I leaned back with a sigh before replying, "I think it's really nice for you to want to help her, but what makes you think you could ever convince a sixteen-year-old girl to have sex with a twelve-year-old boy, especially someone with a problem like hers? Besides, I'm not that big".
"Easily," Beth said, "we'll get her so horny she won't be able to say no, and don't sell yourself short. An eighteen-year-old guy would be jealous of you." Paula handed me a picture and told me it was her cousin, and I looked at it in disbelief.
I knew this person, or rather, I had known her.
She lived in the trailer park I had lived in, and almost every male who laid eyes on her lusted after her. I remembered her centerfold figure, sweet face, and long blond hair very well. I knew her sister much better. She was the one who got away.
Paula seemed to be studying my expression closely as she said, "It's alright if you don't want to; I know it's a lot to ask." I couldn't help it; I laughed till I cried. Both girls finally got the joke and joined in.
Finally, I managed to say, "Two beautiful girls ask me if a third beautiful girl can join us in bed, and it's a lot to ask."
Paula looked down and said, "It's even worse. She'll have her sister Connie with her." She handed me another picture, and of course I knew who Connie was before Paula told me she was the one in the middle.
"What about her?" I asked, trying to keep a straight face and failing badly, "Do you expect her to get into the action? You must think I'm Superman or something."
Beth smiled. "We do," she said, "but I also saw the look on your face when you checked out that last picture. I don't think you'd mind much!"
I told them about Connie then; it took a while, but just telling someone seemed to help. They both hugged us, and Paula said, "Just leave it to us and play along, ok?"
I agreed, and both girls pounced on me, kissing me repeatedly. I swear I could hear the theme from "The Twilight Zone" in the background. Paula called her cousin and gave her directions to my place.
When they arrived, I was as ready as I thought possible. It almost wasn't enough, though. Linda was easy enough, but behind her was her sister. When our eyes met, I felt the same bolt of lightning hit me that nailed me when I was fifteen, but this time it was even stronger. From the look of astonishment on her face, I could see she felt it too.
The first time this happened, we tried to fight it but quickly failed. At the time, she had been going with a friend of mine, and I had also been attached. Within a week, we had both broken up with our respective paramours and gotten together. I hoped the ending would turn out differently this time.
I would say we talked for a while, but actually Beth, Joyce, and Linda talked while I tried to get Connie to loosen up. Eventually Paula said, "I'm bored; let's play a game or something." When they discovered that all I had were cards, it narrowed the choices quite a bit.
Finally, Beth said, "Let's play strip poker!" It took a long time to convince the victims of the plot, but after the usual "you're scared" and such, they reluctantly agreed. This would be easy for me since I would know what everyone had in their hands. Paula surprised me firsthand. She was dealt three jacks but threw two of them away.
I eavesdropped on her strategy and had to agree with it. She and Beth were going to break the ice to loosen the others up. When she lost, she feigned a pout and acted bashful as she removed her top to reveal her bra-clad chest. Beth lost next and removed her top before they got serious. Connie lost the next hand, and at first I thought she'd balk, but the girls' strategy was paying off.
Connie was thinking, "I don't have much up there, but at least I'm even with Paula!" My mouth started to water as she removed her top. I swear that after all these years, I could still taste those lovely (and very sensitive) breasts she uncovered.
I lost next (on purpose) and took my shirt off. The workouts had been paying off. I heard Linda and Connie gasp, and Linda said, "I'm beginning to see why you like Matt so much, Paula!" I could sense the disappointment in Connie as she thought, "Dammit! "I figure he would have already hooked up with someone." I smiled, thinking that she was in for a surprise.
We tried to get Linda to lose the next hand, but it was Connie's turn again. By mutual agreement, neither of us were wearing shoes or socks, so her choices were limited. She chose to remove her jeans, which was fine with me since I had always loved her legs. She did so quickly and sat back down, blushing furiously.
Linda cooperated by losing the next hand and removing her top. I must admit, it was an impressive sight. She had been wearing a halter with no bra, so she was one step ahead of everyone now. I could sense her dismay and her sister's amazement when they realized that I didn't give the display the attention they thought it deserved.
Connie thought, "Why is he still looking at me?" while Linda thought, "Good for him. Paula has great taste in guys; it seems like big boobs don't faze him." Beth lost the next hand and surprised everyone by removing her bra instead of her shorts.
I could tell where her mind was without peeking. Her skin was flushed, and her nipples were as hard as erasers. It wasn't remotely cold in the room. As a matter of fact, it was getting warmer by the moment. She and Linda seemed to be almost the same size on top.
Paula lost next and demonstrated that she was in a similar condition.
I was a little depressed when Linda lost next, but there was plenty of time, and she did have great legs. I lost the next hand and revealed the tent in my boxers.
I could sense the immediate interest from Connie and Linda. Connie acted like she had never actually seen a guy naked, which explained hers, but Linda was thinking lewd thoughts as she said, "How old did you say he was?"
It took a moment for Paula to realize that it wasn't my erection that Linda was talking to since her eyes hadn't left it before she said, "I don't think you'll get an answer from the 'monster in the drawers," but if you're talking to me, he's the same age as I am.
Everyone laughed except Linda, who shook her head and looked a little sad as she thought, "Why couldn't I meet a guy like that?" Paula and Beth managed to arrange to lose their shorts before it was Connie's turn to lose again.
I barely managed to keep from drooling as she removed her bra and added her breasts to those on display. When she saw me staring, she pointed at her sister and blurted, "Why are
you looking at me when she has those?"
I said, "I'm sorry, I couldn't help it. It's true that Linda is very pretty, but so are you. In fact, you're making my mouth water".
She muttered, "He's crazy," but from the state of her nipples, my mouth wasn't the only thing watering!
Linda lost next and had no choice but to reveal her very neatly trimmed and tasty-looking bush, and I finally had the answer to a question I had often pondered in my previous youth. Linda had honey-blond hair, while her sister's was jet black.
Linda must have touched it up a lot because I had never seen any dark roots.
Her pubic hair matched the color of the hair on Connie's head exactly. She seemed totally at ease with being naked and did a slow turn in front of me while yelling "TA DAH!" and sitting back down, giggling.
Connie lost next and joined her sister in complete nudity by revealing her sparsely haired pussycat. We didn't get the show, though. She was up and down in a flash before asking, "What now? We don't have anything else to take off!"
Paula said, "If you lose after all of your clothes are gone, you have to do whatever the winner says." Connie blushed even harder as she thought of what that could be.
I lost next and revealed the Cyclops.
I thought Connie's eyes would pop out but was distracted when I heard Linda say, "Oh wow, you weren't kidding!" before slapping her hand over her mouth and turning even redder. "Oops" she said "sorry".
Paula laughed and said, "It's alright." You're not the only one I tell my secrets to." Linda got very quiet, as if wondering what else I knew.