Dumbledore said nothing at first, bowing his head into a moment of deep thought.
After a while, he spoke slowly: "Harry, you truly are the Chosen One. You have both the courage and the determination."
Harry remained silent, his slit-like pupils narrowing even further in the dim light.
"There are things I cannot tell you yet..." Dumbledore paused, his tone soft and careful.
Harry cut him off. "Then there's nothing more to discuss, Headmaster. Goodnight."
Without hesitation, he turned to leave.
When Harry had one foot out of the office, Dumbledore called after him. "Wait."
"Harry, come back and sit down. Let me think this through."
Harry didn't follow his request but also didn't leave entirely. He leaned casually against the doorway, his eyes fixed on the Headmaster.
"I have a theory," Dumbledore began again, his voice steady but laced with gravity. "If anyone can truly defeat Voldemort for good, it is you."
Harry raised an eyebrow but said nothing.
"The prophecy—" Dumbledore started to explain but was interrupted again.
"It's because of this scar, isn't it?" Harry touched the lightning bolt on his forehead, frowning. "No one can survive the Killing Curse… except me."
"Your parents' sacrifice protected you," Dumbledore said gently. "They cast a powerful ancient magic that—"
"That still works today?" Harry asked, his tone skeptical.
Dumbledore hesitated, his expression more complex than ever.
Harry folded his arms, his voice cool. "You want me to face Voldemort. Fine. He's my parents' murderer; I have no issue with that. But if you want my help, I need answers. Real ones. I won't be a puppet or some blind fool thrown into danger just because you think it's my destiny."
"You're right," Dumbledore conceded after a long pause. "You deserve to know the truth."
He gestured for Harry to sit down again.
"During Voldemort's reign of terror, a prophecy was made," Dumbledore began slowly, his eyes searching Harry's face for any reaction. "A child born at the end of July would grow up to be his greatest foe. In the end, only one of them could survive."
Harry's expression hardened.
"Neville was born at the end of July. A day before me," he pointed out.
Dumbledore's lips twitched into a faint smile. "Yes, Neville too fit the prophecy. But Voldemort chose you."
"Why?"
"Your parents stood in his way, protected you. Your mother, Lily, used an ancient sacrificial charm—fueled by love—to shield you from Voldemort's curse. It rebounded upon him, leaving you alive."
Dumbledore paused, as if the memory itself carried a heavy weight.
"Love," he said, his voice barely above a whisper. "The purest and most powerful force in existence. It still shields you, Harry, though its effects may weaken in time."
Harry's lips curled into a wry smile. "So, I'm a custom-made weapon against Voldemort?"
Dumbledore nodded solemnly. "You're uniquely positioned to stop him. He fears you because of what you represent—a power he cannot understand."
Harry mulled this over, twirling his wand between his fingers. "You can't kill him because… what? You lack the strength? Or because if you do, he'll just come back?"
"The latter," Dumbledore admitted. "But I don't yet know how he achieved that level of immortality."
The sincerity in his eyes convinced Harry, who nodded slightly.
Dumbledore leaned forward. "I need your help to test the effects of your mother's protection. I must know if it's capable of repelling Voldemort's malice, or even turning it back upon him."
Harry took a long sip of milk, weighing his options. "And what are the odds?"
"Pardon?" Dumbledore tilted his head.
"What are the odds this 'ancient magic' actually works? It could fail, couldn't it?" Harry clarified, his words cutting.
Dumbledore removed his glasses, rubbing his temples. "The magic remains active, Harry. On this, you can trust me completely."
Harry drained his glass and set it down with a soft clink. "All right. Then let's talk about my payment."
Dumbledore blinked. "Payment?"
Harry's expression was as calm as it was firm. "Of course. You're asking me to risk my life. You don't expect me to do it for free, do you?"
"You already have the Sorting Hat," Dumbledore pointed out, his tone bemused.
Harry shook his head. "That's mine by right. It came to me when I needed it most."
Dumbledore leaned back, studying the boy before him. "What do you want, then?"
Harry considered his answer carefully. He wasn't short on money, and asking for Galleons felt trivial. High-level spells were intriguing, but power lay in knowledge and experience, not flashy incantations.
"Let me think about it," Harry said at last. "I'll give you an answer by the end of the term."
When Dumbledore opened his mouth to reply, Harry preempted him. "Don't worry. I know my limits. I won't ask for anything unreasonable."
Dumbledore's smile was faint but approving. "Very well, Harry. I trust you."
Harry nodded, finishing his milk and standing to leave.
Back in Gryffindor Tower, the moment Harry climbed through the portrait hole, he was greeted by a deafening cheer.
"Our troll-slaying hero returns!" someone shouted.
"Well done!"
George pushed through the crowd, handing Harry a butterbeer. "Ron told us everything. You took down a troll all by yourself!"
"That's something even sixth-years can't manage," Fred added.
Nearby, a sixth-year turned beet red. "That's not fair! If we had better Defense professors, I'd have no problem!"
Harry offered a polite smile, his weariness tugging at him despite the celebration.
"You're amazing, Harry, but don't be so reckless next time," a concerned voice chimed in.
Harry shook his head. "Hermione was there."
The voice faltered. "Ron said so, but she's—she's not worth—"
"She's worth it," Harry said firmly, cutting them off. "She's a Gryffindor. And she got hurt trying to help me."
Ron raised his eyebrows but said nothing, though a small, knowing smirk tugged at his lips.
The common room grew quieter as Harry spoke. "She's only eleven. She's allowed to make mistakes, just like the rest of us. We should give her a chance to learn from them."
Silence followed.
Harry hefted the troll's head from the center table, motioning for Ron to follow him. "Come on. You said you had something important to tell me?"
In the dormitory, as the door closed behind them, Ron's excitement bubbled over. "Harry, you won't believe what I saw!"
"What?"
"Snape!" Ron exclaimed, his face lit with urgency. "He was heading to the forbidden corridor on the fourth floor!"
Harry sighed, placing the troll's head into his trunk. "So that's why you took forever to fetch the professors—you were following Snape?"
Ron flushed. "Well, yeah… but don't you see what this means?"
"It means you were nosy." Harry deadpanned.
Ron ignored the jab. "Remember what Hagrid said about picking up that package from Gringotts? That thing Snape's after—it's gotta be in the corridor!"
Harry nodded absently. "It's the Philosopher's Stone."
Ron froze. "You knew?!"
"Dumbledore told me. And Snape isn't after it." Harry pulled out the Sorting Hat, inspecting its seams.
"Then who is?"
"Quirrell."
Ron recoiled in disbelief. "Quirrell?! No way!"
Harry raised a hand, cutting off further protests. "Trust me. I've confirmed it with Dumbledore."
Ron sank onto his bed, his face a mix of shock and disappointment.
Ignoring him, Harry poked at the Sorting Hat. "Now, talk. You said you had something to tell me."
The hat sighed dramatically. "I'm clean now, Potter. But it was an ordeal. You've no idea how rough that Weasley boy was."
Ron mumbled defensively. "You were filthy."
Harry's expression remained flat, his voice cold. "Get to the point."
The Sorting Hat paused before responding. "Put me on, Potter. Only you can hear this."
To be continued…