Mateo thought about it. He even considered taking this risk, luring John to the rumored water monster area. With a knife in his hand, as long as he stayed in the water long enough, he could surely deal with John.
He didn't want to deceive Clara. He nodded, admitting that he planned to kill John in the water. If it couldn't be done in the water, he had a backup plan on land. He had already discussed the strategy with his companions. Once they controlled John's allies, he would have a chance to take down John. Anyway, he won't let John go back unharmed. Defeating John would establish his authority in the tribe and ensure Clara's safety.
It was simply a gamble. There were too many dangers along the way, and Clara couldn't stay calm. She immediately said, "It's better to give up!"
