They decided to get the wine from Smith's room first, before heading over to the mayor's room.
Smith gave them a rough description of the villa, so they had some knowledge about where was where.
"How about him, what do we do to him?" Reynolds pointed at Richard.
"Alice." Grey looked at her.
She had the final decision on what would happen to Richard, if she took pity on him and decided they should let him go, then he should count himself lucky. But the group knew given Alice's personality, she probably wouldn't want him to live because of what he thought of doing to her.
"Kill him, keeping him alive doesn't change anything." Alice said decisively.
According to what Smith said, Richard didn't come with the important guests, which meant he wasn't of any use. The group planned to keep Smith alive since he could be used as leverage if by chance things didn't go as planned.