Chapter 4015 - 3

Joanna's voice right behind me startled me. "Kaitlyn, Brandon is the only one who's not naked. Would you remedy that please?"

As Kaitlyn and I switched positions, Joanna walked away from us. Joanna said, "My plan for getting Kaitlyn to talk to me worked great. I was surprised at how well it worked. In no time, Kaitlyn was frequently inviting me over to talk about you, Brandon. I knew she had feelings for you, and I did everything in my power to encourage them. The more she crushed on you, the more she valued my friendship. She became my champion, taking me to almost all the gatherings she was invited to. When my relationships turned disastrous, she was always there to pick me up."

While Joanna said that, Kaitlyn had slowly pulled down my boxers. She alternated between looking at my hard cock and looking up at me with a big smile on her face. Once I stepped out of my boxers, I took her hand and helped her up off the floor and onto the chair.

Joanna was now standing behind Kaitlyn's chair. She said to me, "Go ahead. Go down on my best friend. Make her happy." Then to Kaitlyn, "This is what you want. All those times we talked about Brandon. You wanted him to make you cum, didn't you?" Kaitlyn spread her legs wide as I moved close to her pussy. I saw Joanna had a comb in her hand, and she started combing Kaitlyn's hair. "And I encouraged her to want that. So it's really on me that she so badly wants you."

I looked up at Kaitlyn and took a moment to admire her beauty. She had a light tan now, so the paleness of her crotch and tits provided an interesting contrast. I loved her curves, her smooth skin, her ample tits, her pretty face, and her gorgeous hair. I gave her a smile of appreciation and moved my mouth to her pussy.

I parted Kaitlyn's pussy lips and took my first taste of her juices, causing her to moan loudly. I liked Kaitlyn's taste; it was slightly lighter than Joanna's. I slowly explored her pussy with my tongue while listening to how she reacted. She was so much louder than Joanna. Several times at the lake house, I had felt like I had been making Kaitlyn moan when I was having sex with Joanna, but it was much, much better now that I knew Kaitlyn's every moan really was because of me.

Incredibly, Joanna continued talking while I ate out my sister in front of her. "When Kaitlyn asked you to ask me out, I knew I didn't have a chance with you, that our relationship would last only for the summer like you promised Kaitlyn. And then to my surprise, we started having a lot of fun together. But I always felt like I was just a fun girl to you; that you never took me seriously. You never talked about your feelings with me or the future. So at the lake house, I found myself encouraging you to be involved with your sister. It was like I wanted to see if what worked with Kaitlyn would work with you. I suggested you kiss on Kaitlyn's neck and shoulder as a lesson for Paul. Kaitlyn loved you doing that, as I knew she would, but you enjoyed it too. But you didn't want to admit you enjoyed it."

I licked down Kaitlyn's pussy, concentrating on the outer lips. Her slightly rough skin felt good on my tongue. I planned to drive her wild by licking every inch of her pussy before making her cum. When I reached the bottom of her pussy, I lapped up the flood of juices she was producing. I moved over to the other lip and slowly licked my way up. When I got to the top, I teased her clit for a little while, testing Kaitlyn's response to different ways of stimulating her clit with my tongue. Kaitlyn had her hands on my head and ran her fingers through my hair as she continued to loudly moan.

"Kaitlyn wanted to do more with you, and I let her talk me into it. I could tell how much you were attracted to her, which made me a little jealous. But I felt like you really paid attention to what I said for the first time as you struggled with your emotions. And you were appreciative that I didn't judge you for what you did with Kaitlyn. I felt your feelings for me deepened because I was okay with you having feelings for Kaitlyn."

I made another lap around Kaitlyn's pussy and went back to her clit. Kaitlyn was moaning constantly now. She seemed to react the strongest when I licked the left side of her clit. Her hands were off my head now as she lay back and enjoyed me tonguing her closer and closer to an orgasm. She seemed in heaven.

"I didn't know how things would play out. After the week, would you go back to treating me as just your fun girl? Or was this the start of a new phase in our relationship? I let Kaitlyn talk me into escalating things to find out."

I looked up at Joanna. She was combing Kaitlyn's hair, like she had done so many times before. There was something crazy about her doing such a mundane thing while I ate out my sister as Joanna spilled secrets. I made another lap around Kaitlyn's pussy before deciding the outer lips were stimulated enough, and it was time to focus on her clit.

"And then Kaitlyn sent Paul home, and you told me that you loved me. And the way you told me that made it clear that I wasn't just your fun girl, but someone you wanted to be with long-term. And then Kaitlyn brought up us living together. You surprised me by saying you wanted to live with me at college. I was so happy."

I danced the tip of my tongue around the left side of Kaitlyn's clit, trying different angles to see how she'd respond. She seemed to respond enthusiastically to everything I did. "Oh! Oh! Oh!" I suspected she was close to cumming.

"I got everything I wanted, thanks to my best friend. But my best friend still didn't get what she wanted most."

Kaitlyn gripped my head suddenly. I continued to flick her clit as she let out a massive "YYYEEEEESSS!" She bucked her crotch erratically as she came. I had made my sister cum! I stopped my licking but kept my face in her pussy as she continued to spasm. When she stopped, I pulled back and sat on my haunches. I looked up and saw a euphoric look on Kaitlyn's face. I smiled. She said, "That was incredible."

Joanna continued combing Kaitlyn's hair like nothing out of the ordinary was going on. "I know both of you love each other, and I know both of you love me. And I think my acceptance of you loving each other has made you two love me more." Joanna stopped combing Kaitlyn's hair. She tucked the comb under one of her arms and quickly braided Kaitlyn's hair. She formed it into a complex design that looked like a crown on the front and sides, and a waterfall in the back. It was like Joanna wanted Kaitlyn to look her most gorgeous. Joanna looked down at me and said, "I'm going to our bedroom. Give my best friend what she wants the most in the world. And then come to bed with me."

Joanna walked off. I stood up and took Kaitlyn's hand. She stood up and asked, "Do you want to do this?"

"Yes. You're my sister, but you're also a beautiful woman that I love. I enjoy being with you. You're great to live with. I very much want to know what it's like to make love to you."

Kaitlyn smiled, and we walked hand in hand toward her bedroom. When we got there, I pulled back the covers as she got out a beach towel. Once she had spread the towel out, she said, "I want to be on top."

"Okay."

I laid down on my back. Kaitlyn clambered over me, positioning my cock between her pussy lips. She then put her hands outside each of my shoulders and slowly lowered her head until our lips met. As we kissed, Kaitlyn pulled her hips forward and back, sliding her pussy along my cock. I could feel her wetness coating my cock as she did so. My desire to fuck my sister had been building since it seemed like a possibility when Joanna told me to kiss her neck. I had thought I couldn't want Kaitlyn much more when I professed my love for her, but she was driving my lust higher and higher as she slid her pussy along my cock.

Kaitlyn reached back with one hand guided my cock inside of her. She slid back again, and this time my cock went deep within her. She felt amazing. She was so wet and yet so tight. I loved it as every inch slid into her until I was buried completely inside of her.

Kaitlyn pushed herself up, shifted her position, and kept straightening until she was upright with her hands behind her head, elbows high and to the side. She thrust out her chest for me to admire.

I said, "You look like a goddess."

Kaitlyn smiled, and held the position for a few moments before leaning forward while putting her hands on my shoulders. She whispered softly in my ear, "Fuck your goddess."

I had been keeping my hands lightly on Kaitlyn's ass, but now I firmly grabbed her and bounced her up and down on my cock. I was fucking Kaitlyn! Every time I thrust into her, she moaned huskily. When she had told me at the lake house that she wanted to fuck me, it had freaked me out. It had been too much too fast for me to handle. And then the opportunity seemed to have passed by when she had sent Paul home. But I hadn't forgotten what she had said. I had thought about it regularly at work and when she was wearing a bikini at the pool. I didn't think I'd fuck her - I had no intention of making a move on her and would have rejected any move she made on me - but I grew to accept that it was something I wanted and would enjoy. And now, thanks to Joanna, I was doing it.

Kaitlyn leaned forward, brought her hands down to outside my shoulders and supported her upper body as I fucked her at a different angle. I was sliding my cock in and out of her slick, grasping pussy, and it was heaven. I loved listening to Kaitlyn loudly moan as she impaled herself. As we fucked, her perfect tits danced up and down wildly. I couldn't take my eyes off of them.

Kaitlyn noticed me staring at her tits. "You like?"

"I love. Sit up straight for a moment."

Kaitlyn sat straight up in her goddess pose and held that position. She was so fucking beautiful. I reached up and took her tits in my hands, squeezing them lightly. They were still a wonder to me, and I still had difficulty believing that I was holding them.

