Cait took me by the hand, carrying a small bag in her other. She led us away from the settlement. I wasn't worried about anything attacking us, so didn't bother carrying a rifle, though I always carried a pistol, in just in case. She led us towards an isolated spot far from anything, placing the bag down to take out a rug she laid down.
"Sit," she ordered. So I sat down, Cait lowering herself down to sit between my legs, resting back against my chest. I kissed her cheek as I gently held her in my arms. "Would say nice view but not sure many exist in the Commonwealth. Your settlement is… It's something else, Nate. I've really enjoyed myself the past week. Such a different life to anything I've done before."
"You seem happier. More at peace with things."
"When you found me that morning… I've felt lost for years, Nate. But the fact you were so determined to help me. And you've shown patience with me when I know I'm in one of my moods. You just give a shit. You care. And you've not asked for anything from me. Then there's everyone here. All so nice, willing to help. I haven't thought any of those negative thoughts since we got here."
I gave her a gentle squeeze. "Good. I hoped coming here would help. Didn't know if would work or not."
"You're the first man I've ever met who hasn't just wanted to fuck me then discard me like trash. Even Tommy…" She paused. "He didn't want to fuck me, but he knew I made him caps. I was still used." She paused again, hearing her swallow. "I'm an addict, Nate. I'm still using."
"I know," I said softly.
"But I don't want to anymore. I know I don't need it, not when I'm here with you and the others. I want to be clean. But I need to explain why I'm like I am. Want to hear the unfiltered truth?"
"I do, because getting everything off your chest will get rid of the weight. When I was in Alaska, I'd talk out certain things because they weighed me down. Some of the things we did… Some of the things I've done since waking up, to be honest."
"They were raiders. They deserved it."
"That's how I look at it too."
She fell silent, resting her head back against me. The river was in front of us, the opposing bank bereft of anything except dead trees and grass. But apart from the water flowing, there was barely a sound. It was rather peaceful. When she sighed, I kissed her cheek as I knew she was getting ready to tell me everything.
"Don't think I've ever truly been loved, Nate," she said. That earned an immediately tighter embrace. "It's true. Starts with my parents. Not sure if I was unwanted or not, but I know there is a way that children should be raised. But all I had was years of abuse. Generally, it was emotional and psychological but they liked to both slap me around too. I was stupid. I was worthless. I'd never amount to anything. Never heard them ever say they love me. Tried to run away twice. First time, they just locked me in a shed for a few days. Second time, they broke my leg."
"Jesus," I muttered.
"I thought that, because they wouldn't let me just run away, that they must actually care for me, if not actually love me." She laughed bitterly. "I was wrong. The very day I turned eighteen, they slapped a slave collar on and sold me into slavery for a big bag of caps. I was dragged away desiring only one thing. Vengeance.
For five years, I was kept as a slave. I'm sure you can figure out what I was used for. Every day, for five years. Different men every day. And then the slavers would have their turn too. The slavers broke me first, of course. Made sure I was compliant. If I wasn't, I'd be punished even worse. So I lay there each and every time and took it. But I figured out quickly that I needed to survive, that it would end up with me being dead eventually. Sleeping men tell no lies, and after they've cum in you, most will go to sleep. So I stole a few caps here, few caps there. I didn't know how to fight at the time, use a weapon or anything, so I knew I couldn't fight my way out. I'd have to buy my freedom. I just had to keep doing it until I had enough. Five long years, but I bought my freedom."
"I can't even begin to imagine," I whispered, "How are you… How can you…"
"You're not them. You're nothing like them," she whispered back, "But I still need to be sure."
"So you bought your freedom. What did you do with it?"
"Bought myself a shotgun and went home. I did what I said I'd do, but it didn't make me feel any better. Made me feel worse, to be honest. They were pathetic. Always had been pathetic. Hearing them both whimper, begging for forgiveness. All it did was harden my heart. For eighteen years, all I'd wanted from either of them was a little bit of love, to know I was worth something, that I meant something to them. All I was, in the end, was a meal ticket. Told me they spent most of the caps on chems.
