Cama identified her next target as Sam, whom she observed on Facebook. Noticing that he had mentioned being alone in the fraternity house that night, she determined that it would be the ideal opportunity to carry out her plan. Earlier, while watching television, Cama saw a news report indicating that Colby's remains had been discovered in the abandoned warehouse where she had previously tortured him and set the building on fire after having her dogs kill him. That evening, Cama drove to the fraternity house, accompanied by her dogs, Bear, Gator, and Hog, who were seated in the backseat. The fraternity house was situated across the street from the college apartments and was not within the range of any surveillance cameras. Having noticed a large sign on the college gates earlier that day announcing a party in the college gymnasium, Cama knew that many students would be occupied. Arriving at the fraternity house at 10:00 PM, Cama discreetly entered through the front door. She found Sam sitting on the couch and stealthily approached him from behind, striking him with a hammer and rendering him unconscious. When Sam regained consciousness, he found himself nude and tied to his bed. Upon seeing Cama and her dogs, terror filled his eyes. Cama, wearing gloves and holding a tennis racket, ignored Sam's attempt to apologize and commanded him to "Shut up." She then turned Sam onto his side and informed him, "This is going to hurt," before forcibly inserting the handle of the tennis racket into his anus. Sam screamed in agony as Cama aggressively moved the handle in and out. With a final, forceful shove, she inserted the handle so deeply that only the racket's head remained visible. Sam, crying out in pain, was turned onto his back, and Cama whistled for Bear, Gator, and Hog. The dogs leaped onto the bed and began mauling Sam. Halfway through the attack, the dogs paused and looked toward Cama for further instructions. She simply said, "Eat," and they began consuming Sam alive, just as they had done with Colby. By the time the dogs had their fill, Sam was dead. Cama and her dogs then left the fraternity house and returned to their hotel room.
Upon returning to her hotel room at 12:30 AM, Cama sent a poignant text message to her brother, Kayden, stating, "Sam is dead. I have three more to go. Half of Sam is in the dogs' stomachs. Tell Mom and Dad I love them." She then meticulously cleaned the blood from her dogs' faces and decided to visit a bar that remained open late into the night. There, she encountered Dean, the young biker who had previously delivered Colby to the abandoned warehouse. Engaging in a brief conversation, the two found themselves in the alley behind the bar, engaging in consensual intercourse. Though Cama exhibited physical signs of pleasure, she felt emotionally detached throughout the act. She reflected internally, "I do not know why I am doing this; perhaps I merely wanted to experience consensual sex." Cama expressed physical enjoyment as Dean engaged in anal penetration, instructing him not to cease until he exhausted his energy, which lasted for approximately fifteen minutes. Upon completion, she adjusted her clothing and informed Dean, "As far as I am concerned, this encounter was a one-time event. I will find you if I desire further interaction." Dean responded by suggesting she look him up on Facebook under the name Dean Vallen. Returning to her hotel room, Cama reheated some leftover Cajun dinner. After consuming her meal, she fell asleep while noticing the clock reading 3:45 AM.