The following day, Analise made her way to the grocery store. While browsing the bread aisle, she unexpectedly came face to face with her former case worker, the one who had dismissed her claims of abuse by Jonathan and Amy. This encounter brought back a flood of memories. Hastily, Analise purchased her groceries and headed towards her car, only to run into her previous case worker, Kyle. He inquired about her well-being, to which Analise simply replied, "I'm doing well." Upon arriving home, Michael Myers assisted her in putting away the groceries. Analise then proceeded to feed her dogs a mixture of wet dog food and bread, and prepared a meal consisting of baked chicken, mashed potatoes, and salad for herself and Michael Myers. Following dinner, Analise and Michael Myers retreated to her room, where she shared with him a list of individuals who had wronged her, with her biological father's name at the top. Overwhelmed with emotion, Analise began to cry, and Michael Myers embraced her. They locked eyes for a moment, after which Michael Myers removed his mask and kissed her. Soon, their clothes were discarded on the floor as they made love in the bed. Michael Myers tenderly kissed her body, from her neck down to her thighs, causing all her worries to fade away. In that moment, Analise's sole focus was the gentle rhythm of Michael Myers moving within her. Once their intimate encounter concluded, they lay together in her bed. Analise turned to Michael and asked, "Michael, can you assist me in seeking revenge?" He nodded slowly, and together they devised a plan to eliminate her targets in reverse order, starting with her former case worker who had turned a blind eye to her suffering.
That very same night, Michael Myers donned his jumpsuit, boots, and mask, while Analise dressed in an identical costume. They drove to the street where their first target resided, parking a few houses away. Accompanied by her dogs Lucas and Rufus, they stealthily entered the target's house and patiently awaited their arrival. As soon as the target entered and closed the door, she was met with growling and the sight of the dogs foaming at the mouth. Suddenly, Michael Myers seized her from behind, restraining her, while Analise emerged from the kitchen brandishing a large chef's knife. Analise expressed, "Had you heeded my seek for help when I sought your assistance, things would have been different." Subsequently, she mercilessly attacked her ex-case worker, inflicting multiple stab wounds, relishing each moment of the act. Following the bloodshed, Analise, accompanied by Michael Myers and the dogs, returned to her residence, marking off the name of her former case worker from her list. Analise embraced Michael Myers, expressing her gratitude with a heartfelt "Thank you." Her anticipation for seeking retribution against her remaining targets grew stronger.