"And because of that, I'm not going to fuck your bottom with my cock like Darian is doing to Larkin," Gage commented.
"What?" she screeched and tried to move away from him.
"Oh, no, you don't," Gage said and lay her over his lap, keeping a hand on her back to hold her in place. "If you settle down, I won't make this horrible for you."
Brylee instantly stilled.
****
"Good girl." Gage smoothed a hand down her back and then shoved her short skirt up to bare her ass. He hit her butt cheeks a few times, never slapping the same place twice or too hard. He dipped a finger down between her legs and gathered her cream that dripped from her. He smiled. It seemed she liked the punishment a little too much.
He drew his finger back to her anus. "Have you ever had anything in your bottom, sweetheart?"
"No," she cried. Her tears dripped to the floor.
"I think you'll probably like it. Since it's your first time, I'll just use one finger and go easy on you."
Brylee released a tense breath and nodded.
Gage's finger circled Brylee's little bottom hole before he stuck just the tip in. Right away, he could feel her tighten her muscles to keep him out. He slapped her ass a few times, grabbed more cream, and pushed his finger in to the first knuckle.
"Ow, I don't like this," she complained.
"One way or another, my finger is fucking your ass. It won't hurt as much if you relaxed your bottom."
Gage grinned when he felt her relax. "I'm proud of you."
Brylee scrunched her eyes closed as though she was concentrating on staying relaxed.
Gage worked his finger into her until he couldn't go any further. He stilled for a moment for her to get used to the feel of being invaded before he started working his digit in and out. It didn't take long for Brylee to begin to come. He listened to her cries of need and moved his finger faster to throw her over.
Her cries mixed with Larkin's and Darian's as all three came.
Gage slowed and then stopped when she collapsed on his lap. He kept his finger deep inside her and used his other hand to smooth over her ass. "You did so good, sweetheart."
"I can't move," she murmured sleepily, draped over Gage's lap.
Darian pulled out of Larkin, tucked his cock away, sat, and lifted her into his lap again. He murmured softly to her as she came down.
"Daddy, is my punishment done?" Larkin asked with her eyes closed as she rested against Darian's chest.
"Yes, baby."
"Can Brylee and I go take a bath?"
"Sure. Gage and I will be out on the patio. Come out when you're done."
****
Darian helped Larkin off his lap, waiting with his hands on her waist until she was steady. She walked around the desk and stabilized her friend when Gage made Brylee stand.
Both men watched as the girls slowly walked out of the room before they turned to each other and grinned.
"That was fucking hot," Gage said.
"I was thinking the same thing. Can you imagine if all five of us had our own littles, and we were all together?" Darian asked.
"It would be something." Gage grimaced and stood. "I'm going to use the shower in my room."