I needed caps. And I needed to forget. Took to drinking. Took to chems, particularly Psycho. Sure you've figured that out by now. And with all the rage still inside, I needed an outlet, and that's how I ended up at the Combat Zone. Tommy gave me a contract that guaranteed caps, food, booze, chems, a bed and a fight.
Things were okay for a while. Won all my fights. When I wasn't fighting, I was training. Tommy saw something in me, made sure I was sober enough to fight and do it well, put on a show for the customers. Kept him happy, he gave me chems. Took a shitload of chems. It was a hard life, but I felt safe until the raiders took over. Things changed quickly. I was one of only a couple of women around, so I was constantly watching my back. Had plenty of caps, but I knew I needed protection.
So came to an agreement with their leader, Stratton. He kept me safe, I'd let him fuck me. He took advantage of that, of course. Was never as bad as when I was a slave, but he still degraded me. Things took a turn for the worse when, after a particularly brutal fight, he demanded sex. Told him to fuck off. He smirked, placed a bag of caps on my desk, then walked out.
I'm sure you can imagine what happened. They all had a go. Made them fight for it, but there was only one of me and more of them. And because I fought, they made sure it hurt, and they made sure it went on for a long time. Smart enough not to make me suck dick though. Would have lost it."
All I could do was give her a tight squeeze, kiss her cheek. I simply didn't understand how she trusted me or any man after all that. Her life had just been miserable from the day she was born.
"Was at the Combat Zone for three years. First year wasn't bad. Last two years, when the raiders arrived, that sucked." She sighed again, shuffling back against me. "I'm tired, Nate. I act tough, and I'm a survivor, but I can't keep doing this. I'm broken. Completely. All I have is memories, all of them horrifying. And I'm in constant pain, not just from the wounds and scars I carry. The Psycho. I know it's killing me. I cough up blood. And the cravings… I know I'm going to overdose by accident one day."
"Can't you just stop?"
"Tried going cold turkey more than once. Last time, I think it nearly killed me. I'm not just an addict, Nate. If I stop, I'll die. Tried killing myself more than once. Wanted to do the job properly. Chewed on a shotgun barrel more times than I count. Never could pull the trigger. Know what you said to me, about not giving up?"
"Never will."
"Well, I guess part of me didn't want to give in either. Never really felt any hope that things would get better, but the day you walked in, shot up the place, then gave me my freedom… Took a while to trust you, of course. Part of me still wonders if you're going to exact payment. But that's on me. I've talked with plenty of others. They all think you're great. Piper loves you. So does Jennifer. So I guess you're the first decent man I've ever met."
I pulled her tight against me. "You'll always be safe with me."
"I know," she said softly, "It's why I've never slept better. Feeling your arms around me…" She trailed off, and I felt the first shake. "Now I know what it feels like to be loved," she whispered, hearing her voice catch more than once. She finally turned to face me, wiping away the tears that freely flowed. She smiled, leaning up to kiss me, and it didn't take long until she straddled my lap, though all she wanted was to cuddle me, lying back on the rug, stroking her back as I always did. "What do you think of me now?"
"Strongest woman I've met. What you've endured… But you're still here, Cait. And that's the most important thing. Still alive. Still fighting. The only question I have is regarding the potential of you and I." She looked up, seeing the immediate nerves. Caressing her cheek with a thumb, I smiled to reassure her. "Nothing like that. I only ask if you can handle sharing me?"
"I've watched you with Piper and Jennifer to reassure myself. But I see how attentive and loving you are with them, and when I close my eyes as I masturbate, I think of you with me now. When we're finally intimate, I'll think of you always. The sea of faces I used to see when I close my eyes will disappear." She grinned. "Plus, your other lovers are cute. I've enjoyed watching the three of you." She paused again before lying her head back on my chest. "Definitely want you in my arse too," she whispered with a giggle.
"Sure?"
