Chereads / prison innocent / Chapter 5 - chapter 5

Chapter 5 - chapter 5

Lilly had made a habit of spending every spare moment in the prison library. The dimly lit room, filled with dusty volumes and old newspapers, had become her sanctuary. Here, she could lose herself in research, meticulously combing through legal texts and case files in search of any clue that might help her appeal. Each piece of information she uncovered was like a puzzle piece, slowly forming a clearer picture of the truth she sought to prove.

One afternoon, while flipping through an old newspaper archive, Lilly stumbled upon an article about the night of the murder. The article detailed the crime scene, witness testimonies, and the supposed evidence against her. As she read, she couldn't help but feel that something was off. The evidence seemed circumstantial at best, and the witness statements were vague and inconsistent.

Lilly copied the relevant details into her notebook, her mind racing with questions. She needed to understand every aspect of the case against her to find the cracks in its foundation. That evening, she met with Maria in the library, her notebook open between them.

"Look at this," Lilly said, pointing to the copied article. "The witness statements don't add up. One person said they saw me leaving the scene, but another said they couldn't identify the person clearly. And the timeline is all wrong."

Maria leaned over the table, studying the notes carefully. "You're right," she said after a moment. "This doesn't make sense. If the witnesses couldn't positively identify you, that should have raised doubts in court."

Lilly nodded, her frustration evident. "But it didn't. They convicted me anyway."

Maria sat back, tapping her fingers on the table thoughtfully. "You need to keep digging. Find out more about the witnesses. Were they reliable? Did they have any reason to lie? And what about the evidence? Was it properly handled?"

Lilly scribbled down Maria's suggestions, her determination renewed. "I'll look into it. There has to be something we're missing."

Maria reached out and placed a hand on Lilly's arm. "You're doing great, Lilly. Don't lose hope. The truth will come out eventually."

Meanwhile, Scott Grant was in his office, buried in paperwork. As the prison boss, he had access to all the inmates' files, including Lilly's. Her recent interactions and the encounter with Sarah had piqued his curiosity, prompting him to take a closer look at her case.

Scott opened Lilly's file and began to read through the documents. He was struck by the same inconsistencies that Lilly had noticed. The evidence was flimsy, and the witness testimonies were shaky at best. As he read further, he found more discrepancies—gaps in the investigation, overlooked details, and a troubling lack of concrete proof.

Scott leaned back in his chair, his mind working through the implications. He had seen many cases in his career, but something about this one didn't sit right with him. Lilly's determination and the conviction in her eyes when she spoke of her innocence had stirred something in him. He couldn't ignore the possibility that she might be telling the truth.

The next day, Scott decided to follow up on his suspicions. He called a meeting with the prison's legal advisor, a sharp-witted woman named Karen who had a reputation for her keen insight.

"Karen, I need you to take a look at this," Scott said, handing her Lilly's file. "There are some inconsistencies in this case that I can't ignore. I want your opinion on it."

Karen glanced through the file, her brow furrowing as she read. "You're right, Scott. This case is full of holes. If what's in this file is all they had, it's a wonder they managed to secure a conviction at all."

Scott nodded. "That's what I thought. I want you to dig deeper into this. Find out everything you can about the trial, the evidence, the witnesses. If there's any chance that she was wrongfully convicted, we need to know."

Karen smiled, a determined glint in her eye. "Consider it done."

As Scott watched Karen leave his office, he felt a strange mix of emotions. He was a man who believed in the system, in rules and order, but this case was testing his faith in that system. He had always prided himself on being fair and just, and if Lilly was innocent, then justice had not been served.

Later that evening, Scott decided to take a walk around the prison grounds. As he made his rounds, he spotted Lilly sitting alone in the yard, her notebook open on her lap. He approached her, his curiosity getting the better of him.

"Mind if I join you?" he asked, his tone softer than usual.

Lilly looked up, surprised but nodded. "Of course."

Scott sat down beside her, glancing at the notes spread out before her. "You're really digging into this, aren't you?"

Lilly nodded, a determined look in her eyes. "I have to. It's the only way I can prove my innocence."

Scott hesitated for a moment before speaking. "I've been looking into your case too. There are a lot of things that don't add up."

Lilly's eyes widened in surprise. "You have?"

Scott nodded. "Yes. And I've asked Karen, our legal advisor, to investigate further. If there's anything we can find that supports your claim, we will."

Lilly felt a surge of hope. "Thank you, Scott. I didn't expect…"

Scott held up a hand. "Don't thank me yet. We still have a lot of work to do. But I believe in justice, and if you're innocent, then we need to make that right."

For the first time since her incarceration, Lilly felt a glimmer of hope. She had allies now—Maria, who believed in her innocence, and Scott, who was willing to question the system for the sake of truth. Together, they would uncover the past and find the justice she so desperately sought.

As the days turned into weeks, Lilly continued her research with renewed vigor, often sharing her findings with Maria. Each piece of the puzzle brought her closer to the truth, and with Scott and Karen working behind the scenes, she felt a growing sense of optimism.

One evening, as she and Maria sat in the library, pouring over old court transcripts, Maria looked up with a thoughtful expression. "You know, Scott's involvement is a good sign. If he believes in your innocence, it could make a huge difference."

Lilly nodded. "I hope so. It's strange, though. He's so strict and tough, but there are moments when he seems… different."

Maria smiled knowingly. "Everyone has layers, Lilly. Scott's no exception. Maybe you're starting to see the man behind the boss."

Lilly pondered Maria's words as she returned to her research. The man behind the boss—Scott Grant was indeed a complex figure, and the more she learned about him, the more she realized that there was much more to him than met the eye.

As Lilly continued to uncover the past, she felt a growing sense of purpose. She was not just fighting for her freedom; she was fighting for the truth. And with her newfound allies by her side, she was more determined than ever to see justice served.