Kaitlyn suddenly leaned forward, resuming her position just above my body. My hands automatically resumed their position gripping her ass, and I was sliding her up and down on my cock again. She said, "Joanna said for you to give me what I wanted most in the world. And that was for you to fuck me."

I smiled. "Aye aye, Captain."

After a few more thrusts, Kaitlyn said, "Dear God, it feels so good. I've wanted this for so long, and it's as good as I'd hoped it'd be."

Girl-on-top was not my favorite position. I could tell I was getting close to cumming, and I didn't like cumming in that position. "Mind if we switch positions?"

"Not at all."

Kaitlyn got off of me.

"Doggie-style?" I suggested.

"Sounds great."

Kaitlyn dropped to her hands and knees. I moved behind her. "I want to be looking at your gorgeous ass when I cum in you."

"You think I have a gorgeous ass?" Kaitlyn said as she looked back at me.

I slid my cock into Kaitlyn. "I think all of your body is gorgeous."

Kaitlyn looked forward again. "Fuck me, Brandon. Fuck me like I've always wanted you to."

I grabbed Kaitlyn by the waist and started fucking her. She slammed her ass back to meet each of my thrusts. Our speed picked up and soon I was pounding Kaitlyn as hard as I could. I didn't know if it was the position or what, but Kaitlyn talked to me now instead of just moaning.

"God yes! God yes! It feels so good. Fuck me, Brandon. Fuck your sister. Give it to me. Give it to me hard. Uh! Uh! Uh! Like that! Fuck me like that!"

I fucked Kaitlyn with everything I had. She was an incredible woman and an incredible sex partner. It felt so great to be fucking her, to hold her firm ass as I thrust into her over and over. My heart was pounding with exertion and excitement.

"Oh, God! Oh, God! I love it! I love it!"

I loved it too. The pleasure was so intense that I knew I wasn't going to last much longer. I continued fucking Kaitlyn hard, savoring every thrust. Kaitlyn stopped talking and was now only making low grunts. We were both soaked with sweat. I could feel myself getting closer and closer to the edge. Finally, I went over. I felt an explosion of pleasure, and I was cumming in Kaitlyn. I felt so good to squirt load after load into her. I slowed steadily as each spurt got smaller until I finally stopped. I collapsed, leaning gently on Kaitlyn's back while keeping my cock inside of her.

"That was incredible," I panted out.

"I loved it. I loved every second of it."

"I love you, Kaitlyn."

"I love you too, Brandon."

I stood up, pulled out of Kaitlyn, and flopped down on my back on her bed. "Tired. That was a hard fuck."

Kaitlyn stretched her legs out and stayed on her stomach. She raised herself up and gave me a kiss. "Thanks. For giving me what I wanted most."

"I wanted it too."

"I'm glad. But I've wanted it for years. Have you?"

"No." I shook my head. "Only since last week."

"I'm glad you wanted me. And I'm immensely grateful to Joanna for letting us have this time together." Kaitlyn pulled back and rolled onto her side. "And speaking of your girlfriend, you should go to her. I don't want you to overstay."

"Okay."

I gave Kaitlyn another kiss on the lips, climbed off the bed and staggered off. In the living room, I noticed that mine and Joanna's clothes were gone. I opened the door to our bedroom and walked in. Joanna was reading her tablet on our bed naked. "Did you have fun?" she asked.

"Yes."

"Good. Now fuck me like you fucked your sister."

* * * * Chapter 5 * * * *

The next morning, I woke up lying on my back. Joanna in the night had rolled off my shoulder like she had been doing and was asleep on her side next to me. I gently reached out and guided her to put her head back on my shoulder. "I love you," I said.

"I love you too." Joanna kissed me on the cheek before snuggling into me.

"Are you okay with last night?" I asked gingerly.

"Yes. It was my choice. The bigger question is are you okay with last night?"

"I think so." My thoughts swirled, but not nearly as much as at the lake house. "Kaitlyn and I are adults. We did what we wanted to do. Everything was consensual. Hopefully, it won't ruin our relationship or damage my relationship with you."

"I don't think it'll damage our relationship. Quite the opposite. Do you love me more for letting you have last night?"

I squeezed Joanna. "I do. I think I do."

"I don't think you have a fixed amount of love, and that if you love Kaitlyn more, then you'll love me less. You can love me more while loving Kaitlyn more. So, I'm hoping last night will strengthen all our relationships. But we'll have to wait and see on that."

"Yeah. We'll have to wait and see." I laid there in a kind of awe over last night. That Joanna would let me and encourage me to have sex with another woman. That sex would be so great with Kaitlyn. I knew it was wrong in many ways, and yet it had felt so right. And all those thoughts kept circling back to one question that I eventually asked Joanna. "Will you let Kaitlyn and me do that again?"

"Maybe. I'll have to see how it goes." Joanna moved off of my shoulder and moved back a bit, so she was lying on her side facing me. "I really enjoyed the nights at the lake house. The sex on those nights was extra special. I'm thinking about doing something similar this summer, but only once every week or two. What do you think of that?"

"Sounds awesome." How could I not like it?

Joanna moved back to put her head on my shoulder. "I'll talk to Kaitlyn about it. I want to see how things go between the three of us for a while before committing to anything."

"Okay."

"Now, I want to sleep some more."

I kissed Joanna on the forehead. "I love you." I ran my fingers through her hair until she dropped off to sleep, and then I went back to sleep too.

* * * *

Joanna took first shower, so she was talking with Kaitlyn when I came out for breakfast. I made a couple of toaster strudels before sitting down at the dining table with them. It was like everything had changed and yet nothing had changed. We didn't mention last night. Instead, we talked like we normally talked, and then I rushed off for work. As I worked, I wondered what Joanna and Kaitlyn were talking about. And I remembered making love to Kaitlyn last night. It had been special. It had been very, very special. At the same time, it didn't keep me from wanting to make love to Joanna. The more I thought about it, the more I liked Joanna's idea of having a night like at the lake house occasionally. Not often enough to disrupt Joanna's and my relationship, but often enough that I wouldn't feel tempted to do something with Kaitlyn without Joanna's approval.

Tuesday night, I was on the couch playing a game on my phone. Kaitlyn came out and said to Joanna, "Got the shopping list ready?"

"Here it is."

Kaitlyn said to me, "Let's go shopping."

When I started driving, I said, "You were right at the lake house when you said Joanna and I should live together this summer. It's worked out great. Joanna has been super easy to live with. We've had a few problems, but they haven't been big. It's good dealing with those initial problems now while the stress is low and not at college when Joanna and I both have papers due. I hope you're not angry that I rejected your suggestion."

"No, I'm not angry at all. Do you mind if I talk about my feelings for you? That I love you and am sexually attracted to you?"

I thought for a moment. I was slightly uncomfortable with the idea of talking about our feelings and our being sexually attracted to each other but decided it was stupid to not discuss them. "I don't mind. Joanna knows we love each other and are sexually attracted to each other. I don't see why we can't discuss it."

"Okay, so I wasn't angry that you argued with me. In fact, it got me quite hot. I loved that you weren't letting me have my way, that you weren't letting me manipulate you into accepting something you didn't want. I always want you to push back when you disagree with me. Your willingness to do so is one of the reasons I'm so attracted to you."

"I'll keep that in mind." I laughed. "This is all so crazy. Here I am talking with my sister about how we love each other and what attracts me to you, and I know my girlfriend is okay with it. Is this really fine? Is this going to blow up some day?"

"Well..."

"Let me ask you about something else before you answer that. Were you surprised by what happened Saturday?"

"Yes and no. Did I have any idea Joanna would do that? No. But her giving me what she knew I wanted didn't surprise me. That's the way we are - we do things for each other."

"Did anything she said surprise you?"

"Yes. I had no idea she had used you to become my best friend. But that doesn't matter to me as she's my best friend for a mountain of reasons. I'm glad she's accepting of you and me, regardless of how she started down that path. And it surprised me that she had encouraged you and me at the lake house as a way of deepening your relationship."

"I was surprised by those things, but the biggest surprise to me was that she was so okay with us loving each other, and in fact that she saw that as a good thing. The next morning, she told me she didn't think I had a fixed amount of love, so that loving you more didn't mean I would love her less."

"That's my hope too. Have you heard of the TV show, 'Seeking Sister Wife'?"

"No."

"I came across it when I was looking for ideas of how the three of us could get along living together. I watched some clips, and I felt so sad for the women. For the two families I watched clips of, it was like the guy went out one day and happened to pick up a second wife. If one of my boyfriends had picked up a second girlfriend while he was out, I would have dumped him as soon as he introduced her. And the two wives had the same roles, being the stay-at-home mom. Once the second wife moved in, the first wife was redundant. There didn't seem to be anything in it for the first wife about having a second wife. It was all about the guy wanting another woman to fuck."