"When you do it, it will be because I want it, and I know you'll treat my properly. With affection. Making sure I'm always enjoying it. Trust me, I'm going to cum so hard when you do. Your fingers the other night… No man has ever made me cum, Nate. They never cared. You've already done that with just your fingers. Can't wait to see your face between my legs. When we finally make love, I'm going to cry. I mean a lot, Nate, but they'll be good tears. Happy tears."
"You want privacy that first time?"
"I do, but after that, I would like the others to join us. Can't deny them watching me enjoying your cock like I've watched them." She sighed. "I feel better, Nate. Not perfect, not by a long shot, but telling you all that. You're right, the weight had shifted slightly."
"I hope that, one day, that smile will be permanent, Cait. You're beautiful when you smile." Right thing to say, but that made her cry. "Never heard that, have you?" Not trusting her voice, she just shook her head. "Well, you are. Particularly after you've had a good scrub!" That led to laughing and crying, and plenty more laughing when I started to tickle her. She was soon shrieking with it, gently fighting me off. Then our eyes met, and that next kiss was breath-taking, and led to one hell of a reaction from me, which she felt immediately, managing to grin while we made out.
She managed to undo her trousers, grabbing my wrist and gently sliding it down between us. It was a little awkward, but I managed to get my fingers into her underwear, smiling as she broke the kiss to feel she was already wet. "Just kissing you does that," she murmured, "In fact, you've excited me for longer than I care to admit, Nate."
I could have teased her, but she met my eyes and I knew what she wanted. She was soon moaning, whimpering slightly, kissing me deeply, resting her forehead against mine, begging me to make her cum. I did more than once. After the first one, I pretty much tore her clothes off and asked if she wanted my mouth. She almost cried out yes as I lowered my lips to her body, and now the teasing began. Her nipples were hard enough to cut diamonds, and I gave them plenty attention, feeling her fingers at the back of my head.
Lowering my mouth down her body, soft kisses everywhere, she spread her legs for me as I ran my nose through the hair above her pussy before I took a deep inhale of her scant. Cock felt like steel after that. "Love you scent, Cait," I whispered.
"You do?" she asked softly.
I answered that by running my tongue along her slit. That provoked a loud moan they probably heard back in Sanctuary. "Cait, I'm going to keep going until you say stop. I don't care how long you last. I want you to cum again and again if you can handle it. This is all about you, though I'm going to be very happy doing this."
I loved every second, but I enjoyed even more seeing how her body reacted and the noises she made. It was immediately obvious to me that it was the first time anyone had gone down on her. She spent the first few minutes giggling as well as moaning, and she very quickly realised that I liked to be told when something felt good, because then I'd keep doing it.
Ate her out for at least a couple of hours. I would have kept going, despite the aching jaw by then, but she eventually had such an orgasm, she almost passed out, murmuring that I should stop. So I left a soft trail of kisses up her body until I was resting above her on my forearms, just gazing at her face. She eventually opened her eyes, face lighting up in such a grin, I couldn't help return it.
"Wow," she whispered.
"I'll do that whenever you want, Cait. Trust me on that one."
"Like it?"
"Loved it. Loved watching how your body reacted. And you make some of the most adorable noises when excited, and loved hearing those moans when you cum." That earned a giggle, even bringing slight colour to her face. "First time someone has done that?" She simply nodded. "Well, all the more reason that I do that a whole lot more then."
"And… And maybe the other girls?" she asked uncertainly.
"You'd like some fun with them?"
"I've watched them together. It's very sweet. And…"
"I'm sure they'd love to have fun with you too, Cait."
Lying down on my back, I was amused when she immediately moved to lie on top of my again, simply so I would hold her with one arm, stroke her back with my other hand. She was as relaxed as I'd ever seen her, and no surprise she was soon asleep on me. I didn't mind at all, surprised at how much I really cared for her. Loved Piper. Loved Jennifer. Adored Haylen. And there was no doubt my depth of feeling for Cait was growing more and more each passing day.
