The island of Pologis was not always as friendly as tourists claimed. With a close knit community that knew way too much about everyone but seemingly never enough they struggled to maintain healthy friendships. Being found on tinder would get you judged for not doing things the "good old fashioned" way, the right way. Leo was one such resident, cold and hateful on the outside while tender on the inside, hoping no one would bite back when he went with the crowd against one person.
He held an especially dangerous secret locked away in his little home, he liked men. Leo didn't just like them either, he loved them! In fact he'd started frequenting the beach just so that he could watch the other guys running around on it, his deep green eyes hypnotized by the way sweat glistened on their muscles as they did something as simple as catching a Frisbee!
This had been his hobby for years now, ever since he'd discovered that he liked men. One day he planned on moving to a bigger more accepting place and openly dating any man he pleased, but for now this was where he was stuck. There was an appeal to straight guys though, fantasies of being with them made him feel feminine and accepted. Right now even though he wasn't super tall he was still quite muscular.
Leo was 5'8, a reasonable height for any man but nothing to brag about. On the other hand he was around two hundred and twenty pounds of muscle! That wasn't anything to sneeze at and he was quite proud of it, though the main reason he worked out and looked like this was to ease off suspicion he was gay.
Eventually the young man got tired of watching the others and got up, shaking as much sand as he could off of his shorts. Leo looked around before deciding to walk further down the beach. He found himself walking for what seemed like hours and eventually encountered a cliff face. It was filled with holes, some of them the size of a needle, others gaping caverns. One that he encountered was about eight feet tall and seven feet wide, it then wrapped around a corner that he couldn't see. But he could see light coming out of it!
Leo weighed his choices before deciding to go into the cave and explore, it couldn't be too dangerous! As he walked further in the light became brighter, and he found small cans and items of clothing strewn about. Eventually he reached a cavernous room at the end inside of which was a sleeping bag and a lantern, with a man laying halfway in the bag reading a book.
The man immediately perked up upon hearing Leo's footsteps "whats a guy like you doing out here so late? It's almost nightfall you know?" His voice was different from the others, smooth and deep in a tone that made it hard for Leo to focus, based off his clothes, and lack thereof Leo guessed that this man wasn't from around here.
He paused before responding "I uh, just wanted to go for a walk. What are you doing sleeping in a cave?" Leo asked as he stared at the man who quickly responded "I'm a tourist! And what better way to explore than sleeping out here? Plus it's free, don't like paying three hundred a night for some dingy old hotel room" he says before letting out a big yawn.
Leo nodded and looked around the cave, it looked like he'd been here for quite a few days. "What's your name?" The man smiles "you can call me Josh" his deep voice rang throughout the cave effortlessly, and as Leo looked back to him he saw an intense hunger in the large man's deep brown eyes.
"This towns quite pleasant, not very diverse though. Tried to sign up for tinder and there's not a single other guy available" Josh says as Leo looked at him with shock "you went on tinder? And you signed up to see guys? God you're lucky you didn't get crucified! Though I guess they're more lenient since you aren't from here.." Josh raised an eyebrow at him "then how do you find other guys?" His heart dropped, Leo thought he was great at hiding it, how could this guy tell it at a glance "i.. well I haven't, but how did you..?" Josh laugher, clenching his chest as he accidentally choked on his own spit "no straight man has trouble not staring at another guy's crotch"
Josh stood up, revealing his full height of around 6'3, that look in his eyes had only intensified "but you've never been with anyone huh? Have you worked yourself out a bit? I'd love to be with you but if you've never put anything up there you couldn't take me without some damage" he gulped as he approached the smaller man "I wouldn't want to damage you"
Leo wanted to back away but found himself unable to move away from the other man, he was mesmerized "yeah I've done some stuff" he paused "I managed to sneak a dildo and it's pretty easy to get lube" Josh reached forward, callused hands peeling off Leo's shirt "and how big was it?" He paused to think "I believe it's around six inches and this thick" he held his hand up to show the width of the dildo.
Josh grinned as he began tugging Leo's shorts down "well I'm around seven inches, but I think I'm thick enough you wouldn't be able to measure it with just one hand" after removing everything but Leo's boxers Josh began to taking off his belt and pants until he was in just his boxers aswell. The bulge in his boxers made it clearly visible that the man wasn't lying