him, the crisp air biting at his skin as he made his way once again toward the grove.

His mind was restless. The encounter with the speaker the previous day had left him exhilarated, but Antisthenes' words about the sharpness of truth lingered uneasily in his thoughts. He replayed the confrontation over and over, questioning whether his boldness had been wisdom or arrogance.

As he approached the grove, he saw Antisthenes already waiting for him, sitting cross-legged beneath a tree. The older man looked up as Diogenes approached, his face impassive.

"You're late," Antisthenes said, though there was no anger in his tone.

Diogenes frowned. "The sun has only just risen."

Antisthenes gestured to the sky. "And yet it began its journey long before we saw its light. So must you."

Diogenes sat down across from him, brushing dirt from his cloak. "I'm here now. Isn't that what matters?"

Antisthenes studied him for a moment. "You tell me. Does showing up mean you're ready to learn?"

Diogenes hesitated, then nodded. "I think so."

"Then let's see," Antisthenes said, leaning forward. "Today, we'll strip away your masks."

Diogenes blinked, unsure of what Antisthenes meant. "Masks?"

Antisthenes plucked a twig from the ground and began tracing patterns in the dirt. "Every man wears masks, Diogenes. Some are for others, and some are for himself. They hide his fears, his desires, his truths. You cannot know yourself until you see the masks you wear—and what lies beneath them."

Diogenes frowned, his arms resting on his knees. "And how do I do that?"

Antisthenes leaned back, his gaze steady. "By confronting the things you fear to admit. Tell me, what do you want most in this world?"

The question caught Diogenes off guard. He thought for a moment, searching for an answer. "I want to understand the truth. To live without illusion."

Antisthenes smirked. "A noble answer, but a mask nonetheless. What do you truly want?"

Diogenes shifted uncomfortably. "I told you."

"No," Antisthenes said, his voice sharp. "You told me what you think you should want. Now tell me what you want when no one is watching."

The words hit Diogenes like a slap. He opened his mouth to respond but found he couldn't. What did he want? For so long, he had defined himself by what he rejected—wealth, status, comfort—but what remained when those things were stripped away?

"I don't know," he admitted finally.

Antisthenes nodded, as if he had expected this answer. "Then that is where we begin."

The lesson continued in silence as Antisthenes led Diogenes deeper into the grove. The trees grew thicker here, their branches intertwining to form a natural canopy. Sunlight filtered through the leaves in fragmented patterns, casting shifting shadows on the ground.

They came to a small, clear stream, its surface glinting like glass in the morning light. Antisthenes knelt by the water and gestured for Diogenes to do the same.

"Look," Antisthenes said, pointing to the water.

Diogenes leaned over, his reflection staring back at him. The image was distorted by the ripples, but he could still see his dark hair, his sharp cheekbones, the faint lines of exhaustion around his eyes.

"What do you see?" Antisthenes asked.

"Myself," Diogenes replied.

"Do you?" Antisthenes asked, his tone challenging. "Or do you see a version of yourself that the water chooses to show you?"

Diogenes frowned. "What's the difference?"

"The difference," Antisthenes said, dipping a hand into the water and disrupting the reflection, "is that every surface reflects something different. The world mirrors back what it wants you to see. If you trust those reflections, you will never know what lies beneath."

They sat by the stream for a while, the silence broken only by the sound of water trickling over rocks. Diogenes stared at the disturbed surface, trying to make sense of Antisthenes' words.

Finally, he spoke. "How do I see what lies beneath?"

Antisthenes smiled faintly. "By questioning everything—even yourself. Especially yourself. Most people spend their lives deceiving themselves because the truth is too uncomfortable. They build their identities on lies because it's easier than facing what they fear."

Diogenes looked up at him. "And what do you fear?"

Antisthenes' smile faded, replaced by a thoughtful expression. "I fear wasting my life on things that don't matter. I fear living without purpose, without clarity. But I also know that fear is a mask, just like anything else."

Diogenes considered this. "So fear isn't real?"

"Oh, it's real," Antisthenes said, his tone serious. "But it's not the enemy. The enemy is letting fear control you, letting it dictate your choices. If you let that happen, you'll never see the truth."

As the sun climbed higher in the sky, they made their way back through the grove. Antisthenes walked slowly, his hands clasped behind his back, while Diogenes followed a few paces behind, lost in thought.

When they reached the edge of the grove, Antisthenes stopped and turned to face Diogenes.

"Tomorrow," he said, "I want you to bring me the thing you value most."

Diogenes raised an eyebrow. "Why?"

"Because the things we value are the masks we cling to most tightly," Antisthenes said. "If you want to strip away your masks, you must first understand what they're hiding."

Diogenes nodded, though he wasn't sure what he would bring.

That evening, as he returned to the city, Diogenes found himself walking more slowly than usual. The streets seemed louder, the faces of the people around him more vivid. He passed a merchant arguing with a customer, a young couple whispering to each other, an old man begging for coins.

He wondered what masks they wore, what truths they hid even from themselves.

When he reached his house, Hicesias was sitting outside, a cup of wine in his hand. He looked up as Diogenes approached.

"You've been spending a lot of time with that philosopher," Hicesias said, his tone guarded.

Diogenes nodded. "He's teaching me."

Hicesias snorted. "Teaching you what? How to sit in the dirt and question everything? That's not a life, Diogenes. It's a waste."

"It doesn't feel like a waste," Diogenes said, sitting beside his father.

Hicesias sighed. "You're young. You think the world will wait for you to figure it out. But one day, you'll wake up and realize you've spent your life chasing questions instead of living."

Diogenes met his father's gaze. "And what does living mean to you?"

Hicesias hesitated, then took a long sip of wine. "It means providing for your family. Building something that lasts. Leaving behind more than you took."

Diogenes frowned. "And is that enough?"

Hicesias didn't answer.

That night, as Diogenes lay in bed, he thought about what Antisthenes had said about masks. His father's words echoed in his mind, mingling with his own doubts and fears.

What was the thing he valued most? What mask was he hiding behind?

The answers felt just out of reach, like shadows flickering in the corner of his vision. But he knew one thing for certain: tomorrow, he would face them.