She woke up later, stating immediately she was rather hungry. Suggesting that the orgasms had certainly helped her appetite, she giggled as we got up, sharing one last hug while she was naked before she dressed and we returned to Sanctuary. After grabbing a bite to eat, we returned home and sat on one of the couches in the lounge, listening to the radio. I offered her a drink, and she looked unsure. "Moderation," I said, "That's what you need to learn, Cait. We'll get you off the drugs, but as for drink, moderation is key. Don't need to drink an entire bottle alone, four or five of us will share one. That way you'll get a buzz but not be rolling drunk or worse."
"I should probably just quit everything once I'm cured."
"That's your choice, but if you do, you have my support."
She cuddled into me, wrapping an arm around her waist. "You won't give up on me, will you?"
"Never. Like you too much now to walk away."
"I like you a lot too," she whispered.
Piper and Jennifer wandered in later that afternoon, sitting on the other couch. They took one look at me, one look at her, before Jennifer asked Piper, "Think they fucked?"
"Well, Cait has that sort of look that suggests she'd enjoyed more than one orgasm but…"
"His mouth, my pussy," Cait said softly, "My god, I haven't cum that hard in my life. No idea someone could be so good with just his tongue. I haven't been left smiling so much."
"We have another convert, Jenny," Piper exclaimed.
"Do you blame her for that grin though?" Jennifer retorted.
"No, but all I know now is that she's going to want it all the time." Piper then met my eyes. "And you can stop looking so smug, Blue."
"Talk about me as if I'm not here, Piper. I'm enjoying what I'm hearing."
"Well, I'm thinking Jenny and I find our own bed tonight. Not sure if you two are going to make love, but I think an entire day together, just you two, is what Cait needs."
"Thank you," Cait replied.
"Before we go, Nate, any plans considering we've been here for over a week now and, while we've all been busy, I'm sure you're eager to get back on the road?"
"Yes. We're heading east. Tomorrow, maybe the day after. Settlement called Finch Farm has requested our help. It's not far from County Crossing, we can walk there in a day if we leave early enough."
Joining everyone else for dinner as always, a bar had also been built by a couple of the settlers, with shelves now full of all the spirits one could imagine, while a fridge had been given power to keep a selection of beers nice and cool. Not ice cold, but cool enough that it was a reminder of moments in the past. I ended up at a table with my three lovers, and a few of my Minutemen. Many had returned from their jobs, letting me know everything was quiet and, more importantly, civilians at the other settlements were happy.
Jennifer had her own room in another house, taking Piper by the hand, the pair giggling away as they'd enjoyed a couple of drinks. Watching them leave, I couldn't help chuckle, hearing Cait do the same next to me. "They like each other," she said.
"I think they only do things when I'm in bed with them. Think all they'll do is go to bed and crash, but if they end up having a little fun, good for them."
"We should go to bed too," she said.
Taking her by the hand, I led her home. Walking through the front door, I closed it before pulling her towards me, kissing her deeply. When she pulled back, I ran the back of my fingers down her cheek. "Nora would definitely approve," I whispered. The smile that lit up her face was something I'd remember for the rest of my days.
Back in my bedroom, we resumed making out as I felt her hands at my belt and button of my trousers. Wasting no time lowering those and my underwear, she looked down and grinned. "Definitely returning the favour, Nate. I've thought about sucking your cock since I first saw it."
"Sure?"
"Absolutely because I want to do it. And I want you to cum in my mouth." I raised my eyebrows at that. "Again, because I want you to do it." She met my eyes and ensured a broad grin. "Then you can eat my pussy again. But no sex. Not yet."
Watching her carefully get on her knees, Cait proved she could suck cock with the best of them. When looking up at me, smiling despite the cock in her mouth, she was ever so eager to please me, running my fingers through her hair as her head bobbed up and down. I'd been turned on the entire time I'd eaten her out, and now that she was blowing me, no surprise I didn't last all too long. Letting her know I was getting close, all that did was urge her on.
Groaning loudly as I came, she didn't relent for a second, head bobbing up and down even faster, hearing her swallow every spurt. She kept going and I wasn't going to stop her just yet, my cock barely going soft. She was that good.