"Okay." It sounded like a show that wouldn't appeal to me.

"It really affected me. I was like, 'Joanna and I aren't going to be like this.' So I've tried hard to be complementary to Joanna and not redundant. Joanna has her role, I have my role, and there's little overlap. If Joanna and I were both to cook, then there would be competition about which of us cooked better. And there'd be arguments about how to organize the kitchen. So I've let Joanna own the kitchen, and I've encouraged you to help her cook so that cooking will be your time together. I go do other things while she's cooking. Making the beds and doing grocery shopping are the things we do together. And they're also things that Joanna doesn't want to do. So my presence in the household makes Joanna's life better, and Joanna's presence in the household makes my life better. So you can love Joanna for who she is and what she does, and you can love me for who I am and what I do, and not feel conflicted because Joanna and I have different roles and don't compete."

I hadn't noticed that Joanna and Kaitlyn had different roles, but now that Kaitlyn pointed it out, I knew it was true. "And part of Joanna's role is to be my girlfriend."

"True. One of the things I realized at the lake house is that I can't be your girlfriend. And as she's your girlfriend, you are to be faithful to her. She gets to decide if she wants to share you with me. And I need to build her trust in me that I'll never do anything with you she hasn't given her approval to."

I turned that over. "I'm really happy, and it's easiest to give Joanna all the credit as she is my girlfriend. I'm having good time after good time with her. Every day, I feel more and more compatible with her. I feel I'm falling more and more in love with her. But you're there too. I'm having good time after good time with you. Every day, I feel more and more compatible with you. I also have that feeling of falling more and more in love with you. But because you're not my girlfriend, it's easy to not think about that."

"I'm glad to hear that you feel like you're falling more and more in love with me as I feel like I'm falling more and more in love with you."

"Where is this going?"

"We'll see." I had the feeling Kaitlyn knew where she wanted it to go but didn't want to say.

"Are you going to live with me and Joanna in the fall?"

"I think it's too early to decide."

There was something to waiting, but I felt like Kaitlyn had already decided and was just being cagey.

* * * *

Over the next week, I realized that there was quite a bit of sexual tension between Kaitlyn and me. Joanna had to have seen it. Having sex with Kaitlyn had discharged it for a while, but by Saturday I could feel it building again. Nothing too overt; just an occasional subtle sign from Kaitlyn that she wanted me, and I'm sure I made the occasional subtle sign that I wanted her. But otherwise, the week didn't feel any different than the week before. I still loved Joanna and did my best to show it every day. I still enjoyed spending time with Kaitlyn, sometimes alone like when we made the beds together, but most commonly while we were with Joanna. If anything, I got along with both of them better.

Sunday night as Joanna and I were cuddling after sex, she said, "Tomorrow, Kaitlyn and I will start planning something special for next weekend. Some fun to discuss as we drive to work."

"I'll look forward to next weekend."

As the week progressed, Joanna and Kaitlyn got increasingly giggly. Kaitlyn had taken Mom's sewing machine, and Friday evening I heard sewing sounds behind the closed door to Kaitlyn's bedroom. Saturday morning, Joanna finally gave me a clue. "We're going out to a Polynesian restaurant tonight."

"Okay." A surprising thing about Joanna was that she liked to try ethnic restaurants she had never eaten in before. "What do they serve at a Polynesian restaurant?"

Kaitlyn said, "Polynesian food, Silly." Both girls laughed uproariously.

Joanna said, "And don't look it up. Let it be a surprise."

"Tonight is going to be lots of surprises," added Kaitlyn. "We're counting on you being a good sport and going along with them as they happen."

"I'll be a good sport." It was easy to be a good sport when I knew that playing along would result in a night of hot making out and even hotter sex. "Off to work."

"Call when you leave work," said Joanna. "And when you get here, go straight to our bathroom and take a shower. The clothes you are going to wear will be laid out on the bed."

When my workday was over, I did just as I was instructed. I didn't see Joanna or Kaitlyn as I crossed from the apartment door to my bedroom. I stopped and looked at the clothes. It was a normal pair of jean shorts and a bright green shirt that I hadn't seen before. The material was cotton and had a wild print of flowers of different sizes. It was so bright; I'd be like a walking neon sign.

I showered and put my clothes on. My hands trembled as I buttoned up my shirt. I was very excited for tonight and wondered what the girls had planned.

When I stepped out of the bedroom, Kaitlyn and Joanna were doing something at the dining table. They were both wearing blouses made from the same print as mine but in different colors. Kaitlyn's was a bright blue, and Joanna's was a bright orange. I said, "I'm ready to go."

"Just a minute", said Kaitlyn. "Joanna is almost done."

Joanna did something and then lifted up a string that had several flowers on it. Kaitlyn took the string and lifted it over Joanna's head. I realized that the string was a loop with flowers on the bottom. As I got close, I could see that the blouses Kaitlyn and Joanna were open in the front, something like a vest. Below their blouses, each was wearing a white, knee-length skirt. As I got a closer look at the front of their blouses, I could see that each was wearing several strings of flowers in the open area in the front of their blouse. Neither was wearing a bra, so the flowers were the only coverage of the middle of their chests. With both of them, I could clearly see the side of their tits, about a quarter of each one.

Joanna and Kaitlyn turned to me and stood up straight to model their outfits. Kaitlyn's hair was braided with flowers occasionally worked in. "What do you think?" asked Joanna.

"You're beautiful. Both of you are beautiful. And sexy. Are you wearing anything under those blouses?"

Kaitlyn opened her blouse quickly, giving me a flash of her naked tit. "Nothing," she said with a big smile.

Joanna said, "You'll have to do almost everything for us tonight, so we can keep our blouses closed."

I didn't know how this would work, but it sounded like an intriguing night.

We got into Kaitlyn's car; she was driving, and Joanna and I got in the back seat. As soon as we were buckled in, Joanna took my hand and slipped it under her blouse. "You have to keep your hand below the flowers. Can't have you damaging them."

As I ran my hand over her bare stomach, I said, "You're so naughty."

Joanna laughed. "And you love your naughty girl?"

"I very much love my naughty girl."

We made out the whole drive to the Polynesian restaurant. When we stopped, Joanna unbuckled her seat belt and then opened her blouse wide open to show me her whole chest. She quickly closed it and laughed. I got out of the car and went around to her door. When I opened it, she flashed me again before getting out. Kaitlyn was still sitting in the driver's seat. When I opened her door, she flashed me too before getting out.

I adjusted my hard cock as we walked away from the car. There wasn't anyone outside the restaurant. When I opened the doors, there were several groups waiting to be seated. I could see the eyes of several guys go wide when they got a look at Joanna and Kaitlyn. Kaitlyn went over to the hostess and told her that we had reservations. We were quickly seated. Normally at restaurants, Joanna sat to my right and Kaitlyn to my left, and I'd hold Joanna's hand on the table to make it clear that she was my girlfriend. This time, Kaitlyn sat across from me, and Joanna didn't hold my hand as she was keeping her blouse closed. We had Pot Stickers as an appetizer, and then the girls split a Maui Pineapple Chicken while I had a Kalua Pork. I sampled the girls' plate, and they sampled mine. The food was good. Not a restaurant I would have chosen, but it was good while being different. The girls were on their best behavior inside the restaurant, with no flashing and a concerted effort to keep their blouses from getting too open. Still, it was quite distracting to look across at Kaitlyn and see so much bare tit, and the angle I had with Joanna meant I could frequently get dark glimpses of her whole right tit. I was hard the whole meal.

When we were outside after the meal, I said, "Every guy had their eyes on you two the whole time we were in there."

Joanna and Kaitlyn laughed. I took Joanna's hand as we walked toward the car. The parking lot was dark with no one in sight, so I wasn't worried about accidental exposures now. Joanna and Kaitlyn talked about the many times guys had eating failures as they stared at them and also the many dirty looks women gave their men. They had very much enjoyed themselves.

"You two are so naughty," I said as we approached the car.

"We're about to get naughtier," said Joanna as she took the keys from Kaitlyn. I opened the driver's door for her, and she gave me a big flash once she sat down. I opened the door behind her for Kaitlyn, and she too gave me a big flash once she sat down. I went around to the other side and got in with Kaitlyn. Once I had my seatbelt on, I turned toward Kaitlyn. She took my hand and slipped it under her blouse. She said, "You don't have to worry about damaging the flowers now," as she bent forward to kiss me.

* * * *

I held open the door to our apartment, and the girls slipped in. I followed after them and closed the door. They smiled at each other as they moved over to halfway between the couch and the dining table. When I joined them, Joanna positioned me between her and Kaitlyn with me facing her. "You are overdressed," she said. She began unbuttoning my shirt. "Don't use your hands until we tell you to. Just stand there."

