The truth sat heavy between them, like an invisible wall that neither Jake nor Cody knew how to break down. The diner was eerily quiet after the storm of fists and accusations, but the tension hadn't disappeared—it had only transformed into something darker, more insidious.
Jake backed away from the counter, his eyes still locked on Abby, but his mind somewhere else entirely. Cody stood silent, his fists unclenching slowly, still trying to process everything. They both felt the same—betrayed, humiliated, but also confused by the lingering emotions neither could yet make sense of.
Abby, tears still glistening in her eyes, tried to reach out. "I never meant for it to go this far. I wanted to tell you, but I—"
"Shut up," Jake snapped, his voice low but shaking with barely contained rage. "You wanted this. You wanted us to tear each other apart, didn't you?"
Cody, still wiping the blood from his lip, glanced at Jake and back at Abby, his expression darkening. "He's right. You could've told us, but you didn't. You let us fight, let us lose our minds over you."
Abby shook her head, pleading. "No, I didn't want this—"
Jake's laugh was cold and bitter. "You didn't want this? Don't lie to me. You enjoyed it. You sat back and watched us go at each other. Why, Abby? You wanted to feel powerful, didn't you?"
Cody's eyes narrowed, and a new kind of realization began to dawn on him. "He's right. You played us. Every smile, every touch—you knew what you were doing the whole time."
Abby took a step back, her heart pounding. "No, I didn't—"
But Jake wasn't listening anymore. Something in him had snapped. "You made fools out of us. You knew we'd never see the truth coming, didn't you?"
Abby's breath caught in her throat. Jake's eyes had darkened, something dangerous swirling behind them. Cody, too, was no longer just hurt—there was something cold, calculating in the way he now looked at her.
Suddenly, Jake lunged, grabbing Abby by the wrist. "You think this is over? You think you can just walk away after everything you've done?"
Cody stepped closer, his voice chillingly calm. "You should've told us. But now you're gonna pay for stringin' us along."
Abby's pulse raced. She tried to pull away from Jake, but his grip was too tight. "Let go of me!"
Jake tightened his grip, his face inches from hers. "You think you can mess with people like this? Use us like toys?" His voice was low, seething with rage. "You don't know what we're capable of, Abby."
Cody stood nearby, his gaze eerily detached as he watched the scene unfold. "Maybe it's time you learned."
Abby's mind raced, panic rising in her chest. She had misjudged them both. She thought she had control, that she could manage the tension between them, but now, she realized she had unleashed something far more dangerous. There was a darkness in both of them—something they had kept hidden until now.
"I didn't mean for it to go this way," she whispered, her voice trembling. "Please, just let me go."
Jake's smile was twisted, almost mocking. "Too late for that."
Suddenly, Cody stepped forward, grabbing Jake's arm and pulling him back. "We're not gonna hurt her," he said, though his voice was eerily flat. "Not yet."
Jake hesitated, glancing at Cody, as if weighing his options. Cody's gaze stayed locked on Abby, his eyes void of any warmth. "You know, Abby, we trusted you. We fought for you. And you betrayed us. So maybe it's time we fight for something else."
Abby's heart raced. "What do you mean?"
Jake smirked, stepping closer again. "We're gonna play a new game, Abby. And this time, you're the one who doesn't know the rules."
Fear gripped Abby's chest as the two men closed in, their expressions cold, predatory. She had thought she could manipulate them, but now she realized she had underestimated just how far they were willing to go.
"You like games, don't you?" Cody asked, his voice soft but menacing. "Let's see how much fun you have when you're the one who's trapped."
Suddenly, Jake grabbed Abby by both arms, forcing her back into a chair. Cody stood beside him, watching as Jake leaned in close, his voice a whisper.
"You're gonna wish you never met us."
Abby's mind raced, desperate to think of a way out, but before she could move, Jake took out his knife—a small blade he always kept in his boot—and twirled it between his fingers.
Cody watched with a sick satisfaction, his arms crossed. "You wanted control, didn't you, Abby? Well, now we have it."
For the first time, real fear flickered in Abby's eyes. She knew they were serious. The rivalry between them had morphed into something sinister, something she hadn't anticipated. They were no longer just men fighting for affection—they had become monsters, and she was their prey.
"Please," she begged, her voice barely a whisper. "You don't have to do this."
But Jake only smiled. "Oh, but we do."
The knife glinted in the dim light of the diner as Jake leaned in closer, his breath hot against her ear. "This is just the beginning."
---
The night stretched on, and by the time the storm outside had passed, everything had changed. Jake and Cody left the diner together, their expressions unreadable, while Abby sat motionless in the chair, her body trembling, her mind shattered.
They had broken her—mentally, emotionally. They hadn't needed to hurt her physically. The real damage had been done with their words, their actions, their terrifying control over her life. And as she sat there in the silence, she realized the nightmare wasn't over.
It had only just begun.
--- the end ---
Youtube, ig, tiktok : dony1618