She stopped simply because I'd cum and knew I'd last far too long until I came again, but she still spent time licking up and down my shaft, stating she was cleaning me up. While she did that, I stripped off before helping her to her feet, kissing her deeply as we helped her undress. Once naked, she pressed herself against me, running my hands down her back towards her arse, making her smile as I gave her very tight arse a good squeeze.
"Think you could ever love…"
"Yes," I stated immediately, "I like you a hell of a lot already, Cait. As I said, strongest woman I've met."
"I'm falling for you, Nate. Never felt this way about anyone before."
Picking her up, she wrapped her legs around me as I lowered both of us to the bed, feeling her hands explore my arms and back. I tried to keep my cock away from her pussy but it was like a magnet, making her giggle whenever it rubbed against her. "Well, think my pussy wants it just as much, Nate," she whispered, "She's desperate for a cock that she actually wants." I raised my eyebrows as that was rather suggestive. She smiled and nodded. "I don't want to wait any longer. I want to make love now."
Looking down to position my cock, I met her eyes again as I gently pushed forward. Her eyes stayed glued to mine as I gently slid inside her. Once I was buried, her eyes lit up and the smile that formed was the largest I'd seen. "I love you," she whispered, "I wanted to be like this before I said it."
"I love you too, Cait."
"You do?" she asked, hearing how unsure she was, perhaps not believing someone would say those words to her.
"I do. Absolutely, whole-heartedly." I kissed her again. "I love you," I said softly.
We spent all night making love. She wanted it a certain way. Soft and tender, and she wanted it to last for as long as we could both manage. No exuberant position changes. The first time we barely moved except she lifted her legs to wrap around me as we picked up a little tempo. When I finally came inside her for the first time, she needed a couple of minutes, wrapping her arms and legs around me tightly.
Having watched my other lovers ride me, Cait definitely wanted to try that. As we relaxed before stating, she admitted that, most of the time, she'd only ever been taken from behind, and she wanted to do that with me so she'd have better memories of it. She wanted that last.
Watching her ride me a few minutes later would live long in both of our memories. She enjoyed it so much, and certainly did once I'd licked my thumb and started to gently fondle her clit. Was worried it would be too much for her. All she did was lean forward and want me to do it harder and faster.
Then she enjoyed one hell of an orgasm, repeating again and again how much she loved me. But she kept on riding me, and I kept on fondling her, and she enjoyed a couple more before she asked me to stop so she could just enjoy riding me.
"Best dick ever," she murmured, giving me a kiss, before she seemed to bounce even faster, "Definitely best dick ever. Going to want this all the time. Want you all the time."
"Okay," I replied.
Only when I felt the urge to cum did I move my hands down to her tight butt, watching her face light up as she knew what I needed. "Going to fuck me now?" I nodded. She leaned down and kissed me. "Please fuck me," she whimpered, "God, I want you to fuck me."
I rolled her onto her back, Cait spreading her legs wide, wrapping her arms around the back of my neck as I started to pump her. It felt wonderful, and when she started to beg me for more, we both started to laugh as we were totally into each other and finally letting loose. Didn't last long and that second orgasm was something else entirely. So good I just left myself buried as I felt her wrap me in arms and legs again.
We both needed a cigarette after that, sitting back side by side in silence, sucking in a few deep breaths, both of us glistening with sweat. "I feel full of cum, Nate," she joked.
"You'll have some more later too."
Finishing our cigarettes, she leaned over and took my cock in her mouth, ensuring I was nice and hard again within a few minutes before she turned away, leaning down to rest her head on the bed, wiggling her cute butt in my direction. She instructed me how she wanted me, sliding inside her and leaning forward so my head was next to hers. As soon as we were both comfortable, she begged me to fuck her hard.
"Are you sure, Cait?" I asked. I didn't want her having bad memories creep up on her.
"Absolutely, because it's you. I want you to fuck me, Nate. Just give me everything you've got. I want it so much. Make me beg. Make me whimper. But, by god, make me cum again."
I made her cum more than once. I enjoyed one more. Then we needed to go to sleep because she was exhausted after a long day where she'd probably cum more in a day and evening than she had in her life. Spooned back against me, I held her tightly against me and, again, it was only then that I realised how small she actually was.