Once Joanna had my shirt unbuttoned, she opened it. I felt Kaitlyn take it off my shoulders and pull it off me. Joanna said, "The big spin begins." She moved to my left and Kaitlyn moved in front of me from my right.

Kaitlyn dropped to her knees in front of me. "Have you had a good time so far?" she asked sultrily while undoing my shorts.

"I've had a great time so far."

I could feel both Joanna and Kaitlyn grab my shorts and pull them down.

"Good," said Kaitlyn. "Joanna and I will try to keep that up." As Kaitlyn stood up, she slid her hand up my hard cock. "And you keep this up too." When she was fully standing, she said seductively, "Kiss me. And remember, no hands."

I leaned forward and kissed Kaitlyn while keeping my hands at my side. I so wanted to cup her tits again like I had in the car, but I knew to follow the rules. The girls were apparently going to do their best to drive me crazy before we had sex.

As I kissed Kaitlyn, I felt Joanna rub her butt against mine. She rubbed it side-to-side a few times, and then she circled her butt around mine twice. God, that was hot. It was amazing to feel one pressed against me sexually while the other kissed me. When Joanna removed her butt from mine, Kaitlyn stopped kissing me. She moved around me as Joanna moved in front of me. I could see that Joanna had taken off her skirt and was now wearing only white cotton panties below her blouse. She had spread the blouse further open so I could now see about half of each tit. Joanna put her hands on the side of my chest and asked, "Do you love your naughty girl?"

I smiled at her. "I love my naughty girl very much."

Joanna kissed me, and then rubbed her hands over my chest as we continued to kiss. I felt Kaitlyn press her butt against mine. As Joanna had done, Kaitlyn rubbed her butt side-to-side and then in a circle. When Kaitlyn moved her butt away from mine, the girls switched positions. Kaitlyn too had removed her skirt and was now wearing only white cotton panties below her blouse. She too had spread the blouse further open. She too put her hands on the side of my chest. "Do you love me, Brandon?"

"I love you very much." It was the first time that I had told Kaitlyn I loved her in front of Joanna. It was a little uncomfortable, but Joanna knew that I loved Kaitlyn. Then I realized that Joanna had set it up so I'd tell Kaitlyn 'I love you' in front of her.

Kaitlyn smiled and kissed me. As we kissed, I felt Joanna's bare tits press against my back. Joanna kissed my back and rubbed her hands across it while dragging her tits slowly all over it. I was in sensory overload. When Joanna lifted her tits from my back, Kaitlyn ended the kisses and moved behind me. When Joanna moved in front of me, I could see the flower strings were gone. The blouse was now wide open and the top of it was partially down her shoulders. There was no sign that Joanna was angry with me for saying I loved Kaitlyn. In fact, she looked extremely happy.

"You're so beautiful," I said.

Joanna smiled, took my hands and lifted them to her tits as she kissed me. As we kissed, I felt Kaitlyn press her bare tits against my back. It was such a weird feeling, to be holding one set of tits while feeling another pressed into me. But it was also an absolutely wonderful feeling. When Kaitlyn took her tits off of me, the girls changed positions again. Kaitlyn also had removed the flower strings and had her blouse as Joanna had had.

"You're so beautiful," I told her. I was such a lucky guy to have two beautiful, wonderful women in love with me and okay with me having sex with the other.

As I kissed Kaitlyn, I felt Joanna press her back against me. It was kind of an odd feeling, her sliding her back all over mine. I cupped Kaitlyn's tits and played with her nipples as Joanna moved her back up and down mine. Again, sensory overload. At the same time, I was thinking we were getting close to the end of this phase. What would happen next?

When Joanna moved her back off mine, Kaitlyn moved to the back as Joanna moved in front of me. As I expected, she was wearing only her panties now. "Like what you see?" she asked.

"Very much so."

"You are to use your hands now below my tits."

I dropped my hands to Joanna's waist and held her firmly. "This has been so special and memorable for me. I hope it's been that way for you."

"It has! I'm really happy with how it has turned out."

Joanna kissed me. I dropped my hands down and squeezed her ass as we kissed. Kaitlyn began pressing her back against mine. I slipped my hands into Joanna's panties to squeeze her ass directly. She kissed me more vigorously. As I kissed and groped, I couldn't help wondering what the next thing would be. I couldn't think of what Joanna could press into me from behind.

Kaitlyn pulled her back off of me and the girls changed positions again. Kaitlyn too was only in her panties. She too asked me, "Like what you see?"

"Very much so."

I dropped my hands down and squeezed Kaitlyn's ass as we kissed. I felt Joanna lightly pushing me toward Kaitlyn's bedroom. Kaitlyn and I slowly walked that way while kissing. Once we were in Kaitlyn's bedroom, Joanna said, "See you in a while, Brandon," and closed the door.

Kaitlyn grabbed my hand and pulled me over to the bed. "If you're anything like me, you're ready to cum." She sat down on the bed and pulled down my boxers. Once my boxers were off me, she grabbed my cock and guided it to her mouth. The warmth and wetness of her mouth felt wonderful. She slid her lips down my cock and then back up again, sending waves of pleasure through my body. She bobbed a few more times, and it was too much.

"I'm cumming," I warned her.

Kaitlyn kept bobbing until I was shooting jet after jet of hot spunk down her throat. Kaitlyn never slowed, and quickly sucked down my full load. Once I was drained, Kaitlyn released my cock and scooted back onto the bed. I noticed that the covers were pulled down and a towel was on the bed. Kaitlyn quickly yanked off her panties and said, "Now my turn." I moved to give her oral sex, but she grabbed my hand and brought it to her pussy. "Like that."

I slipped my fingers inside her pussy lips and found her soaking wet. Kaitlyn grabbed my chest and yanked me next to her. She kissed me frantically as I worked her clit, and then she threw herself back on the bed. "Yes! Oh, God! Yes! Oh! Oh!" I worked her clit hard and fast. "Oh, God! Oh, God!" Kaitlyn arched her back. "YEEESSS!"

I worked her clit for a little bit more before letting her finish cumming. Once she resumed breathing normally, Kaitlyn said, "Fuck me, Brandon. Fuck me good and hard. I want you so bad."

I moved between Kaitlyn's legs. She grabbed my cock and guided it inside of her. I slid in part way, pulled back and then slid all the way in as Kaitlyn raised her crotch to meet mine. Kaitlin rotated her hips and raised her legs, so her feet were up in the air. I was fucking her almost straight down. Slam! Slam! Slam! Slam! Slam! Each time I fucked her, I'd press Kaitlyn into the bed, and each time, I'd pulled back, she'd almost bounce off the bed. I had never fucked a girl from this angle before. And both Kaitlyn and I were fucking frantically. My heart was pounding with the exertion of fucking her so hard.

To take a quick break, I bent forward and kissed my sister. Kaitlyn grabbed a hold of my lower lip and held it as I slowly pulled back from her. She released it just as it was about to pull out of her mouth.

"I love you so much, Brandon."

"I love you too, Kaitlyn."

"You feel so good inside of me. I've wanted to fuck you for so long, and it feels so right now that we're doing it."

I went back to fucking Kaitlyn. I moved my arms inside her legs so she could rest her legs on them. Another angle that I had never fucked in before. I was looking down now into my sister's beautiful face as I fucked. She had a look of pure bliss as I pounded her. Looking lower, I could see her big tits bouncing around. God, she had great tits. But now wasn't the time for admiring them. Now was the time for fucking.

It did feel good being inside my sister. I knew it was wrong, but it felt so right. She loved me, I loved her, and we were expressing our love the way God intended. With this angle, Kaitlyn didn't bounce off the bed as much, but the bed sure did shake and squeak. Every stroke filled me with pleasure. Every stroke made Kaitlyn moan loudly.

"This can't be wrong," said Kaitlyn.

"This isn't wrong."

"I'm yours, Brandon. Take me."

Kaitlyn lifted her legs higher and again I was fucking her straight down. I loved the feeling of bouncing her off the bed. I felt so damn powerful. I slammed Kaitlyn over and over, and then I felt my balls tingle. I was going to cum in my sister again. She was mine, and I was going to fill her pussy to show that she was.

I started cumming. I pushed forward one more time, pinning Kaitlyn to the bed as I shot into her again and again. I was breathing hard as I finished pumping Kaitlyn full of my cum. We held that position with Kaitlyn's legs in the air as we caught our breath, and then Kaitlyn slowly lowered her legs.

"That was incredible," I said.

"It was. God, I wanted that."

I kissed Kaitlyn. "You're an amazing fuck."

