Lily and Asta were sitting on the bed together having a conversation in his room. He explained the concern he had at the end of the Magic Knight's Entrance Exam when the Magic Knight Squad Captains were selecting contestants to join their squads. All nine of the captains raised their hands for Lily. Asta revealed he was afraid she'd choose the squad Yuno chose: the Golden Dawn. Then he asked why she chose the Black Bulls instead because she'd have a higher chance of becoming the Wizard Queen by choosing the Golden Dawn and she'd be by her twin brother's side. Lily explained her reasons for joining the Black Bulls and hugged him reassuringly, pressing her chest up against his. Since she was in her pajamas, she wasn't wearing a bra. Asta felt her tits against him which began to arouse him. When he pointed out that he could feel her tits poking at his chest, she quickly pulled away while blushing and covering herself up. Asta just stared at Lily, leaning in until his lips met hers and kissed her passionately. As the sensual atmosphere thickened, Asta's pajama shorts became increasingly tight. He pulled away from the kiss and looked Lily in the eyes.
"Lily, let's do something special to celebrate." Asta said in a romantic yet erotic tone. Lily said nothing and just agreed as she was captured in another passionate kiss. In the heat of the moment, the two of them lost their clothes. Asta pulled away from the kiss, panting as he stared at her figure beneath him. The sight made his erection reach its full size. And it was at this moment that Asta realized just how much he wanted Lily.
'Oh Lil, you're so beautiful. And even though you went through hell at your former home, your personality still turned out perfectly. You're such a gem, beautiful on both the outside and the inside. I can't imagine life without you. So when you were given the opportunity, I was scared you'd choose the Golden Dawn over the Black Bulls. I always want you to stay by my side. You're my best friend and almost like a sister to me, but I'm addicted to you. Even thoughts of Sister Lily can't get me this big. Now's the perfect moment to tell you how I really feel: I love you Lil. I love you so much.' Asta said mentally as his eyes roamed over Lily's bare form. Then he grabbed one of her legs and rested it on his shoulder. He prodded her womanhood with the tip of his penis, but didn't quite enter yet.
"Before we continue, there's something important I have to tell you. I'm in love with you Lil. Not Sister Lily, you. It took me ten years of countless rejections and the arrival of the actual love of my life... But I finally realized you are the one for me. It was you this whole time. I love you Lil." Asta confessed. Lily couldn't believe it. Asta finally acknowledged his true feelings. She started to cry tears of joy.
"What's wrong Lil?" Asta asked Lily as he looked at her worriedly. She wiped the tears that had left her eyes and smiled up at Asta.
"Nothing's wrong Asta. I'm just so happy you finally confessed to me. I was worried that you'd hold onto your infatuation with Sister forever, you know, since you never give up." Lily said as Asta gave her a gentle smile.
"Well I was certain I wanted to marry Sister Lily until you entered my life five years ago. After I met you, I started to have second thoughts about my choice for a bride. But now I'm absolutely positive the woman I want is you, Lil." Asta said, leaning down and briefly kissing Lily's lips, trapping her leg between the mattress and his shoulder. Fortunately, she was very flexible so it didn't hurt for her leg to be stretched like this.
"Then prove it and take me, Asta." Lily whispered seductively in his ear. Asta said nothing and captured her lips with his. As he kissed her, he slipped his member inside her in one swift movement. Lily broke the kiss and let out a cry of pleasure as Asta entered her, calling out his name as she arched her back. Her voice was like music to his ears. He wanted to elicit more sweet sounds from her. So he began thrusting hard and fast, driving her absolutely crazy. Lily tried to keep her volume down since they weren't the only ones that lived here. But Asta was intent on making her scream out in ecstasy. He grabbed her outer thighs and pulled her in towards him with every thrust of his hips, reaching deep into her core and hitting that sensitive spot inside of her. Moans escaped her lips as she failed to hold back her voice.
"Ah~! Asta~! So good~!" Lily cried out in pure ecstasy, grabbing the bed sheets and arching her back. The sight turned Asta on even more. But as arousing as that was, he wanted to try something new. So far they had only done various versions of missionary style. He pulled out of her, making her whimper at the sudden loss of sensual stimulation and emptiness inside her.
