With no real clue what he's doing, Abdul steps up and begins randomly pressing buttons. It takes a good few minutes, but eventually something happens. You hear a clunk and a scrape.
Esme looks at you in excitement. "That's it!" she gasps. "Good work, Abdul. Now, Dr. Spillane, perhaps you'll have more luck with the second one. Sam, the second riddle, if you please?"
Once again, Sam reads from the riddle: "'In the Tabernacle's final days, hearken to Jesus ben Ananias's cries.'"
You take a moment to mull it over.