"Thanks. And you're pretty awesome yourself."

I pulled out and collapsed on the bed next to Kaitlyn. I was still trying to catch my breath. Once I did, I asked, "Can we talk for a bit?"

"Sure. That was so quick, I don't think Joanna would mind if we talked for a while."

Kaitlyn and I rolled on to our sides, so we were facing each other. I said, "I love you."Kaitlyn kissed me. "I love you too."

"How will this work long-term?" I asked Kaitlyn this once already, she had dodged answering it, but I always kept coming back to it.

"Long-term, you and Joanna will be very happy together. You've been great for her, and I think she's been really good for you. You two have gotten along far, far better than I had dreamed when I first suggested you date her. I love the idea of you two marrying someday."

"Okay. But it's way too early to talk about marriage."

"I know you're not into thinking about the future much. Joanna is, and I'm even more than Joanna is. We've talked about you two getting married, buying a house, how long she wants to teach before you start a family, and her being a stay-at-home mom once you have kids." Joanna was going to be an elementary school teacher. "I'm not trying to press you into committing to anything, I'm just trying to give you an idea of how committed I am to you and Joanna being a happy couple long-term and also to let you know the kind of conversations Joanna and I have. Anyway, I've been enjoying living with you and Joanna. I'll like to do things with either of you and with both of you. And I like working with Joanna to strengthen her relationship with you."

I furrowed my brow. "You haven't had to do anything because Joanna and I have gotten along great."

Kaitlyn rolled her eyes. "You're such an idiot at times," she said patronizingly. "The first week we moved in, Joanna prepared a calendar for the week and posted it on the refrigerator. She knew she wouldn't be good at asking you to do things around the apartment, so her plan was she'd post weekly a calendar of when you were to do what chore, and you'd follow that. But you ignored the calendar and didn't do the first chore you had agreed to do when she had scheduled you to do it."

"What was the chore?"

"Clean your bathroom. She asked you to do it, you said you'd do it in a little bit after you got to a good stopping point in your game, and then you didn't do it. Joanna ended up cleaning the bathroom herself. She was really upset about it. She felt like you had broken your promise to do the chores you had agreed to in the first week of living with her."

I thought back to that day. It had happened like Kaitlyn said. I had thanked Joanna for cleaning the bathroom and hadn't thought any more about it. I hadn't noticed that Joanna was upset about anything.

"Since then, my job is to make sure you pay attention to the calendar and that you do the chores you've agreed to do in a way that's acceptable to Joanna." When it was time to clean the bathrooms, Kaitlyn has told me 'Time to clean the bathroom' and then has checked on how good of a job I've done after she was done cleaning her bathroom.

"Okay. I screwed that up. But I wasn't asking about what will happen with Joanna and me long-term. I was asking about what will happen with you and me long-term."

"You know what I've liked most about this summer?"

"No idea."

"I told you that at the lake house, I became obsessed with the idea of you being my boyfriend. It was a stupid idea for many reasons, one of which was that we'd have to commit to being boyfriend-girlfriend without any idea if it'd work. Even though we've gotten along great as siblings, we might have been awful as a romantic couple. What I've liked most about this summer is that I feel like it's been a dry run of us being boyfriend-girlfriend. There isn't much difference between how you treat Joanna and me until bedtime. And the two times Joanna has let us be together, you've treated me very much like a girlfriend. And I've really enjoyed that. We love each other, we've told each other that we love each other, and we're comfortable now with that we love each other and that we're sexually attracted to each other. I feel that if you had become my boyfriend, we would be a very happy couple now."

"But I didn't become your boyfriend. Joanna remained my girlfriend, and she still is."

Kaitlyn reached out and stroked my chest. "And she's what's important now. I know that isn't much of an answer, but it's the only one I have."

* * * *

By this time, we had made friends with some people in the apartment complex. Tuesday, we had a couple a few years older than us over for dinner. We had a good time. They had been living together for almost a year. When we told them about how we divided our household chores, she made some snipes about him not doing enough around the apartment. I felt like Joanna and I got along much better than they did. And Kaitlyn and I got along much better than they did. The whole time they were over, I kept telling myself, Don't act like you're in love with Kaitlyn. It was kind of eye-opening to me just how much I treated Kaitlyn like a girlfriend instead of like my sister.

Friday, we went to a party at an apartment in our complex. We knew some of the people and met quite a few we didn't know. Whenever I looked over at Kaitlyn, at least two guys were in the group she was in. The guys changed regularly through the evening. It was a struggle all evening to not go over to wherever Kaitlyn was and try to drive off the guys she was talking to.

Over the week, I continued to have the feeling that I was falling more and more in love with both Joanna and Kaitlyn. I thought several times about Kaitlyn saying that I treated her like a girlfriend. I saw that now. And I saw that Joanna was fine with it. She didn't expect me to treat her differently than Kaitlyn. We were three equals, contributing equally and making decisions jointly. All three of us were comfortable living together.

The whole week, I kept wondering how this will work long-term. One night while Joanna and I were making dinner, I asked her, "Have you asked Kaitlyn whether she wants to live with us in the fall?"

"A couple of times," Joanna said as she continued to cook.

"What did she say?"

"It's too early to decide."

"What do you think of that?"

"I agree."

It upset me somewhat that she seemed to be taking this so lightly. "Why do you agree?"

Joanna stopped cooking and looked sharply at me. "It's a hard decision, okay? And a big one. Give it time."

Joanna went back to cooking. The way she had said that, it was like she had to make the hard decision, not Kaitlyn.

* * * *

Saturday night after dinner, Joanna said, "Wait on the couch," and then she and Kaitlyn went into Kaitlyn's bedroom. I sat on the couch wondering what would happen tonight. Why the couch tonight? How would they alternate while I was on the couch?

Joanna and Kaitlyn came out of the bedroom wearing short black skirts and fitted white dress shirts. The shirts were tied off below their tits, exposing their midriffs. They looked like two dancers from Britney Spears' "Baby One More Time" video. In fact, Joanna started some music on her phone and "Baby One More Time" came through the speakers of our stereo. Joanna moved in front of me and danced sexily while singing to the song. She stood over me and shook her chest, and it was obvious she wasn't wearing a bra. She danced like that until she sang "Hit me baby one more time," and then she jumped out of the way and Kaitlyn moved in front of me.

Kaitlyn danced sexily in front of me, and she too obviously wasn't wearing a bra. She danced until the chorus, when she switched with Joanna. The girls alternated dancing sexily in front of me. Eventually, Joanna pulled up her skirt to reveal thong panties. Kaitlyn upped things even more by straddling me and shimmying her chest right in front of me. When Kaitlyn climbed off me, Joanna climbed on me. She rubbed her crotch against mine. Kaitlyn said, "Keep your hands by your side." The girls kept taking turns. After a while, they had me stand up, stripped me naked and had me sit back down on the couch again. Both girls took off their panties and "danced" with their bare pussy pressed against my cock. When Joanna was on top of me, she untied her shirt to reveal her tits. She shook those to the music as she rocked her pussy on my cock. Kaitlyn disappeared for a little bit before returning with a beach towel which she spread out on the couch next to me. I guessed I'd fuck Kaitlyn on the couch tonight before joining Joanna in our bedroom. Joanna hopped off me and Kaitlyn climbed on. She untied her shirt and rubbed her tits against me as she swayed to the music. I saw behind her Joanna take off her shirt. When Kaitlyn hopped off, Joanna had me move over to the center of the towel. To my surprise, Kaitlyn walked off.

Joanna straddled me. "Use your hands now," she said. I slipped my hands under her skirt and gripped her ass in my hands. Her pussy was pressed against my cock. I helped her slide her pussy up and down my cock a few times. "Are you ready to fuck your naughty girl?" she asked. She didn't wait for an answer and instead impaled herself on my cock. We fucked like that for a while, and then I pulled her off me and flipped her, so she was lying over the armrest of the couch. I fucked her doggie-style there.

"This reminds me of the lake house," I said. "That was such a great fuck. It was my favorite fuck of the whole week."

Joanna was meeting my every thrust. "Yeah, that was so naughty. I love being naughty."

A few more thrusts, and I was cumming into Joanna. When I finally pulled out, Joanna said, "Wipe yourself and then go to Kaitlyn. You're sleeping with her tonight."

"I am?" It was somewhat obvious that that was the plan, but I was surprised that Joanna would agree to me spending the night with my sister. It had seemed very important to Joanna that I sleep with her after having had sex with Kaitlyn.

"Yes. Kaitlyn asked nicely if you could sleep with her, so I said yes." Joanna kissed me. "Now go make her happy."

* * * *

Monday after dinner, Kaitlyn said, "I need to have a serious talk with Joanna. Would you mind going to the pool for a while?"