"Let's try a new position. Turn over and get on your hands and knees with your ass up." Asta said as Lily complied, facing away from him. Asta grabbed her hips and rammed himself into her womanhood and pounded her mercilessly. This drew out mewls of pleasure from her. As he thrust into her, Asta leaned down and pressed his chest against her back. He gently grabbed her chin and turned it towards him and kissed her passionately. Their tongues danced together until he pulled away. Then he left a trail of kisses down her jawline to her neck until he found her sweet spot. He began sucking on her neck. Lily gasped at the pleasurable sensation and intertwined her fingers with his as he continued to make love to her. Then he pulled away from her neck, briefly pausing to admire the dark purple spot that he specifically placed in an area her clothes would cover. He abused the spot a little more to make it darker. After he was done marking her, Asta resumed leaving a trail of kisses to her shoulder where he bit down, enough to leave marks but not cause her any pain. He continued to nip at her shoulder, leaving faint bite marks that would go away in an hour or so. A feeling of possessive dominance had taken over him.
"You're mine Lil. I've marked you as my own. Don't you forget that." Asta said in a dominant tone as he pounded into Lily ruthlessly, hitting her g-spot every single time. She found this rough dominating side of Asta very erotic and she submitted to him without hesitation.
"Yes Asta! I'm yours and only yours! Ah~!" Lily cried out as Asta leaned in to kiss her again. The two of them moaned into the kiss until the need for air forced them apart. Pulling away, they both panted. Lily felt Asta's hot breath next to her ear as he grunted and moaned. His penis twitched as he was getting closer and closer to climaxing. Lily was nearing her orgasm as well.
"Hah~ Lily, I'm gonna cum! I love you so much!" Asta breathed out as his thrusts became more sloppy and frantic. Even so, he still managed to hit her g-spot every time.
"Me too~! Asta! Ah-ahh~! Asta~!" Lily called out his name. With his last thrust, he buried himself inside of her and came, releasing his warm seed deep into her core. Lily came together with Asta as he filled her up good. They both panted, coming down from their orgasmic highs. Asta rocked his hips, not yet wanting to leave her snug warm core. After a short while, he pulled out, completely flaccid and collapsed next to her on the bed. Some of his semen seeped out of her.
"Asta... you came inside this time." Lily said, sitting up. Asta sat up as well suddenly looking worried, like he had made a terrible mistake. But she put any worries he had to rest.
"You're lucky I began taking birth control. Otherwise, you might've become a father a bit earlier than expected. After all, today wasn't considered a safe day before I started taking birth control." Lily said as Asta sighed with relief then appeared to be puzzled.
"When did you start taking that? Wait, what's birth control?" Asta asked Lily as she sighed. Geez just how clueless was this guy?!
"Birth control is supposed to prevent any unwanted pregnancies. I started taking it after we first had sex. I had a feeling we'd end up doing it again and that you might cum inside of me at one point." Lily told Asta whose confused look turned into a sheepish grin.
"Hehe, what can I say Lil, you're irresistible. When it comes to you, I can't help but lose control of myself. Even thoughts of Sister Lily can't make me as big and hard as you do." Asta said while scratching the back of his head. Lily's face turned red at his comment.
"Wha-?! Asta! Don't say such embarrassing things!" Lily said as she pushed Asta back on the bed, while covering herself up with his bed sheets. The two of them were still naked.
"What? It's true Lil. But it's not just your looks that made me decide to be with you. I love your personality, your body, everything about you. I love you for you." Asta said as she blushed from his flattery. There was an awkward pause before Asta spoke again.
"As much as I enjoy seeing you naked, you should probably get dressed... unless you want to go for round two." Asta teased as he tossed Lily her panties and pajamas. Lily got flustered and blushed a crimson hue as she caught her clothing. She just sat there, her blush not going away. Heat pooled inside her core at the mere thought.
"I wouldn't mind..." Lily said quietly, fidgeting on the bed as Asta turned towards her with a surprised look on his face.
"I-I mean... o-only if you want to!" Lily said frantically as Asta approached her, crawling up to her on the mattress.
"You sure Lil?" Asta asked Lily, his face very close to hers. His lime green eyes were starting to swirl with lust again. Lily's eyes traveled down his body for a split second, then snapped back up to his eyes. He was erect again. The blush on her face became even more apparent. She just nodded her head as Asta captured her lips with his. He kissed her passionately and she gladly kissed him right back. As they made out he leaned in more, pushing her back on the bed. Asta pulled away from the kiss as he hovered over her. He wasted no more time and rammed himself inside her, thrusting hard and fast. His rough movements elicited sweet cries of ecstasy from her as he hit that special spot inside of her nearly every time. But that wasn't the only thing that drove Asta crazy. Her core squeezed him tightly, the sensual stimulation becoming too much. He was already very sensitive from cumming earlier. Asta couldn't hold his voice back and moaned out Lily's name.
