Prime Minister Asquith and Lloyd George sat in tense silence, each unwilling to compromise, creating an impasse that left the discussion at a standstill.
Asquith was resolute in his intent to resign, unwilling to bear responsibility for Britain's impending downfall. Lloyd George, on his part, had no desire to shoulder the burden of such a failure. This deadlock made resolution elusive.
"Your Excellency, perhaps we could consider appointing a new successor for the position of Prime Minister. This way, you would be free to resign, and I would not be obliged to assume the role," Lloyd George suggested.
Asquith nodded; indeed, this seemed the wisest course. However, the prospect of anyone else stepping into such a role at this moment seemed unlikely. "I fear the other cabinet ministers may be equally unwilling to accept this post," Asquith admitted, knowing that Lloyd George, as Deputy, was technically next in line. However, Lloyd George's evasive refusal had put him in a difficult position.
"Perhaps none of them are eager, but I believe there's one man who would embrace the chance to be Prime Minister," Lloyd George offered.
Asquith frowned but soon relaxed as he realized who Lloyd George had in mind. It was a sensible suggestion.
"Churchill desires to keep the British Empire fighting until Germany is defeated. Should he assume the office of Prime Minister, implementing his strategy would be far easier. I doubt he'd refuse such a prospect, and this course would give us an opportunity. Should all fail, we can withdraw to Canada," Lloyd George proposed.
Asquith agreed, saying, "Then Churchill seems the likely candidate. Return to your duties, George, and I shall summon Churchill immediately."
"Very well, Prime Minister," Lloyd George replied, relieved to avoid the heavy mantle of leadership.
As soon as Churchill returned to the Admiralty, a call came from Downing Street. The Prime Minister needed to see him at once.
Baffled but obliging, Churchill returned to the Prime Minister's office to find Asquith waiting.
"Prime Minister, what is it?" Churchill inquired.
"Churchill, I admire your unflagging resolve. While others have lost faith in Britain's cause, you remain determined to fight. I truly hope your commitment proves fruitful," Asquith said.
"Thank you, Prime Minister. I assure you, I will do all I can to defend against the German advance," Churchill responded, grateful for this endorsement, which would greatly aid his efforts.
"However, Churchill, you must realize that this path will be fraught with challenges. Many may misunderstand your intentions, and some might resist your authority, especially given the Navy's recent setbacks against Germany. I fear others may pretend to obey while quietly opposing you."
Churchill nodded, aware of these obstacles.
"I have decided to support you fully," Asquith continued.
Churchill's face lit up. Asquith's support would indeed lighten his burden.
"I plan to submit my resignation to His Majesty. And I intend to recommend you as my successor. I believe you are the best candidate for Prime Minister," Asquith declared, leaving Churchill momentarily speechless.
Overwhelmed, Churchill recognized this as the opportunity of a lifetime, though he knew it carried its own perils. Asquith was likely passing on a doomed responsibility, knowing full well that the tide was against them.
Yet for Churchill, the office of Prime Minister would afford him the unquestioned authority to lead Britain and rally its people. With such power, no one would dare defy him, a necessity in facing the German threat.
"Prime Minister, I'm honored, though this proposal truly surprises me," Churchill said.
"I assure you, Churchill, this decision is not made lightly. Please, do not decline; you are indeed the most suitable choice," Asquith replied, anxious lest Churchill refuse.
After a moment of feigned reluctance, Churchill agreed to take on the mantle.
Seeing Churchill's acceptance, Asquith was relieved.
Early the next morning, Asquith visited Buckingham Palace to meet with King George V. Formally, he presented his resignation. The King, though reluctant to see him depart, found Asquith's resolve unshakable and had little choice but to accept.
Asquith recommended Churchill as his successor. Although tradition suggested Lloyd George, King George V yielded when the other cabinet members rallied behind Churchill.
Thus, Churchill was appointed as Britain's new Prime Minister—a miraculous rise in Britain's darkest hour.