This sounded ominous to me. I looked at Joanna and she said, "Go. I think I know what Kaitlyn wants to discuss."

I hung out at the pool until I got a text from Joanna asking me to come back. When I did, Joanna and Kaitlyn were sitting at the dining table. Both looked serious, but neither looked angry. I sat down at the table.

Kaitlyn turned to Joanna. "How do you want to handle this?"

"You had a good sales pitch for your proposal. Give it to Brandon."

Kaitlyn turned to me. "You and Joanna have asked whether I want to live with the two of you this fall. I've loved living with both of you. I love you both so much." She gestured toward Joanna. "I greatly appreciate Joanna sharing you with me." Kaitlyn brought her hands back in front of her. "But I don't want it to be like this in the fall. I don't want it to be only once a week with you. I don't want to be the girl on the side. If I'm going to live with you two this fall, I want it to be with Joanna and me sharing you equally, and you being equally committed to us."

"Kaitlyn..."

"Let her finish," said Joanna.

Kaitlyn looked at Joanna gratefully. "I want to be able to build my life around you as much as Joanna does." Kaitlyn raised her hand and faced me. "I know this sounds crazy to you. Let me say first that my dreams are the same as Joanna's dreams. I want you two to get married. I want the three of us to buy a house around the time that Joanna wants to buy a house. I want you and Joanna to start a family around the time that she wants to start a family."

I decided to double-check that. "Are those your dreams, Joanna?"

"Yes."

Kaitlyn continued. "But not only are our dreams the same, they depend on both of us contributing to making them happen. You and Joanna won't make enough to buy the kind of house Joanna wants when she wants it. But the three of us can. When you and Joanna start a family, you'll struggle to live on just your salary. But it wouldn't be bad if our family was living off of your and my salaries. I haven't talked to you about my dreams, but I'm very ambitious about my career. But I don't want the loneliness of the single, ambitious young professional life. I want to be able to come home after a long day and talk to you and Joanna about it. I want home-cooked meals, even if I work late. I don't have to worry that this is my night to cook dinner when my boss suddenly drops a big project on me. I want to be able to take long business trips and not have my guy get frustrated about sleeping alone. I may not have kids, or I'll at least wait until my forties as having children sets a woman's career back so much, but I want to be involved in raising children earlier than that. I'd be thrilled to help raise a little niece and nephew, but not have the main responsibility for raising them. So I'm proposing that you and Joanna make me an equal to Joanna. In return, I'll give you two my full financial support, which will enable you and Joanna to live the life you want to live." Kaitlyn looked at Joanna. "Did I cover everything?"

"You didn't say how this would work."

"True." Kaitlyn turned back to me. "This summer would continue as it has been, with us having fun together on Friday or Saturday night, and you then sleeping with me. Once we move into our new apartment at college, we'll start sharing you equally. You'll spend two nights with me and then two nights with Joanna. Breakfast would mark the transition from one of us being your girl to the other. When it's my turn, you treat me like you treat Joanna. You can still hug, kiss and say 'I love you' to Joanna, but only short displays of affection. And when it's Joanna's turn, vice versa. Whenever we go out, regardless of who you're sleeping with, Joanna is your girlfriend, and we're very public about it. Let's say we're going out to dinner and a movie on my night. You and I would pick the restaurant and the movie. When we walk out the door, you're with Joanna until we walk back in the door, and then you're with me. We'll have some practice runs this summer to work out the details. I don't want to rush into the sharing, and I want all of us to work out as many of the kinks as possible before we start. At the same time, starting to share when our schedules all change because of school makes a lot of sense to me." Kaitlyn looked again at Joanna. "Anything else?"

"I think that's it."

I asked, "What if Joanna and I don't agree to your proposal?"

"I don't know. Maybe we'll continue on as we have, and I'll bring it up again later? Maybe I'll share an apartment with you in the fall, but I'd look for a boyfriend? Maybe I'll plan to live on my own in the fall? Depends on how you react to the proposal." Kaitlyn reached out and took my hand. "Remember the last time you asked me how you and I were going to work long-term? You knew then that what we're doing now won't continue to work. The only thing I think will work long-term is for Joanna and me to share you equally, and for you to be equally committed to each of us."

Joanna said to Kaitlyn, "I think it's best if you let Brandon and I discuss your proposal alone."

Kaitlyn released my hand and stood up. "Okay. I'll go for a walk around the apartment complex."

Joanna and I were quiet as we watched Kaitlyn leave the apartment. Once she was gone, I said, "Well, that was a bomb." I shook my head. "What did Kaitlyn say to you while I was at the pool?"

"Pretty much the same thing she just told you. She wanted to make sure I was open to what she was going to propose before she pitched it to you. She thought it was early to make the proposal, but she would like to lock up an apartment for the Fall soon. So we discussed if she should make her proposal now or wait a week or two."

"So you were okay with Kaitlyn suggesting you share me equally with her?"

"Let's go sit down on the couch."

Joanna and I got up and went over to the couch. When we sat down there, my arm automatically went over her shoulder. Joanna was quiet for a bit. "I love you, Brandon. You're the one I want to be with, and I want to be with you forever." I felt like this was a preamble for bad news. "There's something I need to tell you. I've been thinking about not telling you, but things won't make sense unless I tell you." I wondered what could be this bad. "When we were at the lake house, Kaitlyn talked me into dumping you for Paul so she could have you as her boyfriend."

"What?" I asked in shock. I took my arm from Joanna's shoulders.

"This was when I thought you were only dating me for the summer. I would date Paul through the summer and into the fall. At the time, I didn't feel like I was good enough to be your girlfriend long-term. I felt that Paul was more my level. And Kaitlyn had been my best friend for years, so I was far more loyal to her than to you. I had encouraged her for years to want you, so I couldn't deny her when she asked to swap boyfriends."

"But you didn't."

"We were supposed to swap during nap time on Thursday, but right after lunch she broke up with Paul instead. And I'm very glad she did."

"Hold it. How was this supposed to work? During nap time, you were going to tell me that you preferred Paul to me, so I should date Kaitlyn instead? When were you going to get Paul to agree to this?"

Joanna sighed. "Paul always went straight to the hammock when we went downstairs at nap time. Kaitlyn would keep you in the mud room. I'd go to Paul and tell him that Kaitlyn was breaking up with him. I'd suck his cock and tell him he was my boyfriend now. And then I'd return to the mud room. I'd tell you and Kaitlyn what I had done, and Kaitlyn would do to you what I described doing with Paul."

"So your cheating on me and then breaking up with me was supposed to put me in the mood to have Kaitlyn as my girlfriend? What if I didn't want to have anything to do with either of you after that?"

"It was a really bad plan. Kaitlyn was so crazy about you that she wasn't thinking straight. The rest of her plan was for you and I to continue to date in public as well as her and Paul, but secretly she and you would be a couple, and Paul and I would be a couple. And then at some point, I'd publicly break up with you and start dating Paul. I don't know what you and Kaitlyn were supposed to do publicly. But then it turns out that Kaitlyn knew I wouldn't like dating Paul because of his gaming addiction, so maybe I was supposed to break up with him privately and Kaitlyn would break up with him publicly? And I don't know how Kaitlyn was going to keep Paul from telling everyone that she and you were having sex. It was a really awful plan."

"It was." I stood up and crossed my arms. "I can't believe you'd agree to cheat on me and dump me for that loser."

"I knew you'd react this way if I ever told you about what I agreed to do. I'm only telling you this because I think you need to know for what I'm going to tell you next. Please sit down."

I stood there for a while and glared at Joanna. I couldn't believe she'd agree to betray me like that. But eventually, I sat back down on the couch, crossing my arms again.

"The reason I told you about Kaitlyn's plan for us to switch boyfriends was that I confronted her the Monday after we got back during our drive to work about not warning me that Paul was addicted to his game. She had built Paul up as the perfect guy for me, and I was pissed she had left out that detail. And she told me she would have taken care of me, and her plan was once I broke up with Paul, she'd share you equally with me. She added that she needed me to be your girlfriend to cover up the fact that she was involved with you. She'd go out to dinner and movies with you, but as a tag-along with you and me. I didn't think too much of it at the time. It was all kind of bizarre, and I felt like it was Kaitlyn trying to smooth things over with me. But after I shared you with her the first time, she started talking to me about my dreams, and I realized her plan was still to share you equally with me, but just how it came about would be different. She'd convince me that sharing you equally with her was the best way to achieve my dreams." Joanna wrung her hands. "I'm sorry I agreed to Kaitlyn's plan. I can't tell you how happy I am that she broke up with Paul instead of asking me to go through with it. I thought you'd be happier with Kaitlyn than me. Would you please forgive me?"

let out a big breath. Joanna hadn't actually cheated on me. It had been Kaitlyn's plan, not hers. She thought by following Kaitlyn's plan, she'd make me happier. She had chosen to tell me this because she thought it was important for me to know. "Yes, I forgive you."