"I love you so much," she whispered, "Always wondered how it would feel to fall in love. Now I know. I can't stop smiling. And I just want to be with you all the time. Definitely like this. I feel like I'm going to just… burst with happiness."
"You'll be by my side no matter where I go from now on, Cait. If I'm at the Castle, you're there with me. If I'm here, so are you. No matter where…"
"I love that idea too." She paused a moment. "Still going to need you from time to time, you know…"
"I know, Cait. I'm not going anywhere."
Waking up the next morning, apart from a little kissing, cuddling, and giggling from Cait as I tried to keep her mood up, we got up, dressed and headed outside. Plenty of people were already up for breakfast, including Piper and Jennifer, joining them at their small table once we'd grabbed a bowl of food.
The pair looked between us again. "You made love," Piper said softly, her face lighting up in a grin. I took Cait by the hand as she leaned her head against me. "Cait, I've never seen you so happy."
"I love him," she whispered.
"No surprise," Jennifer said, "I fell in love with him the first time we made love." I raised eyebrows at that confession. She met my eyes and grinned. "Think about that night all the time, Nate."
"Don't worry, Jenny. I was pretty much the same. Slept with him the same day we met for the first time. God, it was so good." She leaned across, taking Cait's other hand and squeezing it. "And we're both so happy for you. Nate is the best. And I already know how this works. Jenny will stay here. I need to be in Diamond City sometimes. But you, Cait…"
"She's staying with me," I said, "Jennifer, I'd love to take you on the road…"
She shook her head immediately. "I'd be a hindrance, Nate. I know that. I'm happy here working the farm. I'm safe here. Plus, I get the thrill of you returning."
"I still have my paper to worry about, Blue," Piper said, "But I'm not going home just yet. Finding plenty of stories here from the people who have arrived, and your Minutemen too."
"I'd like you to stay as long as you want, Piper," I said.
"God yes, particularly if you treat my pussy…" Jennifer trailed off and cleared her throat, blushing brightly.
"Oh, do tell, Piper," Cait teased.
"We generally only fool around together with Nate, but as you two needed time to yourselves, Jenny was a little horny. So was I, so my pussy got some treatment too."
"Love to taste you, Piper," Jennifer whispered. Piper leaned across and kissed her.
"Could eat your pussy right here on the table, gorgeous," Piper breathed.
"Don't mind us," I said, much to their amusement.
"Don't tempt me, Blue, otherwise I'll strip her naked and…"
"Don't tempt him? I'd love your fingers inside me again right now!"
"Are we leaving today, Blue?" I shook my head, suggesting we'd leave first thing the next morning. Piper took Jennifer by the hand and dragged her away. "We'll go to your room, Blue. Maybe you and Cait can join us later?"
"Sure thing, if Cait…"
"God yes," Cait murmured. We watched them disappear, shared a glance and started to laugh. "At least they're having fun."
"Shame Haylen isn't here," I said, "She'd join in too."
"And you have other lovers?"
"Just the occasional. Woman called Gwen at Vault 81. I really like her. I'll take us all there to visit one day. We can spend a few days somewhere comfortable and warm."
"So you can have sex with her?" I gave her a look which made her grin. "I'm sure she'd leap all over you anyway."
"More than likely. The only other woman I've been intimate with since waking up is Ellie, Nick's secretary at his agency. She's very sweet. I think you'd like her just because of that." I leaned over and kissed her cheek. "And despite the tough exterior, which I understand completely, I think you have a heart of gold inside too."
"You do?"
"You wear an armour from everything you told me happened. You don't need it anymore around me or the others. But it will take time. I know and understand that. As I said, I'm not going anywhere and, if you need my help, you ask and I'll say yes."
"Let's go join Piper and Jenny."
We arrived in time to see Piper on her back, Jennifer's head buried between her legs. Seeing Cait and I walk in, we were invited to join in, the pair of us undressing and joining them on the bed. Piper offered to give Cait some attention, leaving me to sit behind Jennifer and slide my cock inside her. Though a distraction as I gently fucked her, she managed to get Piper off a few times, while Piper seemed to rather enjoy eating out Cait to more than one orgasm too.