"Hah~ Lily! You're so tight around me! It's like your body is trying to milk me of all my sperm. I don't know how much longer I can hold out!" Asta breathed out as he continued to thrust, his hot and heavy breaths tickling her ear.
"Ah~! Asta, I'm close too! Please, cum inside me!" Lily pleaded as Asta adhered to her request and gave one more powerful thrust that hit her g-spot hard. Lily was sent over the edge with his final thrust and came as well. Both of them called out each other's names as they came together again for the second time tonight. Asta pulled out of Lily and collapsed next to her. The two of them panted as they both rode out the high from their climaxes. After they caught their breaths, Lily gathered her underwear and pajamas and put them back on. Asta followed her lead. Then they both plopped back on Asta's bed, facing the ceiling. Asta rolled over onto his side to face Lily and she did the same, staring into his eyes as he did hers. He reached over and brushed a strand of hair away from her face and smiled.
"You know Lil, I think you're more beautiful than Sister Lily." Asta said as he leaned over and planted a kiss on your forehead. Lily sighed and flicked his forehead.
"Why do you always have to mention Sister after every time we share an intimate moment? You did that all the previous times we had sex too." Lily asked with a frown on her face as Asta chuckled sheepishly.
"Haha, I guess it's a habit? Sorry." Asta explained and apologized as Lily pouted which he found adorable. He leaned over and gave her a short sweet kiss on the lips.
"But don't worry, Lil. I'm over my infatuation with Sister Lily now." Asta said to reassure her. Even though she believed him, her pout didn't fade. She knew Asta didn't let stuff go that easily. Especially something like an infatuation with a nun that's carried on for years, even after many, many rejections. After all, Asta's magic was never giving up.
"Aww come on Lil. Please don't be mad at me." Asta pleaded, giving her the puppy-dog look with big shiny eyes. Lily couldn't stay upset with Asta, especially when he made that face. She started to giggle and ruffled his hair.
"Asta, I couldn't stay mad at you even if I wanted to. But I was never mad at you for mentioning Sister to begin with. However I was a bit disheartened, meaning I was a little depressed and disappointed. I've liked you ever since the day I met you. So seeing you fawn over Sister like you did made me feel a bit sad." Lily said as she began to avert her gaze away from Asta. Hearing this from her tugged at his heart. He didn't realize that he hurt her with all those rejected marriage proposals to the young nun. Asta scooched closer to Lily and snaked one arm beneath her and the other arm over her other side. He pulled her in close to his chest, surrounding her in a warm embrace.
"I'm sorry Lil. I never meant to make you feel that way. But I can assure you, I'm over Sister Lily. You're the one I want. And I want to make it up to you and prove this to you." Asta said as he kissed the top of Lily's head. Then he pulled away from the embrace and looked into her storm blue eyes with his lime green ones, placing his hands on her shoulders as they lay on the bed together.
"So that's why, when I become the Wizard King, will you marry me Lily Grinberryall?" Asta proposed to Lily as she smiled, tears of joy threatening to spill from her eyes.
"Yes, of course I'll marry you! Don't keep me waiting too long, 'kay Asta? But even if I become the Wizard Queen instead, I'll still accept your proposal." Lily said as she gave Asta a quick peck on the lips. A light blush dusted Asta's cheeks as she kissed him. Then he chuckled.
"Don't you worry Lil. I'll become the Wizard King soon enough! Then I'll propose to you officially and make you the happiest woman alive!" Asta said as Lily chuckled.
"And then I'll accept your proposal again. I'll accept it every time." Lily said as she reached over and lovingly stroked Asta's cheek with her thumb. Upon hearing she'd accept all his proposals, Asta knew Lily was the right choice for a bride. He leaned in and kissed her then pulled away and surrounded her in a warm embrace again. He rested his head in the crook of her neck. She nestled up against him, drowning in his scent. Asta's warmth was starting to make her feel sleepy. And before she knew it, she fell asleep peacefully in his arms. Asta chuckled softly and pulled the covers over both of them and fell asleep shortly after, holding her close as she snuggled up against his chest.