I drank my coffee in silence, at 36 I never imagined I'd be living at my in laws but life had a way of being a pain at times. My mother in law hated me, she seen me as the man that corrupted her sweet and innocent little girl but if she knew the truth she'd probably have a cow so I never did tell her it was her daughter that corrupted me!
I'd met Sophie at college, I was there part time to complete a course my employer needed me to have and Sophie was in her final year. We laugh about the old cliche on how we met, both needing the last copy of a book to study for a class and ended up sharing it, studying together and a year later we were married.
The fact that wedding was in Vegas, against her parents wishes and her being ten years younger than me really didn't fly with her ultra religious 'college is nice so you can converse intellectually when you're an at home mom like I was' mother and her preacher father.
We did have a great apartment together that was home while our house was being built but the downstairs neighbor left a frying pan on drunk off his ass after coming home late from a party and managed to burn the building down. We were all lucky to get out unharmed but having nothing and a good few months before the insurance check came through we had no choice but to move in with her parents.
"Good morning handsome, my folks awake yet?" Said Sophie, kissing me softly on the cheek.
"Not heard them, you sleep ok?" I replied.
"Uh, no, I'm back on my childhood bed without my sexy husband to ravage so not really."
Sophie quickly distanced herself from me and poured herself some coffee and smiled as her mom entered the kitchen.
"Morning Mom, want some coffee?" She said, getting another mug.
"I can manage thank you. Sophie, if you could please put a robe or something on, I can almost see your breasts with that nightgown." Replied her Mom.
"Yes Mom." Said Sophie and left to get her robe.
I attempted to say good morning but I was distracted trying to catch a glimpse of my wife's sexy ass as she left the room and by the time I looked round my mother in law had poured her coffee and was gone.
Sophie came back in her 'spinster robe' as she called it, kissed me on the cheek and whispered "I'm going to fuck your brains out when she leaves for the store" into my ear before sitting opposite me with a smile on her face.
I finished my coffee, showered and went back downstairs to see if we were alone when I heard voices from the kitchen, it sounded like an argument and someone was definitely crying.
"You see Mom, this is the wife of your perfect model husband you expected me to have, one of your own daughters married to a jerk who gets drunk and hits her, plays golf and goes to the bar every night but as long as he's there at church every Sunday he's okay. Stop defending him and blaming Claire and stop using her life to judge mine. Claire is upset and needs us Mom." Said Sophie, mostly shouting.
"You will not speak to me that way in my own home young lady, you'd be on the street if it wasn't for me remember." Said her mom.
"Mom, I'm sorry, I don't want to fight but look at your daughter, she has a black eye because she wouldn't cook steak instead of pork chops. I'm grateful you let Marcus and I stay a while I really am but please, Claire needs us."
I decided to hang back until the shouting had stopped and only went into the kitchen when her mom had left.
"Hi Claire, you okay?" I said.
Claire looked up at me, her face red from crying and a bruise over her left eye. Seeing it made me mad, Claire was a lot like my Sophie and only a year younger, beautiful, a very sweet nature and deserved way better than the asshole she'd married.
"I've seen better days." She said, wiping away more tears.
"Want me to go round with some guys and kick his ass this time?" I replied.
"No need, he's in the County Jail, I'm pressing charges, I've had enough."
Sophie and I chatted with her a while and when she wanted to rest, Sophie had me take Claire's bags up to her room. Claire hugged me close and said thanks then started to unpack.
A few weeks passed, Sophie spent a lot of time with her sister helping her through things, I mostly stayed out the way and helped Jan (mother in law) around the house with the cleaning and little jobs that Sophie had been doing.
I didn't expect to become her favorite son in law but I remained respectful and tried to show I was a good person. My father in law was a bit warmer towards me, he had been on a month long Missionary building a Church in Africa and was surprised to come home to both of his daughters back home, Claire had insisted Jan didn't tell him until he got back. I had also taken to getting my release in the shower, Sophie and I usually had sex at least 5 times a week so to go so long without was killing me.
One night though I got a surprise visitor and enjoyed every second of it. Sophie had sneaked into my room wearing only the spinster robe, dropped it on the floor and climbed into bed with me, straddling my legs.
After a quick stroke to get me hard she mounted me, taking me inside her and slowly rode me, whispering 'shhh' when I tried to talk. The room was pitch black so I couldn't see a thing but the familiar perfume of my wife filled my nose. She didn't last long, obviously as pent up as I was but when she leaned on me, gasping as her pussy tightened on my cock as orgasm flowed through her, I pushed up into her and came, gasping quietly in pleasure as I filled her pussy with my cum. Once we had both caught our breath she climbed off me, kissed me softly on the cheek then left me alone in the twin bed again.