I didn't want to cum in Jennifer just yet, as I wanted to please all three of them, so all she did was pull forward, turn around, and blow me to completely, before the three lined up on their backs, spreading their legs before me, each offering rather lewd suggestions as to what I could do with my mouth, fingers and cock. Started out just eating them out, ended very differently.
We barely left the bedroom except to grab dinner that evening. No doubt plenty of people knew exactly what we'd been up to as it was obvious what we'd been up to. The three girls were looking rather rosy cheeked and content with life, while I knew I sat back looking rather smug myself. How could I not with three gorgeous women around me, the three of them laughing and giggling away. I couldn't help grin at how easily the three were getting on. The change in Cait over just a week was astounding. Sanctuary was living up to its name.
After a post-meal cigarette, the three were conspiring quietly as I chatted with a couple of Minutemen. The sun had gone down for the day when they eventually asked me to follow them home. Once back in the bedroom, they quickly got naked and grabbed the bottle of lube from the bedside table. I raised my eyebrows as they sat on the edge of the bed facing me.
"Cait wants anal tonight, Blue. She wants to enjoy it with the man she loves. We've made sure she's certain. Trust me, her words were 'He'd better fuck my arse tonight, or I'm doing something to you instead.' I'd rather you fuck her arse."
"After you've had fun with Cait, Piper and I want it too," Jennifer added, "With Cait, she wants you to fuck her, but still be gentle. I want it like the other night. Just grab my hair and… And god, just thinking about it."
"Me too, Blue. I want that dull ache in the morning feeling." Raised my eyebrows at that admission. "It doesn't hurt at the time, and it doesn't hurt afterwards. It's just that sensation that I know your big cock has slammed my arsehole the night before."
"Didn't know you were a poet, Piper," Cait said with a chuckle.
Piper shuffled closer to Cait, leaning down to her ear. "Bet you can't wait to feel his thick cock slide inside you again, Cait," she whispered, "Feeling it stretch out your tight little arse, the feeling of his body over yours as she slowly starts to pump in and out of you." Piper started to fondle Cait, Jennifer leaning over to kiss her neck. "You'll soon be crying for more, his cock thrusting deeper and deeper, faster and faster. You'll be loving every second, feeling your body and his become one. Your grip on the bedsheets will tighten, you'll raise you arse higher, hoping for a better angle, as you bury your head into the bed, groaning loudly as he dominates your arse. But still you'll want more. Harder. Faster. Deeper. You'll cum harder than you've ever cum before. You'll think it'll hurt, but it won't. He'll simply leave you begging for more and more."
"God, Piper," I murmured. My cock was steel listening to her.
"Then once he's cum inside you, you'll squeeze his cock so he won't pull out, as you're going to want it even more. Head on the back of your head, just his cock slamming your arsehole again and again, building to such a crescendo, you'll pass out from the orgasm. He'll last forever, but you won't complain, enjoying every second you are joined, until he finally cums in you again. Only then will you allow him to pull out as you would have had enough. You'll be amazed at the lack of pain, because despite the hard sex, he's cared about you every step of the way. Then he'll hold you in his arms as you feel his seed drip from you, and all you'll say to him is that you'll want that again and again." She paused and whispered, "Is that what you want, Cait? Is that what you want from him?"
Cait met my eyes and the lust, love and desire in one glance told me it was exactly what she wanted.
"Jesus, Piper, I'm now soaking wet here myself," Jennifer giggled.
"Is that something you'd like to do to all three of us, Blue?" I wasn't sure I could trust my voice so I just grunted, which made the three of them giggle. "Good. Jenny and I will get Cait ready to take your big cock, then it's up to Cait, obviously."
"I want him to fuck me," she stated simply, "God, just like you described, Piper."