Joanna reached out, took my hand and pulled it between us. She looked at me with puppy dog eyes. I couldn't continue with my anger. I smiled at her and squeezed her hand.

"Back to Kaitlyn," Joanna said. "I think that's why she pushed so hard to have the three of us live together this summer. She saw it as her chance to convince both of us to include her fully into our relationship. And since we have started living together, she has tried to make herself integral to you and me happily living together. We've split the work up three ways, with me doing only what I want to do. She's taken on the role of reminding you to do the chores you've agreed to, knowing that's something I'd have a tough time doing. And her contributing to the apartment expense has made living together affordable for you and me."

"But she didn't convince you to share me equally with you, did she?"

Joanna raised her hands in a what-can-I-say gesture. "She did. She knows my weaknesses. She knows living in a house is hugely important to me. Living in an apartment is how I define being poor, and I don't want to live poor once I start working. I know how much I'll make as an elementary school teacher, I've run the numbers, and it'd take you having a great-paying job for us to be able to buy a house within a few years of my starting teaching. But it'd be easy for all three of us to buy a house a couple of years after I start teaching. I really want to be a stay-at-home mom like your mom, and again, it'd be very hard to do without Kaitlyn but relatively easy to do with her. I don't want to have to wait until I'm in my late thirties to buy a house and start a family. Children are very important to me. And most importantly, Kaitlyn has spent the time we've lived together showing she can make sharing you work at the once-a-week level, so I'm not fearful about going to equally sharing." Joanna took my hand again. "So what do you think about Kaitlyn's proposal?"

I had assumed Joanna would say no, so I'd say no. But Joanna was a yes, so was I a yes? "I don't know, Joanna. Finding out Kaitlyn talked you into cheating on me and dumping me for Paul doesn't make it any easier. She's manipulating us, and I hate being manipulated."

"She's not manipulating us. She's putting her cards on the table. She's trying to persuade us with facts. I trust she'll do everything in her power to make my dreams come true. I feel much more confident that my dreams will come true if I share you with Kaitlyn than if I don't. I very much want to live my life with you, but I also want to live my life with Kaitlyn. We're so close, I want to continue this closeness, and I think we will under Kaitlyn's proposal. So I want to share you with Kaitlyn. You don't have to commit to doing it now, but at some point, you'll have to decide on it. What do you think?"

What did I think? I stopped for a moment to clear my head. I put away my anger over Kaitlyn talking Joanna into cheating on me and dumping me. I put away my initial rejection of the idea as being too weird to work. Would I like to be shared by two beautiful, wonderful women that I loved and who loved me? Of course I would. I was very happy with where things were now, and I didn't like the risk of something new. Punting on the choice until later was appealing. But I thought about Joanna saying she wanted to live her life with both Kaitlyn and me. I wanted a life living with both Kaitlyn and Joanna. I didn't want Kaitlyn to return to being just my sister. And what we were doing now wasn't stable. I could see that only loving Joanna and Kaitlyn equally would work long-term.

"I think we should tell Kaitlyn that we accept her proposal."

* * * *

It was the Saturday before school started, and it had been a stressful day moving all our stuff into our new apartment, but there had been an excitement all day about how we would celebrate being in our new home. As always, Kaitlyn and Joanna had given me only small hints about what they had planned for fun time. And they hadn't given me any idea as to who I was sleeping with tonight. We had ordered pizza delivery for dinner and had eaten as we put things away. Once the pizza was gone, the girls had retreated to Kaitlyn's bedroom. I sat on the couch and waited for them to come out.

I heard the door open, and I looked up to see Kaitlyn and Joanna walk out. They were identically dressed, wearing high heels, stockings, a garter belt and a smile. Kaitlyn's stockings and garter belt were a royal blue whereas Joanna's were a bright orange that looked better on her darker skin. Kaitlyn had her hair braided like the first time we had made love - a crown on the front and sides, and a waterfall in the back - but this time with royal blue and orange silk ribbons in her hair. Joanna's hair was braided in a simple crown, the first time she had had it braided since we had started dating, and she also had royal blue and orange silk ribbons in her hair.

I looked over Kaitlyn and Joanna, savoring their beauty. "You two look so beautiful. I'm the luckiest guy in the world."

Kaitlyn said, "You are," and both girls laughed.

"You two look good enough to eat."

"Promises, promises," said Kaitlyn.

Joanna laughed and added, "You're overdressed," and started pulling down my shorts. Kaitlyn started pulling up my shirt.

I laughed. "I am."

Once the girls got me naked, they pulled me over toward the couch. They were sitting on it, and I was standing between them.

Joanna said, "We're going to try something new."

Kaitlyn eased my cock into her mouth, taking about half my soft length in.

I asked Joanna, "Something naughty?"

Joanna smiled while Kaitlyn slowly pulled her head backward, running her marvelous lips down my cock until it was freed from her mouth. "Something very naughty," Joanna said before moving her head toward my rapidly hardening cock. To my surprise, Kaitlyn guided my cock into Joanna's mouth. This was the first time they had alternated while giving head.

Kaitlyn said, "I know we spent the last few weeks working out the rules for when we started sharing equally, but we're going to change some of the rules." The rule that the girl I wasn't going to sleep with had minimal physical contact with me was clearly out the window for at least tonight.

Kaitlyn watched Joanna suck my cock, and when it came clear of Joanna's mouth, Joanna held it out for Kaitlyn. Kaitlyn paused for a moment.

Joanna said to me, "There's a natural revulsion to taking someone's saliva into your mouth. We hadn't realized that when we discussed doing this." She turned to Kaitlyn. "It wasn't that bad once I got him in my mouth."

Kaitlyn looked at Joanna for encouragement, and then to my cock. She opened her mouth wide and took my cock in. Once my cock was fully in her mouth, I said, "You two are amazing."

Joanna smirked. "And naughty."

In the last three weeks, we had done several dry runs of the girls sharing me equally, so I thought I knew what to expect tonight. But I should have expected Joanna to come up with a curve ball.

I asked, "So what are the rule changes?"

Kaitlyn pushed my cock into Joanna's mouth. She said, "We haven't completely decided. But we have decided to surprise you with them." Her eyes twinkled.

One of the things I had learned to accept was that the girls were in charge. They had to deal with the natural jealousy that should tear any sharing relationship apart. It was pretty damn easy for me to be with whoever I was assigned to at the moment.

The girls alternated sucking my cock, taking it deeper and deeper into their mouths each time. They grew more comfortable with going after each other and soon developed a pretty good rhythm. Finally, I said, "I'm wanting to cum someplace besides a mouth."

Joanna smirked. "Are you saying you want to fuck someone?"

"Hell yeah. I haven't fucked anyone in days." The girls had wanted tonight to be special, so they had cut me off for the last few days.

The girls stood up, Joanna grabbed my cock and led me toward her bedroom while Kaitlyn followed along behind. When I got to the bedroom, the covers were pulled back on the bed and a beach towel was lying in the center. I had never fucked Joanna or Kaitlyn in front of the other - I had always gone with one of them into their bedroom and closed the door - so this was definitely a rule change. I wondered how things would play out.

As we got to the bed, Kaitlyn asked Joanna, "Do you want me to go first?"

"No. I've got something special I'm looking forward to trying." Joanna moved into the center of the bed and opened her legs. "You said I looked good enough to eat."

I climbed on the bed. "And you still do."

I moved into position and took my first lick of Joanna's pussy. I then felt Kaitlyn's hand on my back. As she rubbed it, Kaitlyn said, "Give my best friend a good licking." 'My best friend' had become Joanna and Kaitlyn's favorite way of referring to each other whenever it involved sex.

I went to town on Joanna's pussy. She was wetter and more responsive than our usual nights in bed, but not as wet and responsive as on our usual fun nights. But I wasn't complaining about what we had done for our warm-up. As I licked on Joanna's pussy, Kaitlyn stroked my back and made the occasional encouragement. It was an odd feeling, having Kaitlyn rooting me on to make Joanna cum.

And then Joanna was cumming. As always, she came quietly. When I moved my head away from her pussy. My face was coated with her juices, so I wiped it on the towel. I moved to fuck her in the missionary position. If Joanna wanted another position, now was when she'd let me know. She didn't say anything, but instead rotated her hips back and brought her legs up so they rested on my shoulders. She said, "I thought I'd try a new position for our first fuck in our new apartment."