I spent the next day at work grinning my face off, texting Sophie when I could and hoping for a repeat that night. I thanked my lucky stars when sure enough, Sophie sneaked in my room again that night and feeling I was already hard, just climbed onto my waiting cock and slowly rode me to our mutual orgasms. I even got it again later that day, Sophie cornered me in the laundry room and had me give her a quickie, fucking her from behind as she held on to the washing machine before scampering back upstairs when we'd both cum.
My nightly visits went on for about a week until one night, right after another very satisfying climax my phone went off, filling the usually pitch black room with light. Usually it would be off and in the drawer but being on call I had to leave it on and face up so I didn't miss a call. As I fumbled for it on the bedside table, still catching my breath, I looked up in the dim light to see the face of Claire and not my wife! I was in shock and the light clearly caught her by surprise too as she froze, pinning me to the bed with my cock still inside her. She held a finger to her lips as I answered the phone.
"This is Marcus. Sure, start unplugging the other server and I'll be there as fast as I can." I said to my customer and hung up.
Claire leaned forward, kissed me on the cheek and whispered "Sophie knows, don't spoil this" then was gone before I could turn on the lamp.
Thankfully the job I was called out for didn't take too long and I was back in bed asleep at 5am with a note left on the table that I had been called out, a system Sophie and I used to politely say 'please be quiet' and I was grateful the in laws obliged. Sophie woke me around 10am with a cup of coffee.
"Folks have taken Claire out shopping, morning sleepyhead." She said, kissing me on my forehead.
"Morning." I replied, not sure if I was about to be screamed at or not.
"I can tell by that look on your face you have questions, now isn't the time, we have an hour tops before they get home and I want my husband in me."
I didn't argue or complain, Sophie bent over at the bottom of the bed and I took her from behind, shuddering to an enjoyable climax as I sprayed her insides with my seed. She stood up and held me close as we caught our breath.
"I sent your nightly visitor, it was me the second night but the rest have been Claire. I want her to have a real man to enjoy and it's making her really happy. Please tell me you're not mad at me." She said looking up at me.
"Mad at you? I was expecting you to be mad at me. I didn't know, she never said a word and had I not been paged I still wouldn't have known, you two are impossible to tell apart in the dark, hard enough during the day at times." I replied, relieved I got to keep my balls.
"I have a hard time keeping up with you baby, I will never turn you down but you do wear me out sometimes, I thought it would be fun sharing you for a while. Play along like you don't know okay, I love you." She said then disappeared from the room.
Things went on the same for a good few weeks, I would never know if it was Claire or my wife that was visiting me but I played along as asked and enjoyed being ridden.
I got a call on a Saturday and decided to surprise Sophie and after running a few errands, asked her to join me in the kitchen.
"Oooh, a present, I like surprises." Squealed Sophie, opening the small box on the table. Claire stood behind her.
"Are these... are these our house keys?" She asked, her excitement rising.
"Yes, the architect is meeting us there in an hour, he's happy and wants us to do the final walk through." I replied.
I watched a slow look of sadness crawl over Claire's face but I had a plan to change that.
"Claire, want to get out the house for a while?" I asked her.
"Yea, sure, nothing better to do I suppose. I'll go get ready." She replied, trying to appear excited.
When she left I held Sophie close to me, she had a grin on her face and was still playing with the keys like they were the first she'd ever seen.
"So, I have a proposition to run by you, we have a 4 bedroom house, plenty of room for my office and I just thought..." I said, interrupted by her kiss.
"Horny man, I know what you're thinking, I'm sure Claire would love to come live with us." She replied with a smile.
The walk through went well, the architect showed us the features the builder had added and was proud of his work. He had us sign a few more papers then left us alone to explore. We all ended up in the lounge.
"What do you think Sis, like it?" Said Sophie.
"It's real nice, kinda big for just the two of you is it not?" Replied Claire.
"Well, now that you mention it, we said that too. We know you had been looking at apartments but we both want you to come and live with us. You can chose between the 3 rooms and if you want we can go bed shopping for you tonight. Marcus obviously agrees you'd be welcome and our nightly arrangement will only need changing a little." Continued Sophie.
Claire got a little red but looked at me smiling.
"I would love to, thank you so much." Said Claire, pulling us together for a group hug.
Once we were all moved in, my Mother in law took me aside and spoke to me after we'd given her the tour of our house.
"I should thank you for taking Claire in too, I love my daughters but they're a little too wild when they're together. I am not too proud to admit I was wrong about you, I can see how happy you've made both of them and that's all I can ask for." She said, I was a little stunned.
"Thank you, all I've ever wanted is to keep Sophie happy." I replied.
Oh if only she knew...