Piper and Jennifer had a lot of fun getting Cait ready, particularly as both seemed to enjoy sliding a couple of fingers into her arse, something Cait enjoyed too. But it was all simply so she was ready. Once the three agreed she was, I was lubed up and got into position, taking my time sliding into her. When she started to cry, I almost put a stop to everything. She sat back and assured me they were happy tears. I was the first man to ever be so gentle and caring when doing it. Still stopped and just held her, though she was adamant that she wanted this with me.
When we were both comfortable, I got into the position she wanted, Piper and Jennifer lying to either side. Started out very slowly, watching her face for any discomfort. Nothing but a smile and, being honest, joy on her face. I only started going faster when she asked for it, but I was soon pumping into her nice and fast.
"Knew it would be this good with someone I loved," she moaned, "Someone needs to play with my pussy though. I want to cum harder than ever."
"This is a little amusing, Cait."
"What is, Piper?"
"You've gone from nothing to anal with Blue rather quickly."
Cait just smiled as I kissed her cheek. "Watching him with Jennifer the other night solidified the idea that I wanted to have sex with him first, then I was going to offer him anal, hoping he'd say yes. Now that he's in my arse, and god does it feel ever so good, I'm glad I didn't wait too long." She glanced back at me. "Fuck my arse harder, Blue."
"Blue?" I retorted with a grin.
"Think we'll call you that. Our name for our lover."
Cait enjoyed one hell of an orgasm as both Jennifer and Piper started to fondle her. She begged me to keep going, to go harder and faster until I finally did cum. Lasted for longer than I thought. I constantly checked she was okay, but the smile never left her face. She would occasionally shuffle, feeling I was even deeper if possible. She's moan loudly and just beg for more. When I finally did cum, it was such a relief, I had to relax on top of her, laughing as I felt her squeeze her arse to almost drain my cock of cum.
Then we relaxed together, making sure I wasn't squashing her. "Now that's how anal sex should be," she whispered, turning her head so I could kiss her, "We're doing that again. Definitely doing that again."
"Addictive, isn't it?" Jennifer asked, "That first time I was like 'Wow, okay. Didn't know it would be this good'. Thought it might be one of those special occasion things, but I find myself distracted when I'm working."
Cait gave me fifteen minutes, enough time for a smoke, before she wanted it again. Now that she was over the hump in her mind, as was I regarding doing it with her, that second time was something else entirely, but I'll admit I loved it when she wanted to switch to her riding me. Watching my cock disappear inside her again, then watching her face light up as she rode me, Piper and Jennifer giving her body plenty of attention too. No idea how long she rode me for, but by the time she cried enough, all she did was collapse onto the bed next to me and almost fall asleep.
Piper and Jennifer had to decide who was next, Piper eventually agreeing that Jennifer would go last. Piper wanted something a little different, grabbing a pillow to place under her lower back, and we made love. Didn't stop her asking for it nice and hard, but I always enjoyed watching her face, the expressions she made. When I told her how beautiful she was, she laughed, stating I was just saying that because I was buried in her arse. I retorted, saying that was just a bonus.
As for Jennifer, she had wanted it like Cait, but in the end, she wanted to ride me. I wasn't going to complain, Cait snuggling into me one side, Piper on the other, Jennifer happily riding my cock for as long as she wanted. Having already cum twice, I was going to last until I'd either cum again or she needed to stop. She lasted until I needed to cum again, eventually sliding off me, giggling as she suggested she'd be feeling it in the morning.
"You okay, Blue?" Piper asked after we'd cleaned up and were now snuggling.
"I cannot complain for a second, Piper. I have three women I love in bed with me. We've just had a day of really hot sex, two if you include what we got up to yesterday. Cait is now in a better place…"
"Thanks to you," she whispered, though she was practically asleep.
"Jennifer is happier than I've seen her because we now admit how we feel, and she's happy with her life."
"Definitely," she replied with a yawn.
"Then there is you and I, Piper."
"Love you a little more every day, Blue."
"Feel the same way." I checked the time. "But while we've had fun and relaxed, for good reason, time to get our game faces back on tomorrow. We still have plenty of Commonwealth that needs sorting out."
Despite that, the idea that we'd be back out facing god only knew what the next day, we all slept contentedly that night.