I said, "You're such a naughty girl." Joanna smirked. "I've never had sex like this before." Joanna laughed silently. "And you're beautiful. I like your hair braided like that."

Joanna looked down bashfully. "Thanks."

I guided my cock to Joanna's pussy, and I was in her. I started fucking her slowly. Having her legs on my shoulders meant I was fucking her at an unusual angle. Fucking in this position wasn't very different from fucking in the missionary position, but it was different enough to be fun.

I saw some movement and looked over to see Kaitlyn take Joanna's hand. I looked at Kaitlyn; and she gave me a smile, letting me know she approved of me fucking her best friend.

Joanna looked over at Kaitlyn and said, "Cum with us."

Kaitlyn shifted position so she could spread her legs wide comfortably. Soon she was rubbing her pussy with her right hand as she held Joanna's hand with her left. Once she started that, I looked back at Joanna, and she gave me a smile.

I said to Joanna, "I love you." As I had allowed my love for Kaitlyn to grow unconstrained, I felt like I loved Joanna even more. I definitely didn't have a fixed amount of love. If anything, the more I loved, the more love I had to give.

I was really getting into fucking Joanna now. I definitely liked this angle, the way I towered over Joanna which made me feel more physically dominating than in missionary. Joanna and I were panting now in time to the sound of the bed rocking. Kaitlyn was moaning lightly as she jilled herself. Joanna looked up at me and said, "A little sound...pant...track for...pant...our fuck."

I chuckled lightly and replied, "You're so naughty."

I could tell Joanna was getting turned on by having me fuck her while Kaitlyn masturbated next to us. I adjusted our rhythm to match Kaitlyn's moans. I said, "I love fucking you," while continuing to steadily thrust in and out of her. I did love fucking Joanna. I loved her creative and adventurous nature. Sex would never be boring with her.

Joanna said, "I can't hold this anymore," and moved her legs down from my shoulders. I stopped for a moment, so she could shift into the missionary position. Once she did, she asked me, "Or would you prefer doggie-style?"

Ever since I had fucked Joanna over the arm of the couch at the lake house, doggie-style was my favorite position. "Yeah."

I pulled back, slid out of Joanna, and grabbed her waist. With her help, I flipped her over onto her hands and knees. She raised her ass up high for me to mount her and then suddenly reached out to grab Kaitlyn's hand. Kaitlyn continued jilling herself, her moans getting steadily louder.

I slid my cock all the way into Joanna's sopping pussy. I grabbed her waist and started hammering her.

Joanna turned back to look at me, and said, "Cum with Kaitlyn."

I had been getting close to cumming, but I could tell from Kaitlyn's moans that she was a few minutes away. I slowed my assault on Joanna and began doing times tables in my head to distract me. It wasn't much of a distraction - I loved the feeling of Joanna's slick pussy as it grasped my cock while I slid in and out of her; I loved holding her wonderful body and looking at her great legs.

I varied my pace, sometimes going slow and sometimes pounding Joanna. The variety kept up my enjoyment while distracting me enough that I kept my orgasm slightly distant. I listened to Kaitlyn while staring at Joanna's smooth, well-toned back.

I heard Kaitlyn's moans reach a crescendo. I grabbed Joanna firmly and hammered her hard until I went over the edge. My first spurt shot into Joanna as I heard Kaitlyn make the gasp she did when she was cumming. I steadily filled Joanna with my cum as Kaitlyn came while holding hands with Joanna.

When I finished, I pulled out of Joanna and lay down between her and Kaitlyn. Our first threesome fuck had been awesome, both physically and emotionally satisfying. I felt drained but also on cloud nine. I couldn't picture it getting better than this.

I lifted myself up, looked to my left and right and saw that both girls were lying on their backs. I got on my hands and knees and bent over Joanna to give her a soft kiss before moving over to Kaitlyn to give her the same. I alternated kissing the girls, enjoying the subtle differences between their lips and kissing technique.

Joanna said, "Lie on your back." She gave me a wicked little grin, so I knew she had something fun in mind. I lay down, wondering what she had planned.

Joanna got on her hands and knees and moved so her chest was over mine. She gave me her mischievous grin before lowering herself, so her nipples lightly touched my chest. A thrill shot through me. Joanna slowly dragged her nipples about a foot down my chest. Her nipples moving across me like that felt incredibly erotic, and I let out a long sigh while she did it. Joanna sat up and gave me her I'm-so-naughty look before saying to Kaitlyn, "Your turn."

Kaitlyn moved to dangle her tits over my chest, and, as she did so, I admired her awesome tits. They looked even bigger as she dangled them. She slowly lowered herself until her nipples touched me, and another thrill shot through me. Kaitlyn looked up at me and gave me a sexy smile. She dragged her nipples lightly over my chest, which felt even better than when Joanna had done it. She backed away for Joanna to go next.

Joanna moved her tits over my chest again, but this time starting low on my chest. She dragged them upward until she reached almost the top of my pecs where she lifted them off my chest. Instead of sitting up, she continued upwards until a nipple was right over my mouth. She slowly lowered herself as I opened my mouth wide. Once her tit was well within my mouth, I grabbed it with my lips and sucked on it. She let me suck on it for a few seconds before sitting down next to me.

As soon as Joanna sat down, Kaitlyn moved to dangle her tits over my chest. While she was doing so, Joanna grasped my now-firming cock. As Kaitlyn dragged her nipples up my chest, Joanna stroked my cock. Jesus, did that feel great! Kaitlyn moved upwards and dangled her tit over my mouth. I again opened my mouth wide. She lowered her tit into my mouth, but when I went to suck on it, she pulled it out of my mouth and chuckled. She dragged her nipple along my lips until I opened my mouth again. The whole time she was doing this, Joanna was stroking my cock. I opened my mouth again, Kaitlyn lowered her tit into it, and this time she let me close my mouth on it. I sucked on her tit as Joanna's hand steadily slid up and down my cock. I had had vague ideas about what a threesome with Joanna and Kaitlyn would be like, but so far it had vastly exceeded my limited imagination.

Joanna said as she held my now stiff cock, "He's ready to fuck again."

I moved so Kaitlyn could lie down on her back in the center of the bed. She preferred the missionary position. She spread her legs and said, "Fuck me." The way she said it was incredibly sexy. My sister was such a sexy woman, and now I'd be making love to her often. We wouldn't be making love every day, but what couple did?

I moved into position, and as I did, Joanna grabbed my cock. "Let me help you two be naughty." She guided it to Kaitlyn's pussy. Joanna seemed to be enjoying watching me make love with Kaitlyn.

I pushed a little way in. I pulled back and pushed a little further in. "Like that, Brandon," Kaitlyn said lustily. She wrapped her legs around mine, pulling me deeper into her on the next thrust. "So good," Kaitlyn moaned. She was great at letting me know how much she enjoyed fucking me.

One more thrust and my full length was inside of Kaitlyn. Kaitlyn held me all the way in her with her legs. Her beautiful blue eyes looked deep into mine. She said, "Fuck me," and I felt her legs relax.

I did as Kaitlyn asked, starting slow. I hadn't fucked her for a week, so it felt good to be back inside her. Her pussy gripped my cock like a soft glove, making every inch that moved in her so pleasurable, not that her pussy felt so different from Joanna's. It was more her sexual presence, the way she could make the simplest thing sexy, that made fucking her so special.

I thrust into Kaitlyn and pulled back; I thrust and pulled back; her legs pulling me harder into her on every thrust.

A small movement drew my attention to Kaitlyn's hand, and I noticed Joanna was holding it. I looked at Joanna, and she smiled at me. She said, "Kaitlyn, I must be the best best-friend ever, since it makes me so happy to see my boyfriend fucking you."

Kaitlyn squeezed Joanna's hand. "You are the best best-friend ever. Are you going to be happy to watch Brandon fuck me when he's your husband?"

Joanna chuckled. "When he's my husband?"

"Oh, yes. He's going to marry you."

I stopped fucking Kaitlyn and shook my head. My manipulative sister was in action again.

Kaitlyn said, "I hope you don't mind if I continue to live with the two of you after you get married."

Joanna laughed. "I'd love for you to live with us after we get married. But Brandon..."

Kaitlyn looked at me, daring me to say something. When I didn't, she said, "Mom's hinted to me a couple of times she'd like you and Joanna to get married someday. I've wanted you two to get married since I saw how cute of a couple you two made. So give it up, you're outvoted."

I snickered. My manipulative sister was pushing things along again. Marriage hadn't crossed my mind. Then I realized that moving in with Joanna was my last big commitment to her, and I should do a new, bigger commitment so that Joanna won't fall into thinking my I-love-you's are just empty words. And I was ready to make a new, bigger commitment to her.

I said to Joanna, "Would you marry me?"